Interviews

UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 14 Jan 2025 (Delhi)

14 Jan 2025

Name: Ashtray

Date: Afternoon, 14.01.2025

Board: Lt. Gen Shukla Sir

Duration: 28 Mins

Keywords: IRS (IT), SRCC, DSE, Economics, Cooking, Women rights, Hyderabad.

Chairman:

What is the most attractive thing about Hyderabad?

Have you tried Lucknow's Biryani, Which one is better, Hydi or Lucknavi?

What else is attractive in Hyderabad?

There is neither ganga nor yamuna in Hyderabad, why do you say that there is ganga-jamuna tehzeeb?

Is Hyderabad cosmopolitan or it has a hybrid culture?

Why Dosa has become famous as a breakfast Item Internationally, and not paratha?

What is so special of south Indian breakfast, is it just because its healthy or is there something else?

Are you familiar with Delhi, been to CP? Madras coffee house? Any resturants you know near MCH?

Why do you think there are so many south Indian restaurants in CP, and whenever I visit, they are always packed. What could be the reason?

How many varieties of Dosa are there?

In Madras - chennai, People are not having dosa but paneer and soya chap, Why is south Indian food not so desired in south India?

Enough of Cuisine, lets move to Geopolitics. According to you, India should be a continental power or maritime power?

Do you think India is a maritime super power? Why not?

In Ancient India we had good navy, why doesn't modern India wants to improve its naval power and ship building?

Is China continental or Maritime power? Why there is huge ship building in China?

Is US continental or Maritime power?

Why are china and US investing a lot in its navy, unlike India?

Do you think India shall prioritize navy over land based defence??

Member 1:

Asked in Hindi- What do you mean by Urban Under employment, and why is it happening in cities? (Asked me to answer in any language in which I'm comfortable)

An engineer appearing for Police constable exam, is it under Employement?

A doctor appearing for CSE, is it under Employement?

Why do we lack entrepreneurship Spirit in India?

Is family the starting point to inculcate entrepreneurship Spirit?

What can we do to encourage it?

Member 2:

How did you get the internship (Media and PR) at AP government?

Why did they gave you the excellence award?

What was your role? How did you get the contacts? Explain the mechanism through which you did your work?

What is AP janmabhoomi initiative?

Why do you write on Women rights?

Do you say that Hindu women enjoy more safeguards, opportunities and rights on a legal basis in India?

Aren't you restricting yourself by just writing about muslim women?

On what topics have you written blogs on women? (Marital rape, Menstrual leave, Monetization of care economy)

Do you think there is more gender equity among hindus than muslims?

Member 3:

I think you are lost. You should have continued a career in Economics. I discourage you because you are over qualified for IAS. What is your opinion?

An economist is more worthy, and can have a larger impact than a civil servant who has very less autonomy and discretion. Isn't?

Why don't you inspire to be Dr. Manmohan singh? Or follow the path of your alumnus from DSE?

I believe you are looking for power and prestige here. Isn't?

You are either confused, or have made an irrational decision. You are an example of under employment!!

Member 4:

What is the controversy around Places of worship act?

Do you think the Act should be repealed?

Can we have social harmony at the cost of people's faith?

Do you think courts shall be encouraged in deciding the religious character of a place?

Tell me the Constitutional background of women rights - articles?

What is the Article that talks about Maternity Leave?

How can you use your economics in service?

As an IAS? Not as an IRS.

What Practical knowledge of economics can you apply on farmers?

Tell me how you will use the Equi marginal utility principal of micro economics on a farmer?

Any other theory which you can directly apply from economics in practical world?

Chairman Again:

You were talking about gender equity. Do you really think hindu society is more egalitarian than muslim society in India?

Tell me the practices/laws regarding hindus, which you think are egalitarian?

Do you think laws are being enforced as practices in hindu society?

What do you know about sthridhan?

Practices or laws which are more powerful?

Where does the problem lie in Muslim society?

Is this the condition of muslim society everywhere or just in India?

We need to change the practices, what could be the starting point?

Finally, I want your opinion again. Do you still think Muslim society is less egalitarian than hindu society?

Thank you!

Mocks: Gave only two mocks. Final Interview was more like an Interaction. Nothing asked from current affairs!

1. Name () - Zander

2. Date and Session of Interview - AN, 7 Jan..second to go

3. Board's Chairman - Dr. DINESH DASA sir

4. DAF Keywords - kushinagar, uttar Pradesh, NIT Warangal, Mechanical, optional- Mathematics, fuel efficiency, cricket, Leadership, TMKOC (nothing asked on above)

Assistant Section Officer, Education Ministry

5. Your interview transcript -

Chairman: Greeted and asked How are you feeling

Why Now ASO through Cgl whereas earlier directly SO through UPSC...reason

As Dopt secretary, which two service will you include in UPSC....said AIJS and AIHS

NEP based on which two committee...

Subramaniam Committee asked for All India Education Service, whats your take on it

What do you believe should we have stable or unstable Pakistan and why

Member 1:

Bangladesh happening....dont you think india failed at intelligence to predict it.....whats the way forward....long discussion on it...

Chairman: Dont you think we can't hold election.....long monologue and then discussion on it....even sir putting lot of pressure in that discussion

Member 1:

India and Pakistan continued further....few more aspects

Member 2:

India Bangladesh lit bit discussed again

As a ASO working, what weaknesses do you see in the administration there

Discussion bit on my answer....good member to talk

Member 3: (lady)

Bits and few question regarding ASO as first point of entry....LDC and UDC whether now selected...is there still prevalent in any Ministry

Then What do you think whether we should be ready for war....answered it...maam told to elaborate......was giving answer....in between chairman sir told that ok....move to next member

Member 4

Do you know about renewable energy

Which RE contributing most in India energy mix

What are the challenges of Solar energy

What technology is there to store the solar energy ( said not able to recall)....sir asked because you are mechanical engineering

Chairman was eager to end the discussion...stopped the member...and suddenly said you interview is over

I greeted once again by saying thank you and left.

Utility of Mocks Interview - Samkalp ( to have a feel of real environment), Next IAS....all for confidence ......

Utility of One to One -one to one with Dharmadhikari sir, Ravindran sir, Rahul (IaSPcS pathshala)-must......regular discussion with Patil sir(digicate ias)....obviously friends discussion and support

Total time: dont know but close to 25 min