UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 13 Mar 2026
13 Mar 2026
he judgement didn’t define what constitutes Basic structure. Why it is not defined? I answered. Give me some examples of it. I said federalism and judicial review. How do you say Federalism is a basic structure. Centrally sponsored schemes are coming, states are complaining that there is over centralization going on. I answered. (Tum log Federalism mat bolna but. Federalism Pandora box open kar dega). However, At that time nothing else was coming to my mind. He asked: Is preamble part of basic structure? I said yes. He said: 42nd amendment included the words socialism and secularism in the preamble. Doesn’t it violets basic structure? I answered in know, giving reference to Article 25 to 28 for Secularism. You have completed your graduation in 2025 only. Do you know about Arbitration and conciliation act? yes sir but I am not very good at it. an Arbitrator is appointed in which section? Answered vaguely. but you have completed your graduation this year only. You must have studied it. Yes sir 3rd year me padha tha 2 saal ho gaye. Ok. Lets talk about general things. Government is trying to do away with arbitration. Are you aware about it? sir I have not heard this. Rather I have recently red that Government is trying to constitute an arbitration counsel of India. There were also talks going on amending the act. Don’t you think this is a dilemma? At one side you are saying that government is promoting Arbitration and on the other side they are trying to do away with it. He gave the context. They are planning that 10crore se upar ke matters me Arbitration khatam kar dete hain. Do you think this is a good measure? I said no with my reasons.
Member five: it lasted quite long. Why took sociology after law? The one and only HR question. I said it was BA LLB and I have already studied sociology as a part of that course. I took some electives as well on sociology. He cut me shot and asked which elective? I mentioned climate capitalism. so he asked what is climate capitalism. I answered. What is rare about rare earth minerals. They are not rare. Then Why China have them India doesn’t? they are in abundance. I answered. He asked some more examples of climate capitalism. Then he shifted the conversation to make in India. Perhaps from rare earth he must have thought about supply chain and that’s where make in India. Asked about its successes and failure. I started with Success, Iphone assembly and some other points. He said, Assemble hi to kar rahe hain kaunse badi baat hai. I responded. He asked what else in make in India? Didn’t have any point at that moment and reluctantly said sir defence indigenization. As expected, the suicide was done and LT GEN Raj Shukla takes over from here.
Back to chairperson: 11 saal hog aye make in India ko aur abhi bhi 12 me se 9 products to China se import kar rahe hain ham kya indigenization ho raha? I said sir at least 3 to banane shuru kiye. Kuchh to progress hui hai and we have to start from somewhere. Achha to ham 10 saal me 1 product banaye and say make in India is successful? I answered. Sir: China is an autocracy and India is a democracy. They are very successful, they have great ideas. Why we don’t? I said sir hamare yahan kisi bhi project se pahle protest hote hain, environmental litigation hote hain, projects isiliye delay ho jate hain. Unki autocracy hai they can do anything. Shukla sir: achha matlab pahle to hamko autocracy banna padega.☠️☠️ sir we have examples of successful democracies jaise Europe USA etc. Hamare problem ye hain ki ham implementation bahut delay kar dete hain. He said, but China has better ideas and we don’t. Since the interview was about to end and from this conversation I felt he was too adamant to change his stance on China having better ideas than India, I stayed silent. Neither countered nor agreed.
Overall experience: I didn’t find the board cordial. Accept the female board member, rest of them were expressionless. Didn’t show even a single gesture of satisfaction throughout the interview.
Relevant mocks: Sankalp,
Khan sir (KSG). The 1 to 1 with him was the best
he judgement didn’t define what constitutes Basic structure. Why it is not defined? I answered. Give me some examples of it. I said federalism and judicial review. How do you say Federalism is a basic structure. Centrally sponsored schemes are coming, states...
Transcript of Rishabh Yadav, AIR 132, UPSC CSE 2025.
Date 20th Feb. 2026, 5th to go.
Lt. General (Retd.) Raj Shukla Sir Board.
1. No questions from DAF section on interest, hobbies asked.
2. Graduation : Dr. Ram Manohar Lohiya National Law university.
3. Optional : Law
Keywords: IBC, Antitrust etc,.POCSO (but nothing asked from this section).
Chairman.
1. How do we change the ecosystem in bureaucracy where innovation is favoured and the resistance to change/play safe approach is desisted?
2. (Follow up question from my answer) but Nandan nilekani sir is all against AI, even though he favoured and made great leaps in DPI, so how do we exactly change this attitude?
3. Do you know that DGMO's task has become of pointing 3 issues in every file presented to him in a day?,(and a long monologue).
Member 2
1. You named some specialisation thing in bureaucracy, how do you ensure specialisation in bureaucracy:
i) do we want a new 5 year course for the same?
ii) do you know some govt scheme for specialisation?
2. You know govt. is borrowimg so much, is it not alarming to you?
3. Recent DGCA guidelines for No Flying List, who will decide whether these are right or not?
4. New section for cheating(420IPC) in BNS?
Member 3
1. Why your district despite giving a PM way back in 1970s, and phenomenal political leaders has not yet developed?
2. Distance of Lucknow and Kanpur from your distt.?
3. What do you know about Hindi Sahitya?
4. Why is there deteriorating state of Hindi Sahitya in UP, we had seen some stalwarts in the field like Munshi Premchand, Mahadevi Verma but not today, what are the reasons?
Member 4
1. Continue your answer to the last question of the Chairman.
2. The issue is that if I want to do something innovative by being in service there is hanging sword of auditing, and even work done in good faith can be maligned. In sch scenario how do you propose that the innovation can be furthered?
Member 5
1. Are you into Taxation law?
2. Do you know about the details of the recent India-France DTAA?
3. The litigation in taxation regime is mainly because the tax officials making interpretations in favour of extracting maximum revenue, do you agree or not, and give reasons also?
4. So, you are saying that the intent of tax officials is good but the spirit of law is bad?
Chairperson
1. Then who will decide that the spirit of law is good or bad?
2. So, if I have to close the cover of my phone then also should I seek judiciary's permisssion?
3. What did you mean by "top leadership leadership" in your answer to Board member 4?
4. If everything should come from there only then why these top most positions in bureaucracy and armed forces exist, what is their need then?
A long monologue then about the situation, to which I agreed.
Chairman : Okay bye.
Thank you sir(Chairman), thank you sir (to members on my left), thank you sir(to the members on my right).
My experience: Cordial conversation, all members listened to the conversation keenly. I did my best, answered with conviction and confidence. Rest left to the God!
PT Marks: 170.