UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 27 Feb 2025
27 Feb 2025
(1/2)
Name : RS
Date : 27/02/2025, forenoon session
Board : Raj shukla (poker face, continuously going out and ringing bells in between)
DAF key words : AP, Movies, Dogs, IIT X, Civil engineering, Sociology
Time : around 20-25 minutes.
Overall experience : it was completely unrelated to mocks. Nothing based on Current affairs. Round big (dinner)table like setup not seen any where in mocks. More of discussion than QnA. 4/5 members grilled continuously to see if would I change my stance
1. Chair person
a. Long discussion on how customary practices are being increasingly becoming uniform due to modern law. It was at this point I said I don’t know and he said let me finish. This is not QnA, we will have Intelligent discussion. I apologised and let him continue
b. Do you think such modern laws that brings uniformity in customs is necessary ?
c. How do we resolve such disputes ?
d. Have you heard of streedhan?
e. Can SC be involved in this ?
f. Do you know of hindu succession act? And discussion on how bringing uniformity in law is causing troubles in such aspects?
2. Member 1
a. Talked about NEET (30% youth not in education, employment or training). How do we solve this?
b. Why govt is not able to provide this?
c. he said people are shifting from one job to another, what could be the reasons ?
d. I mentioned something about state govt, he asked why state govts are not able to provide ?
e. Follow up on my answer, what is the use of freebies, your take on it? I gave my opinion and said there should be sunset clause to the end. He asked how many years 3 or 4 or 5 or 10 years? I said that should be done based on Cost benefit ratio and party consensus
f. Discussion on capital expenditure and revenue expenditure, should we have more capex?
g. All along this while, the chairman continuously rang bell for puine, went out multiple times to see if would be distracted. no matter what, I did not even care for such actions. Just focused on the person I was answering
3. Member 2 (very close to my left)
a. Greeted hello X, continuing on chairperson discussion, you say there should be balance or should communities themselves resolve this? I said if constitutional aspect of dignity is violated state should intervene, else communities can themselves resolve other matters
b. What is your take on Cock fighting that happens during festivals in AP ? Even MPs/MLAs are known to be involved in this, can communities involve in such issues? I said since betting is involved govt should get involved. He then said, remove the gambling aspect, can communities resolve any other issues amongst themselves or should we ban such practices, say even jallikatu?
c. How to resolve the issue of stray dogs ? I said stakeholder approach and was continuing, to which he immediately abrupted and said don’t use fancy words, if you are adminstrator what would you do ?
d. Since you watch movies, do you justify allu arjun arrest. Was he truly responsible for the stampede?
e. In the past too such events happened, can we still arrest them even now?
4. Member 3 (close to my right) -she is such a sweet heart.
a. Given difference in location of your studies, how different was your school and IIT life especially interms of academics, infra and education?
b. What all would you change in your education system, especially in the school you have studied?
c. Some discussion on NEP and can it be successful ?
d. What is the role of local administration in ensuring the administration of school. I asked if it just the role of MLAs? She said all local administration, to which I gave suited response?
e. Role of AI in education? Can it help?
f. Isn't there excessive focus on Maths (STEM), what was your experience in school? What should be the focus in future ?
5. Member 4 (Had very difficult time in understanding his pronunciations)
a. Have you heard about QUAD?
b. Is it military alliance? Do you think its Anti china? (he was pushing me to say it was a military anti china block)
c. Is it fulfilling its mandate?
(2/2)
d. Given all the global instability, If we go against war with china in indopacific will the neighbours in indopacific come to our rescue?
e. Based on my response, he asked what is NAM? Why did we adopt such a philosophy? What is our current policy?
f. While our neighbours have elected women as PMs or presidents, india has not been able to do so? What is your take?
Chairman said your interview is over, I thanked everyone and left the place.
All in all, it was a completely different ball game. I went into the place thinking its just another day. This helped me keep my calm. But truth to be told, my heart raced when I was being called to the room. So maintain your calm, don’t get distracted, what people say in mock interviews is not completely relavant.
Mocks given : 2-3 panel mocks (one in hyderabad- the worst, 2 in samkalp- the closest one to interview)
4 one to one dicussions with : sangamitra maam from Hyderabad, KSG (khan sir), pranay aggrawal sir for sociology and Mridul sir (overall discussions). In my opinion one to one DISCUSSIONS are more better than these artificial panel mocks. Do give 2 of them to be confident or getting used to answering 4-5 elders.
I really thank this telegram channel for its wonderful support mechanism. For those have you who have uploaded, I really thank all of you. It gave a sense of certainty in this uncertain interview. For those, who eagerly see every transcript and yet refuse to share yours, donald trump is less selfish than you people. I leave the rest for you to decide on how low can you take yourself.
(1/2)
Name : Not Einstein
Interview date : 27/02/2025
Board: Dr. Dinesh Dasa
DAF Key words: Anthropology, IIT BHU, Chauri Chaura, Gorakhpur, Army Public School, Chess, planetary rescue simulator, Robotron, Water quality, Varanasi (Other details were not asked)
Chairman sir:
Congratulated me and said you must be feeling proud and privileged to be here. (I differed and said not proud but definitely glad, which made him laugh)
- You are education secretary and you have to setup an IIT in varanasi and IT BHU still exists. Whether you would like to set up a green field IIT or would you go with upgrading IT BHU in IIT BHU?
(There were some cross questions on this)
- Are you following the India-Pakistan match? Did you see the match? Why did it go so peacefully as opposed to earlier when things used to become chaotic?
- what do you know of the 5th and 6th schedule?
- Why is ladakh demanding 6th schedule status and what are challenges in providing it?
Member 1 (lady member, was listening and smiling continuously) :
- you are from Chauri Chaura? Why is it famous?
- Do you agree with gandhiji's method of satyagraha? Is it applicable today?
- Have you heard of the incident where a DM arrested a person based on an emoji reaction? Do you think such action is justified? ( I was aware of the case so answered accordingly)
- In which case such action is justifiable?
- Suppose you are a DM and you have to make a policy decision. ( She clarified that although you will not get such roles at DM level) You have made the policy but people are protesting outside against it? What will you do?
- what if you believe the protestors are wrong and you are right, will you still listen to them? (I had earlier answered along the line that I will talk to their leader to know their objections, that's why this question. In the end she said well done and seemed satisfied.)
- Asked about my thoughts on equality, equality of opportunity.
- If I and you run a marathon will that be equal? Importance of equity? (Dasa sir interrupted after this question)
Member 2 ( was very energetic and smiling widely) :
- you are from Army Public School? What is unique about gorakhpur and army gorakhpur district?
- why have the gurkhas been historically recruited into Indian army?
- In your opinion why has the recruitment come to a halt? ( I had no idea so told him I am not aware of it and apologised before answering)
- Asked about the public opinion of Agniveer scheme in gorakhpur?
- who is the new star of chess in india?
- Why has chess shown a humongous rise in the recent years?
-replying to my answer he asked so do you think it's just because of celebrity promotion and not much analytical skills? ( I differed)
- IT sector had also seen similar growth as chess is seeing once. Now after AI has the bubble of IT will burst soon and there will be joblosses. What are your opinions on it?
(I talked along the lines of skilling and reskilling, he jokingly said so we should start skilling them from the womb itself and laughed)
Member 3 :
The prizes and medals you have won are very fascinating and some are going over my head.
- what is planetary rescue simulator that you have won in?
( Discussed for 3-4 minutes on it)
- what is Robotron?
- did you make a physical robot?
- was like the famous serial where you have to fight with robots? ( He couldn't recall the name of the serial. Said he will definitely recall and tell before the end of interview)
- what are revolutions that have occured in human history? (He named Harari's book) AI is concentrated in hands of few and is consequently concentrating power in hands of few. What are your thoughts on it?
Member 4 (A bit serious) :
- you have worked on water quality of ganga, where did conduct the study? What were the results? What is the status today?
(2/2)
- Kashi has been known by different names such as banaras and varanasi. Why? Kashi is said to be on top lord Shiva's trishul. What do you make of this statement?
- who was the founder of BHU? What were his views on education?
- What was the relation of MMM with chauri chaura? ( I didn't know the exact relation so apologised)
- What is startup india and make in India?
- how many universities are there in in gorakhpur?
- how is IIT BHU affiliated with BHU?
Chairman sir: interrupted and reminded about time. Your interview is over. I thanked all of them and was relieved.
Overall experience : Board was highly cordial. It felt more like a discussion than Q&A. Interview was completely DAF based as expected of Dasa sir.
Mocks: Gave many (mainly for speaking practise). Samkalp,Vajirao, nextIas, chahl, forum etc. all were good in one way or the other but samkalp , vajirao and chahl stood out.
O2O: again many. Mudit jain sir and satyam jain sir (DAF filling), sajal sir, bhawani sir, Ayush sinha sir.
DAF Keywords- Telangana, Law, criminal laws, cricket
Chairman: Lt gen Raj Shukla Sir
Date: 25/02/2025, Forenoon, Third to go
Chairman
1. Where do you come from?
2. Did bifurcation of the state do good to Telangana?
3. How much of Telangana’s GDP comes from Hyderabad?
4. Is it a good thing to have so much economic growth concentrated in Hyderabad? This has been a scenario in every state having metropolis- what is your opinion?
5. How can regional imbalances be corrected?
6. What is your view on China?
7. China and India have started their path towards development at the same time, why is China way ahead of us in GDP?
8. What is China’s GDP?
9. Though a communist country, China is competing with USA on capitalism as well- how do you view this?
10. Why is India not able to do the same?
11. How much is India’s contribution to manufacturing sector?
12. Should India follow the current path towards development as it is following now? (In the context of India developing slowly as compared to China)
Member 1
1. Following on from Chairman sir’s questions, even when China is so ahead in GDP, why is it that many countries don’t have good relations with China?
2. China vs UK? Why UK favoured over China?
3. What are the key drivers of Indian economy? Have you read about consumption, investments and exports?
4. Are you practicing law or working or just preparing for this exam?
5. Tell me about how the right to privacy is protected in Digital Personal Data Protection Bill?
6. Tell me about IPR laws and how are they related to competition laws.
7. Is there any situation or circumstance when IPR laws can be removed by the government?
8. What is the constitutional basis for Uniform Civil Code?
9. Tell me two case laws where the Supreme Court ruled on Uniform Civil Code.
10. Which beach is in the news recently? and why?
Member 2
1. You have KPC Gandhi gold medal in criminal law in your graduation. Who is KPC Gandhi? His contributions?
2. You have written analysing leadership qualities while watching cricket as your hobby- compare Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma’s captaincy styles.
3. In a democracy like India, do you think we still need laws on sedition and blasphemy?
4. Tell me some case laws on sedition in India.
5. We have borrowed many features of our constitution from UK- they have very few or no amendments. Why so many amendments to Indian Constitution? Are they needed for India?
6. What is the basic structure doctrine? Is it written anywhere in the Constitution?
7. Though we have borrowed our constitution from UK, why is Parliament supreme in UK? Is it the same in India too? Why is it different here?
8. You are using state and government- what is the difference between the two?
9. Do you know about the new parliament, you must have seen it around in Delhi? Tell me about who are the people behind making the Ashoka chakra on it?
10. Which is the largest Loksabha constituency in India- It is in your state?
Member 3 (Lady member)
1. GST bill- which constitutional amendment brought this and what amendments were made?
2. There are different lists in the Indian constitution, so what changes were made to this by GST bill?
3. Tell me about the undertrial situation in India.
4. Is pendency of cases leading to undertrials or undertrials leading to pendency?
5. Why are the undertrials in jail, they can stay out like you and me right?
Member 4
1. Any case law on undertrials?
2. You come from NALSAR University, so what is your opinion on vice-chancellors being appointed to universities from academic background?
3. If we have state appointed VCs, then can we have open houses like you have in your university? Is that possible- to differentiate between political and academic spheres in such scenarios?
4. What are some of the new changes brought in by the new criminal laws- BNS, BNSS, BSA?
5. Forensic evidence has been highlighted in the new criminal laws- what is your opinion on it?
6. What is the timeframe for admitting forensic evidences?
Interview 2024 Transcript.
• Date- 27/2/25, AN
• Board - Lt General Raj shukla
• DAF - IFS, Jaipur, Telangana, IIT , Sociology (No much from DAF)
Chairman
• Where are you from?
• Are you working?
• Monologue on AI about the NEXUS' by Yuval Noah Harari. Have you read it?
• Do you think AI will control humans?
• What are we doing in AI in this regard?
• Compared to China?
• GPUS from where? How many?
• LLMs in India vs China?
• AI replacing bureaucracy?
• Why this generation not risk taking in contect of Space X by Musk?
• Whom to blame, present generation or my generation?
• Have you any friend in IIT who is risk taking?
• Why we don’t have companies like Tesla, Space X?
• What should we do in space sector so that we can match SpaceX?
Member 1:
• What is Romsar sites?
• First Ramsar site in India?
• Campa, which body type, serving purpose, various activities?
• Difference between Natural and Organic Farming?
• What is Green Credit?
• Can Organic Farming be included in Green Credit scheme?
Member 2:
• One American came to IIT during my time and said that Indians are good making 1st generation things secondly, what do you think about it?
• Why we are not good in innovation?
• Do you think climate change is Hoax?
• There are Climate deniers as well, what about them?
• Why red sanders is not allowed to be cultivated commercially in AP?
• That is recently allowed, why it was not earlier?
• Why naxalism was there in northern Telangana more?
Member 3: (lady)
• What is India’s wage bill?
• Why lateral entry was withdrawn?
• Do we need DOGE in India?
• Do you think bureaucracy is degrading?
• What change you will make to improve bureaucracy?
• Why not replace bureaucracy with lateral entrants completely?
• How is bureaucracy different in UK and India?
Member 4:
• Why generalist are important?
• Why democracies in Indian neighbourhood are crumbling but not India?
• Your view on India democracy?
• Your view on Indira Shawney case?
• Subcategorization? Will it benefit?
Chairman:
• Thank you. Your interview is over.