Interviews

UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 5 Mar 2025

5 Mar 2025

My interview transcript

Name-Vladimir putin

Date 5 march 2025

Board- Lt. Gen Shukla sir

Time -40 mins , afternoon 2nd to go

Daf key words- Nothing asked from daf ,State(UP), hobbies,prizes ,achievements

Optional -History medium of interview -English

Only one question from current Affairs

Around 35 questions asked (some I forgot)

Chairman Shukla sir-

Kahan se aaye ho, College kahan h tumhara ,Keval UG PG bhi kr lete

1.Some in west are analysing past and predicting future and charging crores .Tell me few

2.Tell me few in India

3.why indian historians are not in such business

4.why don't you try such business you will earn crores?why this bureaucracy?

5.Romila thapar says something else vikram sampath is saying something else.A laymen like me , always remains confused what is truth in history

6.This is like open Ai and deepseek .He then asked me to compare historiography with AI models

7.Then said good u tried but I m not convinced

8.Then I took name of yajnamdevam who is using cryptography to decipher indus script.he noted it down and said are u sure I will read about this.

M2 (Male) not audible properly speaking slow

1.Recited few lines of a poem and asked me the author

2.Tell me Russian interests in eastern Ukraine other than nato and black sea

3.Asked me about differences between facts narratives and Popular history and many follow ups (I forgot)

Lady member 2- grilling

1.Asked me in hindi what is Itihas in hindi

2.Then asked differences between itihas and history

3.Then asked about Macaulay and bureaucracy and many follow ups .she was forcing me to criticize bureaucracy

4.Colonial legacy in India right now

5.Asked differences between indian and western ancient traditions and some follow ups

M3 (male)More interested in asking questions and listening answers

1.Asked me to summarise discussion happened till now

2.Started asking grey areas in history

3.Continuosly pressing me to change my stand on History as a disciple of utility

3.Asked me differences between Science,social science and humanities and asked me where do you put history

4.situation based question on how you will allocate houses in your district

5.what do you mean by Indian bureaucracy as Steel frame?

Has it rusted?

6. Many follow up questions (I forgot) but Shukla sir stopped him in mid saying sir bahut time ho raha hai

M4 -male (cordial , continuously noding head)

1.science and social science which is bigger for you

2.Then asked me to compare technological advancements in different yuga cycles

3.technological advancements and evidences and excavations of Mahabharata period

4. Literature should be believed or not

5.many follow ups on this

Then Shukla sir started asking again few questions and said something about Wright brothers (All started laughing including me then he said to me with a laughing face I m not joking )

Finally sir asked me about Truths and fallacies in history

At last said with a smiling face chaliye chaliye bahut time ho gya hai

Overall observations - Shukla sir constantly looking at me and also smiling ocassionally

M4 most cordial ,Rest all in grilling mode

They were constantly pressing me to change my stand on few ocassions.

Mocks not much helpful as interview went completely on different trajectory than mocks .mocks only Helpful for building confidence.

Mocks - PS Ravindran sir(Help ful) Utkarsh sir( spent around 1 and half hr ,very helpful)

Panel mock - next ias (good),Chankyamandal ( very good),sankalp ias,Drishti ias

and few others but they were not much helpful.