Interviews

UPSC interview, P. K. Joshi board, 7 Mar 2019

7 Mar 2019

Unkown P K Joshi Sir, 7th March Morning, second last in group, 30 Minutes.

Chairman : 1. So you have a very good name. All Laughed, I said thank you sir 2. Compare your District(sawai madhopur) with Indore (Graduation). 3. During your graduation did u visit any wind power nearby?(No sir) 4. Any other (yes, Solar)5. what is capacity 6. how much land it requires for 1 MW? 7.How can we use dead and dry wells(i said composting, bio-remediation, gobar gas, rainwater harvesting) 8. how can we use croop residue? (fodder, waste to energy and झोपड़ी banane mein) . 9. Any Idea About rice husk used in (Sorry Sir,) 10. Sugarcane residue used in (i said in molassis and others) M1.1. What you studied in electrical engineering in graduation?(explained yearwise..basic to specialisation). 2. what can be done to decrease the area of solar plant land requirement?(Solar tree type initiative and technology improvement like increasing concentration of radiation) 3.research in solar energy(i said there are schemes but i am not able to recall..i said targets we have set, 100GW by 2022) 4. any data on reduced land size (gave example of west bengal where solar tree have reduced it) 5. what kind of job prospects in electrical( I said core comapnies are not much attracting but integrated language and sofatware companies are attracting well). 6. scope for enterprenuership in electrical (i said there are many, we are electronic import based country and in renewables we have high potential) M2. 1.What is IEEE?(research paper published at IEEE) 2. Save the girl child(marathon organised) related schemes by government? 3. which writers have u studied in hindi literature in your course? 4. compare Hindi literature of changing times. 5. what is incredible india? M3: 1. Have u seen incredible india? 2. Tell me about Nalanda University? 3.Present status(New Nalanda we have come up)? 4. who is V-C ?(Sorry sir, dont know) 5. Two lines of any poem of Ramdhari Singh Dinkar.(from Kurukshetra : छीनता हो सत्व कोई, और तू

त्याग-तप के काम ले यह पाप है।

पुण्य है विच्छिन्न कर देना उसे,बढ रहा तेरी तरफ जो हाथ हो।)

(in Veer ras type i recited)

(all laughed ) M4: 1.What type of agriculture u do (kharif and rabi). 2. What is difference between cultivating tomato and brinjal and other crops. 3.Technology used in solar tree (I said it is concentration of solar radiation, he said it arnd that only) Chairman Said Thank You, You can go now.

Thank You Sir

Some questions i am not able to recall😊

S N:

Chariman : PK Joshi

3rd to go in the Morning 7th march

Chairman :

1. You have completed your graduation in 2015 , what are you doing since then?

2. School for girls in line with Navodaya Vidyalaya ? When does it started ?

3. Success of Sarva Shikshs Abhiyan and challenges?

4. What are the problems in Secondary Education

5. How to improve tourism potential in Uttar Pradesh

6. Difference between Applied and Eng Physics

M1

1. About Aravali Location and Recent bill of Harayana Govt related to that ( Question asked due to mention of Aravali Hostel in my DAF )

2. Science Day ...Raman effect application and all

M3(Lady)

1. Should we go for prohibition and its social impact

2. Reason of Kedarnath devastation and how will you handle it as a DM

3. Meaning of your name

M4:

1. India Nepal relation

2. Indias role in Madhesi blockade

M5:

1. How to improve farmer income especially in eastern Uttar Pradesh and reason of low farm income

2. Question and discussuion related to GMO crops

Sumeet Meharda:

Satyavathi Ma'am board

March 7, 2019

3rd to go

CM:

Scra. Why did you leave?

What do you think, did you make the right decision?

How do you find IITB better?

Currics, co currics vs extra currics?

What did you do in extra currics?

SC decision on ayodhya, rafale today?. Relate ayodhya to sabrimala decision? Isn't there dichotomy?

What do you think should be done about Ayodhya- a verdict or mediation? Why?

M1:

OIC

Should we have done that?

But what about the adverse statement then?

UAE, Saudi and Pak. Can we pressurise them to act against Pak. Why or why not?

Football formations?

Diamond formation?

Which formation do you like and why?

M2:

Are you comfortable with economy?

GDP? India's Gdp growth

fiscal deficit? What is the current value?

Debt to gdp ratio?-- i forgot!

India has a demographic dividend, to prevent it from becoming disaster we should....?

Why youth comes out in numbers in any protest nowadyas? Is there a deeper malaise?

M3

Latest news in football: Ajax beating Madrid

Prohibition? On alcohol ? Ur views?

Where has it been done? Has it brought any benefit?

Why others are not doing it?

What about cigarettes, they are more dangerous, doctors even prescribe alcohol in some cases? Why are we not banning cigarettes?

Asked if I stayed in Bihar for long? 10 days

Did you travel to Munger?

M4 ; not audible!

NAM is defunct. Comment. Who were the leading nations?

What is India's foreign policy in this regard?

Assam deaths due to liquor? Was it govt failure?

Some Assam related Q. I did not know.

Is India federal democracy or union democracy?

Ghanshyam:

Place : Rajasthan

Work exp: Powerplant

Hobbies : volleyball and badminton

Background: IIT Kharagpur , mechanical

P k Joshi sir board

1/03/2019 , 25-30min .

Chairman : so passed out and have been working since then , and preparing too ?

Why do u want to leave ur organisation and join civil services ?

What is society ?

What is socialism , capitalism , communism?

What are similarities in Indian economy and china economy ?

M1 : what is diff between IIT AND NIT ?

Why IIT are famous ?

( told about famous alumini ) he added arvind kejriwal ...and laughed

What can u do to boost agriculture using mechanical engg . ?

Explained how china' s agriculture is so advanced ...

M2 : my district is communally sensitive ....so asked me what 3 steps as dm u will do to ?

Asked about what will u do to young people indulging in violence ? What is unity in diversity ?

M3(lady member) : she was smiling and giving some hints and nodding .

Give me 1 eg. Where u used ur work exp. To solve problem. Of society ?

Have u heard of shg ? .....is there anything like shg in agri .......i told about cooperatives .....then FPO .....

Then follow up ques. On degrading values in society ....

M4 :aajkal to hume log buddha bolte hai koi buzurg nhi bolta ......

Then something on throwaway society.

Why Northeast development lagged for so long ?

Some questions on values and ethics .

Chairman : Thank you . Overall cordial board , chairman didnot show any signs.......blank expression .no questions related to power sector or hobbies ......mostly society , agriculture and values .

Murali:

Ch:- Smitha nagaraj

Forest Ranger

1 Where you posted ?

2 How long you have been working?

3. 6 years ?

4. Due for transfer?

5. Why transfer officers

Challenges ?

6. Why convictions low ?

Member 1

1.What are the programmes undertaken by govt under national integration for kashmir

2.Blood donation side effects(DAF)

3.Uses

4.???

Member 2

1.Fc act 1980

2.Do you think it's correct to divert area

3.Sc on recent evictions of tribals

4.Ayodhya dispute what is the solution?!

5.What will you chose forest service or administrative service

Member 3 lady

1.Gst

2.How will it benefit economy

3.Triple talaq

4.What government did

5.What is ordinance

6.What will you consider while framing environment policy

Member 4

1.Are you satisfied with your job ?

2.how would you know that you will get satisfaction in IAS ?

3.North East forest cover is more but difficult to create infrastructure

4.What are disadvantages of forest

Ch:-

1) e commerce - change of policy by govt

Is it good?

2) But Consumers will not get much discounts , then how?

3) How can small sellers compete ?

4) What type of incentives for small sellers ?

Overall cordial board

Prateek:

Optional – Management

Home State – MP

DOI – 5th March 2019

Education – B.Tech, MBA

Hobbies – Singing, Fitness

Board – M Sathiyavathy Madam

Duration : 30 – 32 mins

GENERAL OBSERVATIONS

• Chariman was attentive throughout, checked her watch towards the end

• All members were smiling and acknowledging answers

CM: Showing my passport photograph – Is this you ?

CM - Reading out DAF to other members – he has done this .. then this .. belongs to this place. After all of this why do you wish to join civil services ?

CM – But isn’t the bureaucracy a failure in our country. IN 75 years, we still have almost 30% people poor in the country. What do you think?

CM – Okay. But what about health and education – we are very poor in those sectors.

CM – So what do you think about lateral entry in civil services ?

CM – So what should we do then ?

CM – You have worked in CRISIL. How was the work there ?

CM – Okay which verticals ?

CM – Great. But you didn’t tell me how was the work – did you like it ?

M1 – So , Govt has done many reforms in its term – what are some of the big reforms that the Govt has done in the last 5 years in terms of Indian economy, what issues are still pending and what is the way forward ? Take your time and answer.

M1 – Are you forgetting a big reform related to the twin balance sheet problem that you mentioned ? Something related to the banks ?

M1 – No something else ?

M1 – What about the IBC Code ?

M1 – Okay good. You were in a rock band. What do you do ?

M3 – Oh you are a poet also ? Do you write poetry ?

M1 – Can you recount a couplet from whatever you have written ?

M2 – So you have done computer science engineering. Recently Government launched the Electronics policy – what are its key positives ?

M2 - What are the other provisions regarding (forgot what he asked)

M2 – Okay, no worries. But if you had to suggest improvements to the electronics industry as a whole. What would you suggest ?

M2 – What can the government do for that ?

M2 – Okay. So these NRIs, they are not investing in the country – they have so much wealth that they accumulate – but why are they not investing ?

M3 – may I know your service preferences ?

M3 – I want to understand why all of you people are putting IAS at the top and IFS lower ? Humare time pe toh everyone wanted to join IFS. What is the reason ?

M3 – Okay. Lets say you get the Postal Service – will you join ?

M3 – You will join? Sure ?

M3 – (not wanting to hear the reason) Okay tell the reason

M3 –Accha lets talk about this India Pakistan, Pulwama, WC Abhinandan. How do you see Imran Khan’s stature in the world right now? Has it improved in terms of his face value ?

M3 – but theyre saying he should get a Nobel Peace Prize. What do you think ?

M3 – So Kashmir. What is the issue how can we solve the problem?

M4 – (thick accent difficult to comprehend)

M4 – Why is agriculture struggling in the country ?

M4 – What about inequality. You must have heard about the inequality index in the world where we have highest number of wealthy people in the world.

M4 – Don’t you think that’s also an issue ?

M4 – Should agriculture be given industry status ?

M4 – But are you aware that Govt accorded industry status to Agriculture once in the past ?

M4 – Okay. You spoke about agricultural distress earlier. Why is agriculture distressed ?

M4 – (said something which I don’t remember)

CM – Okay. Thank you.

Avantika.

7 March, 2019

Afternoon session.

Board: Sathiyavathy ma'am.

Relevant info: schooling in jalandhar, BE ECE from PEC, chandigarh, organised blood donation camp in college.

Ma'am: Blood donation camp, your role, organ donation, laws related to organ donation, Green corridor? What else disease are screened for in the donated blood? Do they tell it to the donor?

M1:(first he asked me whether I am comfortable with economics as I didn't have any background in it) Changes in budget process which happened in last 2-3 years, what's fiscal policy, what's monetary policy, total capital held by the rbi, what's monetary policy committee. What's the tussle between govt and rbi? Can rbi dictate to the government? 2-3 question I can't remember.

M2: what's special about chandigarh, who designed it? Internet of things? what's jalandhar known for? Universal donor, universal recepient, what does positive and negative in blood signify (rh factor)? What is Internet of things?

M3: (a little grumpy) GPS working? How does it tells us route? If you were DM in a poor district what will be your priority? Why education? Why do people keep demanding from the govt?why can't they do anything? Don't they have any duty towards the country? What duties we have in the constitution? Name a few of them.

M4: what would happen if the pregnant mother and baby would have conflicting rh factor? Effect on baby? Effect on mother? Animal whose heart is closest to human. Transplanted in human as well. (pig, didn't know). The doctor who performed 1000 heart surgeries, what's his name.(At this point ma'am intervened that she's not from medical background.) a few question I don't remember.

Observation: board was cordial, ma'am was smiling and supporting throughout.