Interviews

UPSC interview, Suman Sharma board, 30 Mar 2024 (2)

30 Mar 2024

Shubham Bhardwaj PT 24:

Name- Shubham B.

Date and session of interview- 27/03/24 Forenoon session, 1st to go

Board- Suman Sharma ma’am

Optional- Anthro (nothing asked)

College- IITB Metallurgical engineering and materials science

Profession (if any)- Data Scientist (nothing asked)

Hobbies/Keywords- Shoonya meditation (nothing else asked from DAF)

Your experience in interview-

Ma’am mentioned degree and work experience in the beginning while reading DAF, and then DAF was completely ignored.

Chairperson:

1. Can’t recall any of ma’am’s 3 questions

Member 1:

1. Tell 3 issues with rural health

2. National Rural Health Mission - specific provisions?

3. If given piece of land, will you develop as office or hospital? How do you weigh both needs?

4. Stunting and wasting

5. There are 2 views- greatest good for greatest number, or timely interventions for important matters. Which will you prioritise?

Member 2:

1. Student of metallurgy, so tell views on state of high end metallurgical engineering in India and its impact on India’s growth story?

2. What is issue with indigenous development of jet engines?

3. State of titanium in India - enough reserves? If not, which country has highest reserves?

4. If we divide aviation - between civil and military, which one should we focus on given recent deals?

5. CAATSA

6. Why India not sanctioned?

Member 3:

1. How do you see India-US relations?

2. View on US statements on CAA, Delhi CM arrests

3. So you do Shoonya meditation. Tell me in one line about the benefits of this meditation.

4. Have you read about the book on shoonya meditation?

5. What comes after Shoonya?

Member 4:

1. There are always contrasting pulls for budget spending, so defends budget is limited. What recommendations would you give to get “maximum bang for buck”?

2. Tell about military-industry-academia linkage in India.

3. Do you know about Marut initiative?

4. Explained all about it. Asked if it was right to shelf the plan because of crashes that happened?

5. Don’t think of finances, from a purely technological perspective, what recommendations would you have given for the Marut project?

Then ma’am abruptly said thank you, you may go!

Utility of mocks or O2O (if any)-

Actual interview was completely different from mocks, with intellectually superior questions.

Mocks (gave 10):

January - Through Quantel (EdSarrthi, Maluka IAS, Allen IAS, 99 Notes), Raj Malhotra IAS, Vajirao and Reddy

February- ALS IAS

March- Forum IAS, Samkalp (seating closest to actual interview ), Chahal IAS

Most improvement happened in first 4 mocks, then all were just good reviews.

Raj Malhotra’s, Samkalp, Vajirao and Reddy, Chahal were the best in terms of quality questions.

One on One:

DAF Discussion with Mahesh Bhagwat sir, Abhishek Saraf sir.

Friendly mentoring by Utkarsh Shukla sir (EdSarrthi).

O2O with Ravindran sir (Vajiram), Khan sir (KSG)