UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 4 Apr 2024 (2)
4 Apr 2024
Name - Gareebon ka Adinath
Date and Session of Interview - 4th April 2024, forenoon
Board's Chairman - Hon'ble Lt Gen Raj Shukla
Home state and places mentioned in DAF - Jharkhand, Ranchi, Kolkata
Optional - Sociology (nothing asked)
College (UG/PG) - WBNUJS
Educational background - BA LLB (Hons.)
Hobbies - playing football and snooker; listening to hip-hop and rock music; raising awareness about legal issues, rights and responsibilities; writing poems on human emotions and patriotism; acting in plays based on youth and society
Achievements (if any) - Gold in Bharatiya Sanskriti Gyan Pariksha; NTSE Scholar, Won negotiation competitio; Football and snooker champion
Your experience in interview via a detailed transcript -
Chairman:
Good morning. What time did you wake up? (6 am).
What did you do then? (Got ready, read the paper and came here)
What will you do after going back today? (Relax and watch a football game. I think Liverpool play tonight)
So you are a football fan? Why, despite being so popular in pockets of India, football lags behind cricket? (Lack of a pyramidal league system, grassroot development, only 14 pro-licensed coaches)
But football is so popular, Messi is considered god, why is the craze for football limited to bars and pubs when people want to drink and cheer?
But there is a huge craze for league matches, like between Mohun Bagan and what is the other team? (East Bengal, sir) There is a league structure.... (But there are very few teams, and professionalisation of football is inadequate)
But cricket was in a similar situation in the 70s and 80s and an elite sport? Why did it succeed but football did not? (India won the world cup when colour TV came) But that is not the only reason... (one of the reasons, sir) Yes, what is the major reason? (Lack of resources) But Mrs Ambani is investing in football... Who has more money than her? (BCCI's revenue is 5000 cr which dwarfs all other associations).
Okay, what is your opinion on the 3 language vs 2 language debate? (Mother tongue + Hindi + English) But I have a tiny brain. How will a child like me learn three languages and maths science etc. (Sir, there are other stakeholders like family who can share the burden with the school) Why not mother tongue and English, like Tamil Nadu FM said? (English is technical lingua franca and constitutional obligation to promote Hindi) Sudhanshu Trivedi says shuddh Hindi should be promoted. Do you agree or should bolchaal wali Hindi be promoted? (Bolchaal wali as it is more accessible).
M2 (lady member):
You are from Jharkhand. What are Eklavya schools? (State of the art education for bright and talented students) Why do you say bright and talented? (Sorry, ma'am. I recant that statement) What are Ashrams? (Don't know) Is there any reservation for STs in Parliament? (mind had gone blank due to messing up the last two questions. Couldn't answer even this full toss).
What is hip-hop music? (Origin in 1970s, four elements of DJing, MCing, Beatboxing and B-boying) I don't understand these terms...(I will explain each one, ma'am —explained all four) .... Okay.
Your hobby is raising awareness on legal issues, rights and responsibilities. If you are DM and a group of labourers are agitating, what will you do? (I will use my training, but as an outsider looking in I think I will speak with their union leader) No union leader is present, only an agitated mob is there... (I will calm them down by assuring that their concerns will be heard, then I will sit down with their union leaders to understand their issues and concerns).
M3:
Do you know the Places of Worship Act? What is it's crux? (Told about character of place on 15/8/1947) Why is there an issue in Gyanwapi etc? (The petitioners argue that their character was Hindu due to Puja being allowed, hence Act does not apply) Okay, so this is why there is survey being done to determine character (yes sir...)
The CJI in a statement said he had reversed his father's biggest mistake. Which case was he talking about? (ADM Jabalpur) What did that case say? (Gave the ratio) And what did the CJI overturn it to say? (A.20 and A.21 sacrosanct, 19 also post-Puttaswamy)
M4:
When you were discussing language earlier, did you notice there is a gap between policy and practice? Politicians give speeches about regional languages but we all prefer English education for our kids... (Issue of quality and quantum in regional language schools, market forces determine demand and supply of English education due to privatisation and commercialisation) But politicians are said to understand the pulse of the people? Have they not understood it here? (No sir, there is a saliency bias in policymaking, like ES23 said) You said saliency bias, which is related to behavioural economics. Is the govt trying to nudge people away from government jobs? (It is partially true, sir, given the recent comments of Economic Advisor to the PM, but a nudge must go beyond political rhetoric in the form of government cutting down on recruitment and outsourcing ancillary functions)...
What was your specialisation in law? (IP law, advanced criminal law, etc.) It is said a good criminal justice system is a factor of likelihood of getting caught, possibility of punishment, and severity of punishment... Where do we stand on this in India? (Sir, unfortunately we lag behind here. Overburdened and inadequately equipped police affects the first, judicial pendency and money power in getting legal aid affects the second, while we have moved to a reformative system of punishment when it comes to the third, hence the corrections system needs to be overhauled to provide better rehabilitation and job opportunities for inmates)... All that is okay but it is often said process is punishment (yes sir), people don't get bail (right sir), there are so many undertrials (70% of inmates, sir)... Okay....
M5:
What is hypersonic missile? (Speed more than 5 mach) What is mach? (Speed of sound) What is speed of sound? (IIRC from Class 11 Physics, it is 330 km/s) 330km/s???? (Sorry sir, I don't remember) What is *some random missile*? (I don't know) What is Agni? (India's nuclear missile)
Have you heard of PMLA? (Yes sir) What was its historical background? (I know the current provisions but not the background) You don't know? It's a current topic (I need to read up on this, sir)... Okay..
Chairman: Your interview is done. All the best! Thank you!