UPSC interview, Sanjay Verma board, 24 Jan 2025 (2)
24 Jan 2025
[1/2 ]
Date of Interview = 24th Jan 2025.
Name = Ezio Auditore da Firenze.
DAF Keywords = Blogging on social, economic and philosophical topics; Dance and Choreography; Commodities trading intern. (Didn't ask anything else)
Optional = PSIR.
Grad subject = Chemical engineering.
Board = Sanjay Verma sir.
M1 Chair sir -
1. (Asked details as to since when I had been blogging) So you are interested in Philosophy. Tell me, the act of me giving marks to you in this interview would be me expressing my Free will or would it be Determinism?
2. Which do you do more - Dance or Choreography?
3. 3 states in India where people are very pro-dance and 3 states where people are not very pro-dance?
M2 Ma'am -
1. What does your name mean?
2. What side would you choose in the Ends vs Means debate?
2. What did Krishna say to justify the end of fighting the war despite Arjuna's focus on good Means?
3. (follow up) So you will go for ends in the ends-means debate?
4. 1 child playing on an old railway track that has gone into disuse. 4 children playing on a new railway track that is in active use. Where should the train go? You know that the 1 kid is less at fault since that track is in disuse. Where should the train go? (I decided to not commit on any one side in the answer here)
M3 Sir - (Speaking too softly. Had to lean in even though was sitting right beside me.)
1. Why should Commodities trading be allowed? (I just listed a few positives)
M4 Sir -
1. Does SAARC hold any relevance?
2. Top Chemical engineering industries where government should give a push.
3. Given the huge judicial pendencies, should judges be recruited on contract? (I asked for a clarification that if he meant judges from private sector. He said yes of course.) (I said yes if qualifications are fine then can be done.)
4. Ohkay but do you think only Qualifications are enough in case of appointing judges? (I said yes along with them need to see values for which the person stands for)
5. Idea of Affordable Housing - what's the need of it?
M5 Sir -
1. Who planned Chandigarh? (not from DAF)
2. (follow up) What special planning did he do for the city?
3. Should cities of Delhi-NCR (Noida, Faridabad, Gurugram) be included in Delhi state itself? Why or why not? (I said revenue generation of home states so no)
4. (follow up) Don't you think Delhi state deserves the revenue from the cities that it helped establish in the first place?
5. A cricketer with a similar name as mine in news? Why is he in news? (for 2nd part, said Idk)
6. How did you sustain yourself through the 5 years after college? (I misunderstood the Q twice as I thought he was asking about my motivations for CSE. Chair intervened and said that Panelist was asking how I financially sustained myself without working. I politely apologised for misunderstanding and answered the Q.) (In hindsight, I still think the Panelist could’ve framed the Q a little more clearly.)
7. Global warming --> stress on Himalayan peaks + Melting ice caps. What should be done to reduce further pressure due to overtourism?
M1 Chair sir -
1. You didn't answer Ma'am's Q. You ducked it. Take a stand - will you kill one innocent kid or 4 who are knowingly playing on the active track? (I said objectively I will go for Greatest happiness of greatest number, choose the lesser evil and if I have to, will kill one.)
2. But you do realise that you are decreasing deterrence against bad behaviour of the 4 kids? (I said yes sir but since first aim is public welfare... He cut me short and said - Okay I realise there's no correct answer here. But I'm happy you at least took a stand.)
Observations - Sanjay Verma sir seemed interested in his Qs and my answers. Overall cordial experience. Some of my answers could have been better in terms of forward-looking conclusions which I perhaps didn't give.