Interviews

UPSC interview, Sheel Vardhan Singh board, 30 Jan 2025 (3)

30 Jan 2025

(1/2)

INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT

Interview Date – 30 Jan 2025

Board – Shri Sheel Vardhan Singh

Forenoon session, 2nd to go. Nearly 45min.

DAF Keywords – Chemical Engineering, Research Internship, Indian Hip Hop Music, Karate, Perspective-taking visualization, Cargill Global Scholars Program, Sociology.

Chairman

1. Reads the DAF – You are {Name}, come from {place}. I see that you have mentioned that you follow Indian Hip Hop music, what is it?

2. From your answer, I see it is more like fusion music rather than a distinct genre of music.

3. What is the origin of Hip Hop music?

a. Rooted in protest movement of Afro-Americans during 70s in USA.

4. (Building upon my answer) So Hip hop music has this protest element, but Indian Hip hop music lacks this, so how is IHH a category of music?

a. Gave some examples of tracks that have this element of protest.

5. What you’re telling is rap music like Tupac Shakur in the west coast etc., is rap same as hip hop?

6. What do you know about Hindustani music and Carnatic music?

7. (Interrupts my answer) What is the textual source from which they are derived?

a. I said sorry sir I’m not aware. Sir said - you know so much about hip hop and western music, you should be aware about our own music as well.

8. Our discussion on fusion reminds me of a new genre that is gaining a lot of popularity – Historical fiction. What is your opinion on it?

9. So according to you it is rooted in history but is essentially fiction?

10. But I think it is distorting history. When people like Amish write about the people of Meluha, most readers don’t distinguish history from fiction.

a. Helps in creating awareness.

b. Leads to curiosity about history, people can read more about true history based on their interest.

11. As per this logic, if there is crime in society, it would create awareness about it amongst people. So, crime is also good for society?

a. Answered as per normal and pathological social facts of Durkheim and impact on collective conscience.

12. So, you have used the Collectivism theory from sociology. What good is this shock to collective conscience? We have seen that in past there have been incidents that have created ripples in society, but the situation remains same and nothing has changed.

a. I began answering that it depends on the type of crime and the severity.

b. (Interrupted in between) I’ll narrow it down for you, let’s talk about crime against women.

13. I see in your DAF that you’ve accomplished a lot in research domain. You did {read out the details and achievements}. It seems you were on course to do your PhD, become a professor, do brilliant research and bring in a Nobel Prize for our nation (says this playfully). Why this sudden 180-degree switch to Civil Services?

Member-1

1. What belt are you in Karate?

2. Which style of Karate do you practice?

a. Shito Ryu

3. Is it related to Shoto-kan? What is the difference between both?

4. After learning Karate, do you feel like beating people around? Or getting into fights?

5. So did you not get the opportunity to get into fights or you don’t like it? (with a slight laugh)

6. Assume that you get into a fight with a random person on the street. He won’t follow the rules that you are taught in Karate like hit above the belt etc. So how would you fight with him?

a. I mentioned that we are aware of basics of street fighting if someone uses sticks etc. Chairman sir adds that if the person has a gun, then the entire situation changes.

b. After my answer member says I thought that like my students in exam you would say that this is out of syllabus (starts laughing). He said that I asked these questions to ease you into the interview, now let’s get to serious questions.

7. You have done Chemical Engineering? There is another discipline called Chemical Technology for graduation. What is the difference between both?

8. (Probably was not completely satisfied with my previous answer) Can you think of what is the relation between Engineering and Technology?

(2/2)

a. I said rightly pointed out sir, Technology is actually application of Engineering. I think this was what sir wanted to hear.

9. Are you aware about Ceramics and related aspects? (I was a little hesitant to answer, so he said you study it as part of your curriculum, right? I said yes)

10. So at what temperature does ceramic manufacturing takes place?

a. I said I’m not aware, so sir told roughly around 1500-1800 degree Celsius.

Member-2

1. (Asked me to look behind me at the wall) What is it that you see?

a. National Emblem

2. Where did it come from?

a. Mentioned Lion capital from Sarnath Ashokan pillar.

3. What is the history behind it?

a. I said I’m unaware. Sir said do read on it, it has very interesting history over the years and especially the British era.

4. You must be knowing that China claims Arunachal Pradesh as its part, Ladakh as its part. Even Nepal claims Kalapani region as its territory. We Indians have cultural claim to Mt Kailash, we say Lord Shiva even lived there. Why don’t we also start claiming it as our territory? Something of a tit-for-tat response?

a. Talked about ambition to become Vishwa Guru (Member-4 noted and cross-questioned on this later).

5. So you’re saying we should be a saint and uphold the global order when we have such a large trade deficit with China? Doesn’t it threaten our sovereignty?

a. Cross-question on Chinese FDI incoming.

6. Where is the Chicken’s neck?

a. Where is it located?

b. It is also known as?

c. Significance (told this himself)

7. What district of Bangladesh borders that part? What is the demographic composition of the district?

a. Told him I’m not aware, said you’re not up to date with this issue.

Member-3

1. What is Cargill that you’ve mentioned in your DAF?

a. Explained the program and what the leadership position was about.

2. (Clarified) What is Cargill? Is it an organization or name of a person?

3. You have sociology as your optional. What are Veblen goods?

4. So, demand increases as the price rises, it that right? How do you explain this phenomenon?

5. What is India’s policy on Cryptocurrency? Is it legal?

6. What is President Trump’s stance on Cryptocurrency?

7. Should India also take steps to increase crypto acceptance as it is the currency of the future?

Member-4 (Lady)

1. You have mentioned that your hobby is Perspective-taking visualizations. What is it?

2. So how is that a hobby? (looked perplexed)

a. After my explanation, she looked at Chairman. Sir confirmed by rephrasing it if this is what I mean.

b. After I said yes sir, ma’am asked sir I’m still not sure how this is a hobby (and started laughing). Sir said this is what he is saying (looked dead serious).

c. I requested if I could clarify and gave an example. Sir asked if your visualization of your interview going well has manifested (with a smile).

3. You mentioned about India aspiring to become Vishwa Guru. Don’t you think it is a very ambitious goal?

4. What are the three major challenges that can hinder our progress to achieve Viksit Bharat by 2047?

5. (Probably wanted to hear about unemployment crisis in previous answer) Can you think something about unemployment and some recent initiatives that Government of India is taking to address it?

6. What is immigration and why is it a major challenge for the nations? Why anti-immigrant sentiments are on the rise?

7. (Cross question from my answer) So the rise/ resurgence of right in Europe and USA as you mentioned is linked to influx of migrants?