UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 8 Mar 2019
8 Mar 2019
Balram Meena
DANICS 2014
IRTS CSE 2015 exam, did not join
IIT Kgp, Civil Engg, Rajasthan
Hobbies- Cricket, Badminton
Chairperson: Smita Nagraj
8th March, 2019 FN, 3rd to go
Chairperson
1- Balram, there is a confusion, IRTS and you are working in Lakshadweep as Director Tourism
2- why, you have to give me the reasons for not joining IRTS?
3- But IRTS is a good service(i smiled). What if you will not make in to IAS?
4- What is the nearest land part to Lakshadweep?
5- from Kochi?
M1
1- Balram, you are well versed with tourism sector, okay we will talk about Tourism in Kerala , which has already established itself in tourism, known as “gods own country”. What potential tourism attractions it is having?
2-Kerala is also having lot many inland waterbodies like lakes, ponds etc. how can we develop tourism there?
3-Yes thekkedy is having so many houseboats. What about rivers?
4: what else we can use them, the floating solar panels is a new concept coming up.
5. Okay in sea or lagoon?
6. Ohhk, yes in sea they will not able to stand the sea waves and wind. Even in Lakshadweep, you will be having more sunny days.
M2
1. Balram, if you dont mind i will ask that you belong to Meena community, why they are successful?
2. Anything else?
3. Anything else?
4. Okay, now tell me. There is one IAS officer who has been transferred 55 times in 21 years of service. His batchmate batchmate has only been transferred 22 times. Who is more successful?
5. So what might be the reasons for so frequent transfers?
6. Okay you have said that success of civil servant will depend upon implementation of projects etc. but doing that also there might be compromises have to do.
7. Balram, why SC has given 2 years fixed tenure for DGP , but not to CS?
8. But why the stability is given to DGP, as stable tenure is desirable to other civil servants also.
9. The perceptions is yours also?
M3-
1. Okay, so you might be referring that there is more interaction between police and politicians.
2. As per the discussion ,i think you want to go into All India Services. Why so?
3. You will be promoted to IAS, how much time it is taking?
4. Okay, so what things one person at individual level might be missing in Central Services?
5.But in specialised services, one can be expert of a subject. In IRS IT, you can be chairman CBDT and after the retirement, you services will be sought by many. But in Generalist services, you can not be expert.
6. Okay, which sectors will you choose for domain knowledge?
7. Tourism, due to your current posting.
8.Are these jobs in India or world level?
9.You told about the stability of tenure, what should be the ideal tenure? Both longer tenure and shorter tenure are not good.
F1-
1.You told about tourism, but i was there in Lakshadweep, its not very good. Lakshadweep is having complete prohibition, does it affects the tourism.
2. So how do you tell them, do you fight with them?
3. Maldives is almost same with Lakshadweep, it is having around 1200 islands and same is with the Lakshadweep?
4. How many are inhabited? Me: only 10 islands are inhabited, rest are uninhabited.
5. Maldives is very ahead in tourism from Lakshadweep. Did you learn something from them.
6. You tell me two most important problems india is facing? Or maximum 3.
7. Be specific, what do you want to say is it literacy or jobs?
8. Okay thats what you want to say. Now tell me about internal security challenges.
Chairperson
1. Balram, you have talked about the opportunities and challenges in civil services. How will you make any difference in Lakshadweep as an individual?
2. Have you take any special measures for fragile ecology for tourism. How will you make any difference in Lakshadweep as an individual?
2. Have you taken any special measures for fragile ecology for tourism.
3. Balram, are you aware about the recent developments regarding the issue between LG and Delhi Govt. Do you think this can be better managed?
4. But is it required that these issues come out in open?
5. Who should be the referee between Govt and LG, central govt, courts or the kh
ap panchayat?
6. Then who will interpret the constitution?
7. But can the courts interpret every issue? Is it advisable and feasible to go to the courts?
Thank you Balram, you interview is over.
I wished Smita ma’am and lady member Happy women’s day.
Ma’am wished be back Happy women’s day.
I said thank you ma’am and came out of the chamber.