UPSC interview, Suman Sharma board, 20 Jan 2025
20 Jan 2025
Name: Mohammed Siraj Official (baaki sab fake hai :P)
Date: 20/01/2025
Afternoon session, 5th to go
Board: Suman Sharma ma’am
Optional: Law
DAF Pointers: B.A.LL.B. (Hons), Youth Parliament on River Pollution, Criminal Law Research, DPIIT – other DAF entries not relevant
Chairperson
1. Fact-checking procedure in India
a. Who appoints fact-checkers?
b. What is the fact-checking procedure?
c. Why did Bombay HC stay the government notification?
d. What other remedies are available?
e. What exactly did Meta do on this front? Why did Zuckerberg do so?
2. Is the world heading towards unipolarity, with Elon Musk controlling everything?
a. Why not?
b. Why is he seeking entry in India?
3. What is the legal position on attempt on commit suicide in India?
a. What are its consequences?
b. Don’t you think this would hide the actual attempts being made?
M1 (Female Member)
4. Why is the problem of river pollution persistent in India?
a. What can be done about the matter?
b. The issue is not so much about capacity of STPs: we see so many unregulated colonies in Najafgarh releasing sewage directly, why are we unable to rectify the problem?
c. Why is it still an issue, despite government awareness of the issue for years now?
d. Polluting industries are shut down in Delhi: sewage is to be largely blamed. Comments?
5. It is said that the Third World War will be fought over water – how can we save water in such a scenario?
a. Should we ban swimming pools as well, if fountains are a problem?
b. Why do we have so many river-water disputes?
i. Within the country
ii. Between countries
c. What can be done in such a scenario?
M2
6. What is the New York Convention?
a. What do you know about it?
7. Why are judgments from our Supreme Court not cited so much in other countries’ judgments?
a. Is it because our judgments are too lengthy?
b. Is it because our judges’ appointment procedure is said to be biased?
c. Developing countries (like South Africa) may cite our judgments, but why not developed countries?
d. As Law Secretary, how will you ensure that our judgments are promoted?
e. How is the American legal system different from ours?
f. How are judges appointed in the US?
8. As a law graduate, how will you promote awareness amongst the common citizens about laws and their rights?
M3
9. Should we ban expeditions to the Mount Everest?
a. If this debate is in the context of waste piling up there, then how do we solve the problem?
10. What are the consequences of legalising cryptocurrency in India?
a. You’ve cited the positives, what are the negative implications?
b. How should we regulate crypto in India?
11. Have you heard the term ‘BIMARU’ States?
a. Why is this term allotted to them?
b. What has been or should be done on this matter?
c. How should we address the problem of malnutrition?
d. Don’t you think we should also be boosting local-level agriculture here?
M4
12. What do you know about industrial corridors?
a. How should their location be decided?
b. Is it enough to just demarcate corridors? What more needs to be done?
13. We see India taking no position between Russia and Ukraine, and having good ties with them all. How should we navigate the cause of peace in such disputes?
a. How can India lead the world in this context?
Might have missed some Questions.
Time – nearly 25-30 min
Mocks: Vajirao & Reddy, Unacademy (conducted in a basement library in ORN 💀💀), Samkalp, Chahal.
Usefulness: marginal utility falls with each experience – one must look to incorporate their feedback, and get comfortable in interacting with learned senior civil servants.
One-on-One: Rajendra sir (Kalam IAS – SAR analysis of mock interview video was quite helpful), Varun Jain sir (SarrthiIAS).
While inputs in all these were helpful, the actual PT ended up on a very different line from what I had personally expected. Actual PT was across a round table (unlike the mocks): I was unable to maintain eye-contact with everyone at the same time.
The board was very cordial, and I was happy to see two women (unlike the mocks, where all were ‘manels’). I am very grateful for this opportunity, it was truly a learning experience – thank you!