Interviews

UPSC interview, Dinesh Dasa board, 28 Feb 2024

28 Feb 2024

Name - Kaal Bhairava

Dasa Sir board

28 feb 2024 forenoon

Daf pointers - economics, political science, sociology optional, kriya yoga, rural background

Chair

1. describe your life between 2019 and 2024 (spent in my village prepping for civils) - is this your first PT? ( no sir it’s third ) - okay so your graph is on the upward every year, will try to push it further upward (thank you sir)

2. What is comprehensive GDP? ( I didn’t knew)

3. Did you hear President’s budget address? Did she mention reduction in poverty? (Yes sir india has reduced Multi dimensional poverty)

4. How did we reduce MDP? (New Welfarism - public provisioning of private goods - named different schemes like PMJDY, HAR GHAR JAL, PM-AWAS, SBM etc that have helped improve on individual dimensions of MDP - then gave counter view - Household consumption expenditure survey data that says 55% popn still below median std of living)

5. Works of yogender Singh and Andre Beteille (sociology) - couldn’t recall so said sorry

6. Sanskritisation and de Sanskritisation

M1

⁃ What is kriya yoga - why we do it - how we do it

⁃ Works of Dipanker Gupta - (discreet castes and muddled hierarchies)

⁃ What changes have you observed in your village in past few years ( english medium school under Mahatma Gandhi scheme, primary health centre, proper roads under gram sadak yojna and meetha paani via taps)

M2

⁃ How has planning in india changed?

⁃ Rationale behind 5 year plans

⁃ Why change in 2015?

⁃ Which is better - Niti aayog model or 5YPs? (Sir based on today’s requirements centralised planning by planning commission is not preferable as a stakeholder based team india approach has proved itself in past decade)

⁃ Describe higher education scene in India (mentioned UGC and it’s role)

⁃ What are issues in higher education ( rote learning based structure that has led to poor employability of our graduates)

⁃ How do we make it better (implement NEP 2020 which provides for funding body and then I mentioned major features of NEP like multiple entry exit points, focus on R&D, no clear distinction btw curriculum/extra curriculum, learning while doing etc )

M3

⁃ Approach the israel-Palestine issue as a political scientist ( talked about 2 state solution and Oslo accord template going forward but before that an immediate humanitarian ceasefire enforced by international peacekeepers

⁃ Should india send peace keepers? ( there is no harm in sending as both parties hold Indians in high regard and india was involved in formulation of 2 state solution )

⁃ Who shall we send then? (preferably a force consisting of members from paramilitary and army under command of an army officer who have such domain experience

M4

⁃ now approach the israel-palestine issue as a sociologist ( sir a unified Palestinian consciousness might be missing due to israeli occupation of land between major arab settlements like Gaza strip, West Bank and Ramallah which have become mini societies )

⁃ You have agri background so you know the issues just tell me the solutions to our problems ( sir first we must remove export bans to give market access that will increase farm incomes and in long term we must focus on high value products like horticulture, dairy, fisheries which have clocked near to double digit growth rates and have driven our positive agri growth rate rather than cereals that are stagnant at 1.4-1.5% gr and also have led to monoculture )

⁃ Last question betaji - which is the latest book you’ve read not related to upsc prep ( sir I read “how China sees India and the world by Mr Syam sharan)

Chair

⁃ your interview is over

I thanked the board and left

Might be missing few questions

Total duration - 30-32 mins

Super mellow board, no disagreements or counter questions

Utility of mocks - good for practice and some questions might repeat; peer mocks and discussion are best IMO; special thanks to Dudi Sir, Vikram Sir and Karnail Singh sir

Interview Transcript (CSE 2023)

Name: XYZ

Board: Hon’ble Dinesh Dasa Sir

Optional: Anthropology

DAF Keywords: IFS, Maharashtra, IIM, Marketing, Women in Science

Time: 1st March 2024 | Forenoon Slot | 2nd to go

Room was small and brightly lit. Chairperson and members were seated across a circular table which was also small in size. Seating was like shown in the interview scene of 12th fail movie

Greeted the members and took my seat.

Chairperson

- So you are from Maharashtra. You must have heard about the Shinde vs Thackrey controversy (I misheard this as Scindia vs Thakrey. I asked for a clarification. Sir clarified but the discussion took a turn towards how the surname Shinde is differently called in different parts of India)

- What was the SC judgement in Shinde vs Thackrey?

- How do you relate it with the Nebam Rabia judgement?

- What is the population of Pakistan?

- Should’nt India and Pakistan trade with each other (I said I agree with the government’s stand that Terror and Talks cannot go hand in hand. But Sir persisted that both parties will gain if they engage in trade and cultural exchanges. I accomodated sir’s pov but said that we need to use our trading potential as a leverage to negotiate terror talks with Pakistan)

- Why do shows like Bigg Boss have greater viewership than shows like KBC?

M1 (Male)

- Would you call the Maratha state in 1800s as a kingdom or a confederacy? and why so?

- Indo-Bangladesh Border disputes

- Noticed the gap on CV after I left my job and asked what I have been doing in the meantime?

- IIMs publicise huge packages through their placements, what are pros and cons of such glorification?

M2 (Male)

- When was Mumbai University established?

- What is Saras Mela?

- What would you prefer - Environment or Development?

- How has India tried to strike a balance between the two?

- What was the Mahindra Case Competition about? (DAF)

- What was your role?

- What were your suggestions?

M3 (Male)

- Have you read some books that were recently written by women in STEM? (DAF)

- Can you name some women in STEM fields and what were their contributions?

- Would you call Vandana Shiva as a scientist or a activist?

- How necessary is science in activism?

M4 (Male)

- What are some key learnings from Marketing? (DAF)

- How can they be applied in administration?

- What are some changes in bilateral ties with increase in globalisation?

- What are some areas that countries need to collaborate in to further globalisation?

Back to Chairperson

Ok your interview is over, is there any part of your DAF that we missed out and you would want us to ask questions on it? ( I replied no)

So, how are you feeling now? ( I said I am feeling quite destressed)

M3: So now what will you do after you go out of this room?

Chairperson: Ok you may go now

Mocks given: 7

Mocks that in hindsight were similar to the actual UPSC interview: Vajiram and Ravi and Vajirao Reddy. Since the interview was mainly DAF-centric, mocks were certainly useful and some questions were even repeated.

Overall good experience and cordial board!

UPSC CSE 2023 PT

Date : 04/04/2024

Name : Optimus Prime

Board: B.B.SWAIN SIR

DAF KEY WORDS:

Officer at Ministry of Finance, playing Guitar, travelling, cooking, chess etc.

Education qualification: B.Tech(mechanical engineering), L.L.B., M.A( public administration rural governance)

M1.

1. Why did you choose MP instead of Andhra Pradesh for place of posting/ preference.

2. What developments did you notice in india from 2014- till

3. Is vande Bharat a semi bullet train

4. Principle of bullet trains

M2:

1. How far defence procurement policy is successful

2. Can India withstand 3 world war if it breaks out if so how

3. Do you think regularisation of contract labour a wrong step

M3:

1. Difference between music and song

2. What is project 75

3. Do you think GDP is a good tool for measuring development

4. Difference between thermal engineering and thermodynamics

5. Which is the most efficient cycle in thermodynamics

M4:

1. What changes do you suggest if you are posted as DM to a particular district

2. Throw some light in micro matters- macro view report

3. As you are in leadership since your academics are you interested in politics in future

4. Present drug busting case in Visakhapatnam

M5:

1.How the introduction of new TDS codes help govt.

2. Is caste survey necessary for India

3. Why gravitational force is considered as a weak force

4. Why did you choose law after engineering and master of arts

Interview duration: 40 min

Insights:

They have tested the aptitude skills, academic skills and professional side.

Self preparation, mocks with some academies and questions from my friend helped me to sail through.

Thank you

Jai hind 🇮🇳