UPSC interview, M. Sathiyavathy board, 27 Mar 2019
27 Mar 2019
Sumit Kumar:
Interview Date: 27/03/2019; Board: Ms. M. Sathiyavathy
About Candidate:
Sumit Kumar
Anthropology Optional
2009-2013: B.Tech., Materials and Metallurgical Engineering, IIT Kanpur
2013-2015: Consultant, Pricewaterhouse Copers Private Limited
2016: Cleared CAPF in 2017 and allotted SSB in April 2018
2017: Cleared CSE 2017 Mains, Result in April 2018
2018: Allotted IDES
Hobbies: Watching Ted Talks, Playing Cricket
Chairman (Female):
1. What did you after 2015 (before you graduated from iitk in 2013, did 2 years of job).
Ans: i was preparing for govt. services
2. You are selected in capf. Which force did you get selected in?
Ans: SSB
3. Did you join?
Ans: No mam, the result came in 2017 but appointment letter came in april 2018 and in same month civil services result came in which I qualified
4. Which services are you in?
Ans: Indian Defence Estates Service
5. What is the work of IDES?
Ans: told about ceo and deo roles
6. What exactly do you do in cantonments?
7. What are TED talks (how does it affect lives of people)?
8. Name any Indian person who has given TED talk?
Ans: told about Roopa Moudgil and Arunachalam Murugantham. Told about latter’s work on sanitary napkins
9. Did you see the movie on it? What was its name?
Other members discussed about getting oscars on the same topic
At last when they finished discussing, I told that it was short film as they were confused that it was documentary
Others agreed that it was a short film
Member 1 (Male):
1. You play cricket. Will you play cricket world cup this year?
Ans: I said sorry sir (shocked to see this surprise ques). He repeated the question saying will you play world cup this year. I said no
2. He asked are you excited to watch world cup this year?
3. Which other teams would you look forward to?
And: I said Australia, England and gave analysis why (high scoring pitches and slog hitters in English cricket team)
4. So you would be supporting other teams also in the spirit of the game?
Ans: yes sir
5. Do you know about CCI (Competition Commission of India)?
What is it?
6. Are you aware about the Act regarding maintaining competition? Tell me its name
Ans: Sorry sir not aware
7. There was earlier Monopolistic Restrictive Trade Practices Act. Do you know about it?
Ans: As the name suggests it ensures that monopoly doesn't prevail
8. Any other provisions?
And: Sorry Sir, I am not aware about other provisions
9. Have you heard of IPRs? What is it?
10. Isn't IPRs and Competition conflicting? What is its solution?
11. What is compulsory licensing?
Member 2 (Male):
1. Sumit you are from Jamui, recently DM of Jamui has been in news for wrong reasons. What is it?
Ans: Told that divorce has been filed by him
He interfered by saying that his wife sat on dharna with her mother near Sam's residence. There are allegations of dowry on him
2. Civil servants have been taking dowry. It is common in all services (not necessarily IAS, IPS). Why such practice has been continuing?
Ans: Sir, it is very regressive step that civil servants whose job is to serve the public are taking these regressive steps. However, these are only allegations on him and nothing has been proved yet
3. How do you solve problem of dowry?
4. How will you ensure gender equality?
5. Are women given inheritance property rights?
Ans: Yes under Hindu Succession Act
6. Chairman interfered by saying what is the provision "women shall inherit property" or "women can inherit property"
Ans: I said "I am not so sure but if it is a step promoting gender quality, shall should be the provision mentioned"
Chairman said that it is shall
7. Since Jamui is mineral rich region, what are the reasons for industries not getting set up?
Ans:
1. Land locked state
2. Freight Equalisation Policy
3. Resource Curse
Sir told there is one more reason i.e., presence of Naxalism
Agreed with it that in presence of Naxalism, development of industries couldn't take place
Member 3 (Lady Member):
1.
Difference between income generating scheme and social protection scheme
Ans: In answer, told MGNREGA as example of income generating scheme
2. How MGNREGA is income generation scheme?
3. Give examples of social protection scheme
Ans: National Old Age Pension Scheme, PM Jeevan Jyoti Beema Yojana, Ayushmaan Bharat
4. How scheme like Ujjwala Yojana contribute to women empowerment?
5. Define women empowerment
Ans: giving space to women in social, political and economic domains
Ex- 73rd Amendment Act; social empowerment like social protection schemes
6. You have read from IIT and have good CPI, then why you didn't pursue higher studies?
Ans: Said wanted to use my experiences like leadership, team management, academic into my job and hence didn't pursue higher studies
Member 4:
1. Why so many IITians are coming in civil services?
Ans: Civil service promote diversity, don't know why so many IITians are coming up
2. Why have you come for civil services?
Ans: Said in job, I met with alumni and senior who are in administration through which I got to know
a. impact I could create on masses
b. job satisfaction I would derive
3. since you had MME in college, plastic is becoming nuisance these days? How will you control it?
Ans: Told points of Plastic Managment Rules of Central Govt
4. There is problem of water scarcity being faced. What measures will you take to solve it?
Ans: Tild about "Ralegan Siddhi model" and elaborated on it
5. Do you know technogy which is used to extract water from atmosphere?
Ans: Sorry sir, I don't know
Chairman said thank you, your interview is over
I greeted everybody with thank you and departed from the room
Sandeep Sheoran:
B S bassi sir board: 27 March
From Rajasthan work ex in oil sector and social security sector. mechanical engineer.
Tell me something about digboi.
Oil crisis.
Petro dollars.
Siachin issue.
Last me Brixit - sector effected and their strategy to handle no deal brexit?
EPFO job data controversy?
Defence budget. How much? What % of GDP.
Revenue and capital expenditure difference.
R&D experiture. What r&d at BPCL. Why we always catching up in r&d? Field in r&d where India is good. Why lack in r&d developments. Other than money what is needed. HAL and DRDO success and failure.
Border defence. Technology use in border defence. Comprehensive border management? Pitfall of technology in border management.
Settelte name - GSAT. How it works.
Labour laws anti-growth? Labour laws stringent. Their effects. What labour laws. Examples. Labour reforms which are proposed.
Yo Yo Choti Singh
28/03/19 A/N
Sujata Mehta board
Pub adm optional
Online Knowledge sharing and learning hobby
CM:
1. What is gig economy ? (Sorry mam I don't know)
2. What is this hobby ? What you do?
3. Have you heard of MOOCs ? Have you used any ?
4. How you deal with fake news problem ? What can be done for others those who are not aware like you ?
5. Does social media algorithm promotes fake news ?
M1: (Worst experience)
1. How will you explain 2g 3g 4g 5g to a very common man ?
2. No tell me exact frequency bands of each of them ? (Couldn't recall except 5g) He grilled a lot here. I keep saying Sorry sir.
3. Ok How our armed organized territorially ? Tell me name of all those commands ? (Told only 2 3) again grilled here with few more factual questions. Some replied some Sorry sir.
4. Ok tell me has judiciary performed good ? What else institution performed good ?
5. Tell me some famous constitutional cases ? (After this much grilling couldn't recall except Keshavananda + K Puttuswamy ..Went blank.. said Sorry sir I am not able to recall more)
M2: Lady member (Best part)
1. Difference in AIS vs Central services
2. Why do we need AIS when we have state CS in States already ?
3. Tell me a situation. Your boss asks you to something illegal. Will you do ?
4. Ok if he asks you to do something which is legal, but not gives you in writing. Will you do ?
5. Ok suppose if he ask legal thing to do but you conscience don't allows you to do, will you do ?
M3: Sardar g (low voice)- ok ok
1. In services Joint secretary is higher or Director ? (Told wrong .. shittt) (FEW such other small facts.. some answered some Sorry sir)
2. SSP with IPS tag vs SSP with HPS tag .. How's this possible ? (Told 1/3rd promotion rule)
3. One territory of Pakistan where lots of exploitation (Baloochistan) ..Counter questions on situation
4. Is afghanistan land locked ? Is pakistan land locked ? Name one famous port in Pakistan ? (Gwadar)
5. SAARC HQ ? Members ? Is Maldives a part ? Why we not going for SAARC Meeting ?
6. Maximum seats in RS ? Why no election for RS like LS?
Few more facts about similar things/factts (not able to recall)
M4: don't know kya shi kya galat ..Pura india ghuma diya
1. Blue water navy vs Brown water navy ?
2. Sir Creek ? What's issue ? (Told good)
3. SIACHIN Issue ? Why siachin important ? (Screwed here by saying something vague.. grilled.. sorry sir kah k nikla )
4. Doklam issue ? What China doing why ?
5. What you share ? Where you share ? Do you use Cloud ? How will 5G benefit here ? (Average answer)
CM:
Do you want us to ask anything ?
Mam very important occasion so I have prepared for it BUT NOT PRE PLANNED IT. So I have nothing specific to ask as such.
CM: Good but still you would have prepared something which you may want us to ask you ?
Mam Agriculture family..So prepared agri issues in detail
CM signs M1 to ask something
M1: Agriculture distress - a reality or overhyped ? (Personal experience..It's sad reality sir)
Where it is ? Haryana m to nhi hoga ?
(Sir in all Rainfed areas it is intense.. in rest it is there mostly everywhere)
Why ? What are solutions ?
Sir root reason is Huge Uncertainty existing in Agriculture right from pre sowing to during to Post harvest.
What kind of uncertainty ?
Told well.
Solution ?
In short term enhance MSP. But long term give farmer access and control over basic resources like irrigation. Empower to Let him be an entrepreneur. Because MSP enhancement is not sustainable alternative.
How it is not ? (Distorts Market)
No it don't. How can you say it distorts market ?
Elaborated with examples like .. in Haryana govt enhanced MSP for Paddy or Wheat disproportionately - cropping cycle became distorted. UP Sugarcane MSP/FRP is more economically attractive.. result Market oversupply issue.
Lastly If we increase MSP it increases costs across supply chain. So final consumer price also increases. Causing High Food inflation. Again distorting market.
CM: Very good. Thankyou.
Thanked all. Left. They were watching carefully.
Self-analysis:
Overall a
verage. Factual weakness most negative. Played satisfactory in prepared areas. Baaki rabb rakhaa. Finally Free after 3 months of pain. Expected marks range - 165-175. :|
Born fighter:
Transcript:
Mechanical Engineer
History Optional
2 years work experience in designing
Welcome..
Have a seat.
So Ur name's Pronunciation is right? Showed pic and asked is it you?
Briefly introduce yourself only education and work experience. So u r mechanical engineer? What was Ur work profile? Describe it. How many member team? Division of work. Name of client( I didn't tell name it may go wrong rest I told everything)
So was job satisfying?
( I said I loved the job it was good designing part) why civil services ? ( Told diversity as in other areas after a point scope of work gets limited)
Then questions related to Gurgaon- changes you saw in Aravali while growing up, Punjab land amendment act, what was it, u support supreme court stand? What will you do?
You stayed in Hyderabad. What is fish therapy?
Asked M1 to take over
M1: so u r mechanical engineer but history optional. Ur fav history part? Changes in society? How society has been impacted? Was fall of Roman Empire just a political change or society was involved?
What is building block of society?(I told family) How families have evolved overtime? How societies have changed? Changes in society post independence? Nuclear family how u see it? Divorce rate has increased or remained constant or changed? What's Ur perception? Why it has happened? Which pm died post signing an accord? What was accord name? Why he was killed and it's background?
M2: what is euthanasia? Can we go for Singapore model? Santhara? Historically right to die concept? If u hv to frame law on euthanasia what will be three pillars ? What u mean by value system? Do u think defence personnel are a burden and number needs to be reduced and instead amount be spent on development? How u see Indian defence historically? What were the lacunae in past? ( Mam asked next person to take over)
M3: so where is Srinagar? I told jammu and Kashmir. He told he is asking about another Srinagar I said sorry sir I don't know. Then he asked have you heard about Kollam ( I said yes sir) he asked to compare Kollam and Kovalam I apologised that I hv not heard of Kovalam. Then he asked about some beach I told I am not aware( he told it's in Goa and laughed so u haven't been to Goa)I said no sir.then he asked about some beach in Mumbai I told I am not aware of it. Name states having coast west to east, where is Vizag? It's importance? Difference between ins and inhs. Where is defence north hq where is defence western hq. If waterworks dept is there who should be it's CEO. Engineer or civil servant? Why? Tell the names of dynasties who creates cultural link with south east Asia.there contribution. Present status. Where Portuguese landed? Why they were not able to create Indian empire. What went wrong.?
M4: so u r born in Delhi but brought up in Gurgaon. Can u mention Ur stay at both places. Historical places in Haryana period wise. How they can be leveraged to promote tourism. History has been classified as ancient mediaeval and modern. Is there any other approach? What is Magna Carta? What was french revolution? Compare the role of girodins vs Jacobins ? Impact of world events on India. Old age people are neglected do u think matriarchal families value elders more? Slavery in India didn't occur same way as in America how u see it? Historically plus as society. Did slavery never existed in India?
Chair: what is demographic dividend? What is the window given by scholars? How can be achieve it? What can be done? Any other area from Ur daf you want us to cover or you are satisfied with your interview?
Some questions I may have skipped..
Wunwun
Board: Smita Nagraj
DoI: 28th March 2019
Background: Oil Industry
Hobby: Poetry
Pub adm
Chairman:
1. natural resources: Should government have full control?
2. Should private sector be allowed?
3. Coal nationalisation, coal allocation(interrelated and follow up qns)
4. What private sector brings
5. Private sector in other fields etc.
M1
1. TAPI, IPI projects.. feasibility, India role
2. What India can do to secure pipelines
3. How do you see Afganistan-Pakistan relationship
4. Taliban.. should we be worried about taliban coming to power.
5. Some other qns on same theme...India-pakistan-Afganistan-Taliban
M2.
1. Name some Hindi poets
2. Tulsidas ..how do you place him in this?
3. Solar energy...has infinite potential..does that mean we can have infinite energy?
4. What are the obstacles
5. Our renewable energy target?
6. Solar energy vs thermal energy.
M3:
1. IIT, good job...why you want to come to civil service?
2. Your contribution in civil services and in your own industry? How do you see both? Should not you be in oil industry?
3. Someone said for our country " we have enough natural resources for our needs" how do you see the statement ( mentioned about natural gas hydrate in Indian ocean, 5th largest coal reserve)
4. Then we should not focus on renewables, rather focus on these resources? Why we should focus on renewables?( follow up with few questions)
M4:
1. India is a federal country, how the fiscal relationship between state and centre is decided?
2. States say that all the taxes are generated in states, centre gets taxes from it and then returns very less ...is it justifed, are states right? ( Talked about finance commission and equality, allocation aspect)
3. Are finance commission recommendation binding?
4. Does it require parliament approval?
Chairman:
1. How come you stay in Delhi, when you are working in other state( explained my working pattern)
2. Enquired about my work pattern
3. What do you miss most there.
Sai Rohith:
Sai Rohith:
Sai Rohith
ECE, Public administration
3 years Software engineer
Karimnagar, Telangana
Board: Manoj Soni
Date: Mar 28, 2019
Chair:
Why did you change from TechM to another company? No need to say if its personal
Why left software when you are earning good
How do you appraise yourself of International affairs?
Which news papers do you read? Who are the editors?
What do you watch in Youtube?
Indicators of Malnutrition govt should consider for making policy on malnutrition?
Member1:
How metro operates without driver?
Favourite topic in ECE
Difference between 2G, 3G and 4G?
Voice calls use 2G or 3G or 4G?
Member2:
Speciality about Karimnagar
Qsns on Silver Filgree
Reasons for global economic slowdown
Member3:
What is famous about your home town
How do you make Gram Sabha more efficient?
How do you use mobile communication to improve administration
Nirmal paintings
Member4:
What is urban naxalism?
Recent incident?
Which police got intelligence about urban naxalism
Prefernce of services
Situation: You are an IPS and was invited as chief guest by an old age home. Give a speech for 1 minute. (I started saying answer normally. Member asked me to give a speech assuming all 5 here as old age members)
Chairman:
Full form of IAS
What is meant by Ordnance
Last punch: How can you choose Ordnance factory in your preferred list without knowing the meaning
Your interview is over
PS: Overall cordial board. No expressions from Chair - was smiling at times
Ozil_10:
Ozil_10
28 March,forenoon session
Smita Nagarajan maam
B tech (marine engg)
Optional - sociology
Cwmn - y left such a high paying job.
Y engineers quality r low.
Who was montessori (based on the name of my school)
Diff between vocational nd nrml educational institute.
Quality of engg low,,y.
Beside skills ,wat needed for jobs to get.
Give some positives nd negatives of our education system.
If u r made dm ,which olace u choose.(i chose urban areas)
M1- y urban areas,,problem of urban areas,,as a dm how would u control traffic,,hiw would u control pavement(give 2 min speech ).
M2- u lived in hongkong,ruled by one country ,twosystem rule,,dat should be applied to jammu nd kashmir.ur view.
Is election being fair in india ,wat all needed to be done in inida.
Do u think care taker govt system be applied to india in intervening period between elections.
M3- maritime board(couldn't say)
Why every state need ports.
M4- how do u manage stress in ships.
Should military personnel be allowed on ships.(italian marine case.).
Y not apply vocational institues instead of technical institutes.
M4 - y not hockey growing in india.(hobby nd related question)
Should universal franchise be revisited.
Electoral reforms that is needed.
Which country u visited,,what u brought from there.
Cwmn - u talked about ethical skills in institutes ,,wat does dst mean.
Thank you,ur interview is over.
Few more questions ,cant recall.
25-30 mins,,
It was a cordial board.
Pilani_owl
MSc Eco,BE Civil
Optional Law
Hobby Cricket,Drawing
Smita Nagraj mam Board
Come in.
How are you?
What are you doing these days?
Why MSc after BE? (Oh integrated)
MSc vs MA Economics
Why civil to civil services?
Bent of mind for administration? How
Leadership, do civil servants have to be leader? Don't you think that politician's job.
How do you think you as a bureaucrat will manage political pressure?Say if he is saying waive all electricity dues/farm dues.
Ok!
Member 1: Name four Indian economists and their domain areas.
How Prof Amartya Sen is different from others?
What was his significant contribution?
Where we need to improve in HDI?
Why Scandinavian countries are on top?
What is Norway's oil fund for?
Member2
Why law? You seems interested in it.
Syllabus of law?
Kulbhushan Jadhav, what if Pak loose case and doesn't act?
Your areas of interest in civil?
Do you know Prof GD Agarwal?
Drawing? Do something for us.
Member3
Tax terrorism, tyranny of unelected what do you mean?
Budget, populism or forward looking?
Fiscal deviation in budget?
Why are we not spending enough on health, education?
Member 4
Kharif and Rabi crops?
Why named Kharif?
Farmer's distress? What to do.
What is golden rice?
Can transgenic crops beneficial for tribals?
Issues with PDS?
Smita Mam:
Do state civil services allow people from other state?(picked from initial talk)
Some states have domicile requirement? What is your say on restricting outsiders in group B/C services of state?
Thank you, your interview is over!
Satyam:
Name: Satya Prajapat
DOI: 25/03/2019 Afternoon (second to go)
Sujata Mehta mam’s board
Optional: Sociology
Home State: Sujangarh (Rajasthan)
Graduation: Chemical Engineering NIT Warangal
Job Experience: Reliance Industries Ltd. (Biofuels)
Hobby: Reading Hindi fiction
Chairperson
1. Would you like to introduce yourself with your graduation background and job experience, if any.
2. What is the biofuel project you are working upon?
3. Is it a patented technology? Is your company doing is for themselves or are they are doing it for some other company?
4. Your project job role seems fascinating, then why do you want to come into civil services just for file pushing?
5. What was your experience of going to Warangal for graduation? How different it was from your native area?
6. Do you think IAS would be still same attractive even if Home cadre provision is not there?
M1
1. Which route did you take to go to Warangal?
2. Which all states you crossed? What was the topography of region you crossed?
3. Which mountains you crossed?
4. Is Deccan plateau a part of something or an isolated landmass?
5. You crossed Eastern ghats or western ghats?
6. Which LWE affected districts you crossed? (said don’t exactly know)
7. Is Swachch Bharat Mission a success? What changes you felt in your hometown?
8. What was the highlight of Swachchata sarvekshan report?
9. Which was the cleanest city in Rajasthan? (said don’t exactly know)
M2 (Lady member)
1. How do you see the future of petroleum industry?
2. Is RIL doing anything to diversify their profile?
3. Do critical analysis of Mahatma Gandhi.
M3
1. Do you know Tesla? What is it?
2. If the law allows you operate the process at 23% efficiency (you know which law I am taking about) but your boss asks you to do it at 40 %. How would you deal with it?
3. Do you know which law is it? (said sorry sir, I don’t know)
4. I want to make tea and put everything (water, tea leaves, milk, sugar) at once in a bowl and allow it to boil while my friend adds each ingredients in step wise manner (first water and tea leaves and so on). Whose tea will be prepared first?
5. Why to read sociology?
6. What is the most crucial point from where a problem should be tackled nation level, state level or city level?
M4
1. What was your observation of overall experience of Pulwama Incident? How better it should have been tackled? (he framed this question in ambiguous language and I couldn’t answer it properly)
2. What are the two social problems in your native town which was different from Warangal?
3. Who is your icon and why?
Chairperson:
Would you like to discuss anything else? I told Ma’m you can ask me something related to my hobby.
She asked what your hobby is and what is the contemporary book you have read? What was its impression upon you?
Thank you. Your interview is over
Amit:
AMIT KUMAWAT
SUJATA MA'AM
28/03/2019(morning)
biochemical and biotechnology, IIT DELHI
reading book, teaching, jogging and vippassana
Chairman:-
1. Showing other person's photo- is this you?
2. tell me about yourself- educational and professional qualification
3. Why do you want to come to civil services after the engineering
4. How will you use engineering knowledge in the administration
5. How will you use biotech if you are made joint secretary of ministry of law?
6. what if there is no direct scope of use of biotech.
7. what is outcome based solution? Don't you consider values more important that outcome.
8. Case study-> you have two officers one corrupt and efficient and other (inefficient and honest )whom will you choose).
9. What is the importance of the emotional intelligence in the administrative life?
Member -1
10. Which part of India you have visited
11. Do you know about the peninsular India.
12. tell me about the two ranges of the peninsular India
13. What is the vipassana?
14. you have read sanskrit- how the word vipassana has originated?
15. How you do the vipassana?
16. If you get the Tamilnadu cardre - will you go there or will opt for the some other service.
17. Tell me one word from the Tamil.
Member -2
18. You are from rajasthan- which regiment in India belong to Rajasthan (eg; sikh regiment)
19. Western commond headquarter - where it is located?
20. Issue of Kashmiri pandits- what are 3 major problems that will be faced if we try to relocate the kashmiri pandits
21 Tell me two people from public life whom you admire - apart from politician?
22. Follow up questions-> will may get tranfer for multiple times are you ready for that?
23. Some maths question- which I didn't know and said no?
24. What type of maths is used in the AI neural network.
Member-3
25. You are graduate from the biochemical engineering and biotechnology- something related to dual degree
26. What material is used in the implants ( said-> you are from biotech you should know about it)
27. Recently contraversy about the knee implant about the ceramics and steel
28. Which part of rajasthan is demanding for the new state.
Member -4
29. How mathematics is important in our daily lifes.
30. tell me name of two ancient mathematicians
31. Recently there has been contraversy about the "ASTO MAA SADAMAYA, Tamaso maa jyotirgamya" should it be recited in the schools.
32. You are Hindu- if you are asked to recite verse of quoran which is objective in nature will you do it?
33. India Iran relation
34. Should India Antagonise the United states of America in pursuing relation with the Iran.
Chairman->
35. Is there anything which you would like us to ask you? ( I said Ma'am education sector)
Member- 1
36. What is difference between the sarva siksha abhiyan and Right to education
37. What are the issues with regard to the Right to education
38. Which is one provision you will implement in right to education.
Thanks Your interview is over.
Rajanikant:
Name: Rajanikant Chilumula
Date 28/03/2019
Background: Dual degree from IIT Madras (Mech Engg)
Job exp: Gas Turbines Engg in GE
State: Telangana
Hobbies: cycling, music
Board: Manoj Soni Sir
Chairman:
1. Very cordial welcome and made me comfortable. Had some lighter moments about my name and hero
2. Asked about my work profile and my role
3. Energy Policy of India
4. Challenges with the renewable energy sector and how to deal with them
5. Integrated power systems and advanced technologies in it
Memeber1:
1. Why did you take Psychology as optional?
2. Do you think leadership can be taught? Can we make any layman a leader?
3. Do you think Multi National Companies are looting us since all the profits earned by hard work of Indian employees is taken away?
4. How to improve the value of Indian labour?
(Some more questions I can't recall now)
Member 2:
1. What are the threats for our internal security?
2. How to tackle Cyber warfare?
3. Do you think Telangana is developing after its bifurcation?
4. Hyderabad was developed by Telangana politicians. Don't you think they are at loss?
5. Do you think Naxalism has reduced in Telangana post bifurcation?
6. What is red corridor in India? What is the spread of the affected areas?
7. Do you think Telangana would be completely free of naxalism soon?
Member 3:
1. What kind of safety measures do we have to take during cycling?
2. What should be the optimum no. of gears for cycles?
3. What are dreams? What do the modern theories say about dreams?
4. Do you think the dreams that come in the morning will come true?
5. What is OCD? What psychological theories can be used to explain such disorders?
6. What is the status of GE companies shares?
7. What led to the overall GE business's losses?
8. Do you think big companies like GE can go bankrupt?
Member 4:
1. What is the significance of your name?
2. Why did you have to go to Vijayawada to study?
3. Do you support the corporate education system which makes children work like machines?
4. How will you as an administrator ensure quality education in Government schools?
4. People from telugu states are behind development but why do we see a rise in Honour killings in recent times
5. What are the factors that made Hyderabad and Bengaluru IT hub?
6. How will you make sure your staff who will be much senior to you work and cooperate with you?
7. Did you have any dreams recently ?
8. Dream about this interview? Did you perform well? (all started laughing)
Thank you.. your interview is over 🙂
M. Sathiyawati Ma'am Board
Name - Priyanka Shukla
Optional- Geography
Graduation - Electronics & Communications Engg.
State - MP
27 March 2019
Ma'am herself said Good Afternoon as I entered the room. I wished them all in reciprocation.
Ma'am - Showed my Photo and asked - Is this your photo?
She read out Keypoints from My DAF (Background etc)
Ma'am -
1. You are from Kendriya Vidyalaya. What is the Objective behind Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalayas?
2. How are JNVs performing?
3. How KVs different from JNVs?
4. You have been a member of Bharat Scouts &. Guides. What is their Motto?
5. What did you learn as a member of Bharat Scouts & Guides?
6. What are the Objectives of NSS? How different from BS&G?
7. Why so many different organizations and not one? ( BS&G, NSS etc)
M1 -
1. So, you joined Bhart Scouts & Guides at a very young age. What is a young guide called as?
2. What is Innovation. How does it help in nation-building? Also, relate with your educational background.
3. We live in a global village. Innovation anywhere in the world can be used by us. As such, what is the relevance of Domestic Innovation?
4. What are IPRs related with Integrated Circuits (ICs)?
5. What is topography of ICs?
6. Your hobby is Creative Writing. What do you write?
7. Tell one English poet and one Hindi/Urdu Writer you have been inspired by. ( I said Nida Fazli)
8. What is his style of writing?
9. Don't you take interest in sports like playing or watching it? ( I said I play badminton)
10. Who is your favourite Badminton player?
11. You play Singles or Doubles?
12. Where do you place India in the community of Nations? As a strong nation, as a weak nation or as an indifferent nation?
M2 -
1. So, your optional is Geography. What Continents are there and how they have been formed?
2. India is surrounded by Himalayas in the North and by Ocean on three sides. What is the problem related with Himalayas that India faces?
3. GPS vs GPRS
4. How Google Maps estimates traffic density?
5. What is difference between Shayari and Ghazal?
M3 -
1. Recently, there was a controversial SC judgement in which SC said - Sometimes even " No means Yes". What is your opinion about this judgement?
2. Are you aware of legislations regarding Sexual Harassment?
3. Can you name some high-profile sexual harassment cases?
4. #MeToo movement - should women come out with such allegations?
5. You come from a Technical background. What was the proportion of Girls to boys in your College?
6. Do you think there is equal access to Technical Education for Girls and Boys?
7. What barriers are their to Girl Education apart from Parental Aspirations in rural areas?
8. Are you aware of History of Bhopal? It was ruled by Begums. How did their rule come into force in Bhopal?
9. What is the significance of Sanchi Stupa?
M4 -
1. Give me an honest answer, Why do you want to join Civil Services?
2. We see people violating laws e.g. Traffic Rules. Suppose you are posted in a City like Delhi. How would you ensure that people follow rules?
3. Suppose you have been made Dist. collector in your own district. What steps would you take to change mindset of people towards Girl Education.
4. Suppose you are made the Brand Ambassador of Girl Education. What one-liner would you use for Girl Education Promotion Programme?
Ma'am -
Your Interview is over. All the Best!
Ma'am was very cordial. Gave nods during most of the answers. Smiled throughout. Two Members tried and maintained Blank expressions during most of the Interview except for their own turn of asking questions when they sounded enthusiastic.
vamshi:
Sujata mam
Mathematics optional
HAL
Tell me about your education background?
Why you left Hal?
Are you satisfied by working at HAL?
What is CDS?
Why army is divided into regiments based on state(don't know this)
Tell me one artificial intelligent application that we carry in our pockets?
What is difference between IIT and NIT?
When is NITW established?
Do you support women in combat role?
Do you think women can't do mathematics?
Who is shakuntala devi?
What is Nobel prize in mathematics?
Tell me one mathematician who got Nobel?
Contributions of betrrend Russel?
Do you support introduction of sanskrit prayers in KVs?
Did we missed any areas that you prepared and we have not asked?
There are some questions which I can't remember now.
Board is very cordial.
Rahul Koppati:
Rahul Koppati
28-3-2019, Afternoon.
Bhim Sen Bassi Sir board
5 th to go.
Chairman:
1. You worked for Economic Times. Only Technology or articles also?
2. What is paid news?
3. How is money paid for paid news?
4. Do you think the person who gives money for paid news wants to be identified?
M1:
1. What is Brexit? Who are all protesting? Why did Theresa May threaten to resign?
2. What are fundamental rights?
3. Forgot right to education?
4. Right to Property? Status? Why relegated? 1st amendment?
4. How are they enforced?
5. What is 73rd Amendment?
M2:
1. What is give it up campaign? Why needed?
2. How many people have given up?
3. How to make LPG subsidy scheme sustainable?
4. What is relation between Give it up and Ujjwala?
5. Who will benefit from Ujjwala? Do you think poor people can afford LPG?
6. Tribals?
7. What is recent Supreme Court judgement with respect to Forest Rights? Why forest rights act enacted?
8. Are people from your state effected? Why?
9. If implemented, will there be any impact on environment?
M3:
1. Issues between India and China? How are we trying to overcome?
2. Border disputes? How to deal with them? Give any innovative solution to settle the disputes once and for all?
3. Doklam issue? Is it disputed? Or being claimed by China? How did India handle the issue?
M4:
1. After bifurcation, which state do you think is doing better? Telangana or Andhra Pradesh?
2. Analyze the issues between Andhra Pradesh and Union Government objectively?
3. Data localization. Isn't it additional cost on companies?
I couldn't answer to the Chairman's question properly. But as the interview progressed, I could put my points more assertively. Especially with respect to state related issues.
Yashpratap Shrimal:
25th March forenoon
Last to go
Board TC Anant
Chairman:
1.What is your name? (Referring to my longer name)
2. Real time strategic gaming(hobby) - what is so real about it?
3.How do you play? Do you have different strategies? Any examples of such games?
4.how would you apply in the real world scenario?
5. What strategy/strategies India should apply against Pakistan?
Member 1(the toughest part)
1.what have you been doing so long in the exam? And why? Don't you feel the need for doing something different?
2. How do keep yourself motivated and positive?
3.What is macivers view(still don't know what he asked) (sociology optional)
4.Weber on bureaucracy and attributes of bureaucracy.
5.Talcott parsons and his view on social institutions.
6.comparison between functionalism and structural functionalism.
7.what should be a civil servants priority when he joins district administration for the first time?
Member 2:
1.What is bri? (international relations hobby)
2.What has been india's strategy?
3.What should India do?
4.Do you watch movies? Which one is your favorite? What did it teach you? (hobby documentaries)
5.You are the security advisor to the government of India. Two strategy you would suggest?
Member 3:
1.What are clean technologies?
2.is solar energy a clean technology?
3.What are the problems in shifting to solar energy completely?
4.Will international solar alliance be successful?
Here chairman intervened and asked if solar energy is really a clean technology?
Tell me some instances?
Member 4:
1.What are sdg?
2.Why needed?
3.Who is nodal agency in India?
4.Maharashtra is successful in reducing malnutrition through a very successful policy in 1980S.What has it done?
5. What is stunting?
6. Do you think midday meals are necessary? I believe that all the intervention should be at the pregnancy and infant level and midday meal be scrapped. Your opinion?
7.It has been 30 years since pri(panchayats) started. How successful has it been? Highlight the success stories of your state. Now highlight what are the concerns of the pris.
8.apart from mahatma Gandhi tell me in brief about one leader after independence that you admire the most? And why?
Chairman: would you like us to ask anything? I answered football.
1.Why football
2 enlighten me on the future of football in india
3.what role does it play in the society?
Anything more would you like to ask.
Thank you your interview is over.
The board was very cordial.
Chairman sir was smiling as always. This meant i never lost my smile in the interview.
Kiran Yadav
Board - Bassi sir
Optional - Commerce
Date 28/3/2019
Afternoon session, last one to go.
Chairman
Why left CA? PMs address on CAs.Name of company audited
Member 1
1.What's GDP?
2.What's GNP?
3.What if a person marries a working woman and she leaves job what effect it wud be on GNP?
4.Whats inflation?
5.Is it good or bad?
6.Good for whom bad for whom
7.Whats price index
8.Who issues CPI and WPI
9.Whats frequency of revision of inflation?
Member2
1.How financial position is analysed?
2.Whats Current ratio, quick ratio ?
3.Whats cash flow and funds flow?
4.Whats Ujala- I said LPG scheme, he said no..another..I said women scheme he said no..he mean light 🤣 pointed towards ceiling and asked what's that..I said LED .ok how it's good .I said less energy consumption.Further asked what more..is it more illuminating.I said no idea through expressions.🤣
5.whats other scheme's of govt for environment
I said Renewable energy targets, target under Paris, bioethanol, solar energy, methanol economy,reduction of sulphur content in coal for thermal power plants.He said why? Coal is carbon how sulphur dioxide.
6.Carbon credit
7.Carbon sink
8.Any technology for carbon sequestration..i said sir I am not able to recall .🤣.chairman interrupted...she is commerce student..how she will know.
Member 3
1.Does India has signed MFN with any south east Asian countries? After telling everything that's it's on default for WTO members still he asked can u name..I said no sir.
2.Issues in RCEP- told China n FD, Singapore n skorea manufacturing countries so effect make in India, newzealand n Australia dairy industries may effect, India's
3 .Should India sign it? Yes sir important for integration of India's economy with work
Member 4
1.Whats issue in Ecom
2.Should govt give benefit Customers
3.Whats mechanism for compliance n performance audit
4.Whats internal and external audit
Chairman gave case study
There is a training institute and last year 10 candidate failed n this year 14 .Whose fault is this.poor Training ?
Bushara Bano:
Bushara Bano
Satyavarthi madam board
Afternoon session
4th one to go
I entered in interview room. I greeted everyone. Chairperson welcomed me. She read my DAF and told about my PhD, postdoctrate qualification and 8 years of job.
She asked after so much why civil services?
What are your service preferences?
How your optional Management going to help you in civil services?
Women of Saudi Arabia are not getting due rights. Is it so?
What is the sex ratio and literacy level of saudi people?
Why more women than men?
M-1 Sabrimala issue.
Saudi- India relations.
Energy security of India. How saudi is helping?
Some questions not able to recall.
M-2 Perfume industry of Kannuj (DAF)
Why it is declining?
What to do to make it efficient?
What is change management?
How will you implement change in your organization?
Why people resist to change?
Why is informal communication important?
Are you a part of any informal group?
M-3 Do you think india is more racist than other countries?
Advertisements in india for matrimony are related to tall, beautiful girls. Racism is everywhere.
Women from NorthEast feel alienated in Northern India due to racist attitude of boys. What to do to eliminate such behavior.
M-4 Phd Thesis related questions.
Major stressors among police.
Different stress level of male vs women police.
Should all women police stations be there for decreasing crimes against women.
What are the problems of women police in UP?
Women education is not up to mark. What are the reasons?
Why Brexit and election of Trump in America? Its because of migration issue or some other reasons?
Thank you. Your interview is over.
Overall very cordial and involved board. Thank you.
Important Alert:
Today is last date of Attestation form submission. Those appeared in Interview this year please ensure you have filled it. 🙏
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Important Alert: Today is last date of Attestation form submission. Those appeared in Interview this year please ensure you have filled it. 🙏»
If anyone else wants to share his/her CSE 2018 transcript, do share in next 2 3 days. We will be revoking pm links soon. Final Compilation will come whenever feasible.
🙏🙏🙏
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «If anyone else wants to share his/her CSE 2018 transcript, do share in next 2 3 days. We will be revoking pm links soon. Final Compilation will come whenever feasible. 🙏🙏🙏»
RDB:
Sathiyavathi Panel
25 min
28th March 2019
Optional and graduation: Law
Chairperson
Q. 4-5 questions related to DAF, meaning of name, job experience and so on.
Q. Have you heard of the surrogacy law? Why is it controversial?
Q. What about the organ donation law?
Q. What is the difference between a law and a code?
M2
Q. Mumbai is the financial capital... (long description). Let me ask you about banks. Recently many female heads of banks have been implicated. What is your take on it?
Q. Why do you want to get into the Civil service.
Q. Should lawyers become politicians? Is that acceptable? What is your view?
Q. Give some solutions for malnutrition in rural areas.
M3
Q. Let's talk about law. Are you comfortable with jurisprudence?
Q. OK good. What is the relationship between law and morality? In case of a conflict, what would you choose?
Q. Any recent law that shows this dichotomy? That was changed.
Q. Are all fundamental rights part of the basic structure? If you were a judge deciding the EWS Amendment, what would he your stand?
Q. What are your views on the sedition law. But law commission advocates its scrapping.
M4
Q. What is a bullion market?
Q. How does it impact the larger economy?
Q. Which sector of the economy does it affect?
Q. What is the difference between a statute and a gazette?
Q. What is the Belt and Road Initiative? What are the issues with it?
M5
Q. What is the difference between travel and exploration?
Q. Where have you been? You've already mentioned these places. Ohh Andaman. And where else? And?
Q. What is the reason for social reforms in Kerala? In addition to literacy. Historical reasons.
Q. What do you read? What kind of fiction?
Q. Why do you like reading short stories?
Q. Any other authors? Manto, Roald Dahl? Which foreign authors?
Q. Name any stories you've read.
Q. Besides your family members, who is a female role model you look up to?
Q. It is said that the Swachh Bharat Mission is only about building toilets. Your take.
Thank you
http://quest.forumias.com/topic/61/cse-2018-final-result-insider-info-bakar-and-speculation-thread
Important Announcement for those who know me for long through discussion Forum (discuss.forumias.com) :
I am shifting permanently from old Discuss forum to new and better Quest Forum.
My Quest platform id - @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh
http://quest.forumias.com/user/yo_yo_choti_singh
http://quest.forumias.com/topic/59/forum-oldies-attendance-thread
http://quest.forumias.com/topic/60/prelims-all-types-of-doubts-asking-thread
http://quest.forumias.com/topic/61/cse-2018-final-result-insider-info-bakar-and-speculation-thread
Always there to help anyone and everyone for any CSE related issues/doubt/problems/queries et al.
Hopefully the old glory of forum as KNOWLEDGE SHARING AND LEARNING PLATFORM FOR CSE ASPIRANTS revives on new Quest Forum.
Jai Hind. Ram Ram g. :)
#Hum_Honge_Kamyab_Ek_Din
#Being_IAS_4_U_Onlyyy
aspirant18:
27/03/2019
Sujata Mehta Madam Board
Afternoon session (1st to go)
IITD, Mech Engg
Hyderabad, Telangana
Hobbies: Cricket and TED talks
Chairperson
1. What is this fish medicine that is used in Hyderabad? Do you know about it?
2. Can you tell me about the work you have done on the kilns? (B.Tech Project)
3. What is the current status of the project? Can you scale it up to a larger level?
4. You have interned @ HUL. So you haven’t you thought of pursuing your career there?
5. Why do you watch TED talks? What attracts you the most?
M1
1. Which is your favourite state in India and favourite country (except India)?
2. Do you know about the new island being constructed by Japan? Name 3 famous cities of Japan (Answer to earlier question)?
3. Which of them is most famous for technology?
4. What is Shinkansen? What is the maximum speed that a bullet train can attain?
5. Name 3 cities of Telangana? Which do you think is best? Why?
6. How is electric car different from a conventional car? How much % of moving parts have been reduced in the former compared to latter?
7. Who is the leading wicket taker in test cricket?
8. What is your evaluation of AICTE? Is it relevant or should be done away with? Can you suggest some measure to improve engineering in the country?
M2
1. Do you have any kind of exposure to rural life? How do you find the administration there?
2. What is the difference between IITs and other engineering colleges in India?
3. It is generally seen that alumni of IITs contribute to foreign economies! What is your opinion on that? Do you think we should make them work at least a year in rural India?
4. What do you bring to civil services?
5. Do you watch TED talks in any particular field or general?
6. Do you read books? Any specific field or general?
7. Do you have any bucket list in life? What is the thing that keeps you motivating? What is it that you have learnt recently?
M3
1. Did you receive the KVPY scholarship money (DAF)? Why did you choose engineering over science?
2. Are you aware of the concept of hierarchy of laws? ( you can take a guess)
3. What is the difference between laws and rules?
4. Is there any mechanism for legislature to ensure that the delegated legislation is performed properly by the executive? Can you tell me something about Public Accounts Committee?
5. What is charged expenditure? Can you tell some examples related to it? (After the answer he told not to forget the place where I was sitting! (UPSC) )
6. Do you follow Supreme Court judgements? What is your opinion on Collegium system? Was there no independence of Judiciary before the collegium system?
M4
1. When did you choose to join civil services and what motivated you?
2. There is a notion that doctors and engineers from publicly funded institutions like IITs don’t opt for their respective graduation subject careers? Don’t you think it is a loss to the exchequer?
3. Can you tell me about the integration Hyderabad into India?
4. Was there any proposal of Hyderabad joining Pakistan? Then why joined Hyderabad ultimately?
5. Can you tell me in which districts of Telangana Naxalism is still prevalent? Why the name naxal?
6. Have you watched any TED Talk on UBI?
Chairperson
Do you want to ask or say anything to us?
Ok Then. Your interview is over!
Unknown
Board: B B Vyas Sir
First one to go in the Board, Time: 10 AM
Optional : Sociology
Date: 28.03.19
Chairman
Q1. What does Paras India do?
Q2. Why so you think in some states, NGO are more prominent than other states? Give me sociological reason.
Q3. Should NGO be regulated?
Q4. But they are voluntary organisations?
Q5. What do you know about Contraceptive Jewellery?
Q6. Any hormone related to this?
Member 1
Q7. What was the role of George Fernandes in Bihar during emergency of 1970?
Q8. What is anti-defection law?
Q9. Tell me three pro-poor schemes of both UPA and NDA government.
Q10. What is financial literacy?
Member 2
Q11. What are the steps taken by government to develop Biotechnology sector?
Q12. How do you see the future of this sector?
Q13. But students from your institute do not join core engineering sector. How can you say it is on the right track?
Q14. What is Alzheimers?
Q15. Do we have any drugs to cure it?
Member 3
Q16. What is the difference between Alzheimers and Parkinsons?
Q17. You know China is an adversary. There is no doubt about that. But I am not interested in China. Rather I am concerned about Pakistan. What has been the strategy of India to deal with Pakistan?
Q18. What has been the recent change in the Indus Water Treaty strategy?
Q19. What is the news which was announced yesterday by the PM of India? (it was about ASAT)
Q20. Why do we need ASAT?
Q21. What has been the international reaction in this regard?
Q22. What they say about orbital debris?
Q23. Do you think it is dangerous?
Member 4
Q24. Why Madhubani painting is so well known?
Q25. How can migration from Bihar be tackled effectively?
Q26. Do you think Bihar government has worked well to improve the status of education and health?
Chairman
Q27. In economic survey, there was a term "decoupling". Do you know about it?
Thank you for being with us.
28th march
Home state - Bihar
Optional - chemistry
Work ex- currently in ifos. Earlier Ongc
Manoj soni board.
I was the last to go in evening
Chairman went through entrie DAF
Chairman: u r from Madhubani, you must have prepared well hence I will not ask from there.
1. Tell me the theme song of IIT Bhu.
2. You hv technical background & 5+yrs of work ex. Will u stay in Forest service or willing to go back to corporate sector?
3. I don't think that in our life time kashmir issue will b solved. If you get a chance, how will you proceed to solve this? (almost 8 min of argument & counter argument)
M1:
1. There is growing movement towards protectionism in world. Why?
2. What's the issue between ongc & hpcl?
3What is the progress of social forestry in India?
4. I want to have my own private social forest. Is it legally possible?
5.Tell me something about Chemistry of life.
M2:
1. Madhubani painting?
2.What is the status of Ganga river cleaning in varanasi?
3.As a DM in your district, what will be your priority area?
4.Why science subject popularity is decreasing in india?
M3:
1.How China relationships with Nepal will effect India?
2.How prevention of flood will effect agricultural productivity in Bihar?
3.How Gujarat is different from Bihar?
M4:
1.Why Bihar lagged behind other states in development?
2.Pakistan keep on instigating terrorist activity in different cities of India. What is d purpose behind it?
3.Will you leave Ifos if you get Into IPS?
Chairman:
Last question: If your senior gives you a legal order with which you don't agree. What will you do?
Thank you
Ramesh N
26 March
MANOJ Soni board
Academics: Masters in Information Security
Optional : Public Administration
Geo: Adilabad, Telangana
Hobby: Badminton
Interview was for ~30 mins.
Chairman
1.what have you been engaged in these days?
2. What was the issue in IT act few years ago( 66A)
2. How to address data colonization problem.
3. Is there any law on data protection across globe which we can follow to enact our law?
M1
1. What is PPP? Has it been successful in India?
2. Isn't it shutting off government duty?
3. How can we evaluate ppp?
M2
1. Are you happy with the bifurcation of telanaga and Andhra Pradesh ? How do you see the progress so far?
2. Express your take aways about the success of badminton in Hyderabad.
3. What was issue in Adilabad few years ago? ( I spoke about tribal Issue) followup question to bring discussion on Naxalism
4. Who spearheaded Naxalism in Andhra pradesh?
5. What are the reasons for Naxalism?
M3
1. How to play cross court shot in badminton?
2. How to hold racket while hitting smash, and while playing a drop?
3. Why has the electronic industry not developed in India? And follow up questions
M4( lady member )
1. Why is your district backward? Reasons?
2. Do you support division of districts in Telangana? Why?
3. Is MGNREGA success? Why?
4. Don't you think MGNREGA is leading to Alcoholism, increased wages in agri labour causing loss to agriculture?
5. What is the relationship between China and India?
Chairman
1. If NAXALITES are causing violence and not surrendering, should we kill them BRUTALLY, MERCILESSLY?
Your interview is over. All the very best for your future.
ABHISHEK GOSWAMI:
Abhishek Goswami
Afternoon session (3rd to go)
Sujata Mehta Ma’am’s Board
Optional: Sociology
From: Agra
B-Tech in Civil Engg (IIT Delhi)
1st Attempt
Chairman
1. Is this your photograph?
2. Would you like to introduce yourself giving your educational background?
3. Were you offered any campus placements or you rejected them?
4. Why you chose civil services?
5. Would you like to tell us about the social environment in IIT?
6. What do you like most about the social culture in your college?
7. Ok, tell us about any social presumption that you found not being true after your stay in IIT?
8. Do you think IITs promote Conformity?
9. Is obedience considered as a virtue or a vice in IIT?
10. So how it encourages Innovation and do you agree that social innovation is quite different from innovation?
Member 1
1. How many times have you visited Taj Mahal? How do you feel when you see it?
2. How will you increase tourism in Agra?
3. Other than Taj Mahal what else is there for tourists?
4. Besides these monuments and structures, what else Agra has to offer?
5. What are the famous cuisines of Agra which attracts tourists?
6. What about the cleanliness situation in Agra?
7. The vendors, locals are aware that cleanliness will increase the tourism, still why do people indulge in polluting the city?
Member 2
1. Are you aware of the term green buildings?
2. Tell us about advance materials?
3. What is low cost housing and how it’s done?
4. Which is the longest Railway Bridge in India?
5. Why is it called as a civil engineering marvel, what’s special about it?
6. You like teaching, what domain in civil engineering do you feel you have speciality in?
7. Do you know about cantilever bridge?
8. Why are other Humanities disciplines taught to engineers? Is it useful?
9. Tell us about the term Liberal arts?
10. Okay one last question, you are to go on an expedition in an area which have no resources and no population, what will you do?
Member 3
1. Tell us about employment situation in India?
2. How will you improve employment in the country?
3. What are labour intensive jobs?
4. Some questions on startup’s, can they help in massive job creation?
5. Tell us how the big stones in the historical structures were kept together, they don’t have cement then, what was the binding material?
6. Have you heard of Catalonia? Tell us about it?
7. Catalonia has been part of Spain since 15th century why suddenly they want to have separation?
Member 4
1. We see countries like US, Canada, UK making big things like Google etc, what has been the contribution of IITs other than in e-commerce?
2. Why not so many big innovations from IITs?
3. What role finances have in creativity and talent?
4. What specifically regarding our education system which acts as a hurdle to start ups?
Chairman
1. Do you want us to ask anything else from your DAF?
2. Okay, tell us about your views on High speed railways?
3. What about Railway safety, what should be done for it?
4. Have you heard of surge pricing? Do you support it?
Member 3
(asks chairman to ask one last question since I have mentioned railways)
1. Tell us about tunnel 10 that has recently been completed in north east.
Chairman
Okay, your interview is over. Thank You.
@crux_insider_info_Speculation
Channel for cruxified insider info/speculation