UPSC interview, Sheel Vardhan Singh board, 29 Mar 2024
29 Mar 2024
Name: 66
Date: 28/03/24 (Forenoon)
Board: Sh. Sheel Vardhan Singh (3rd to go)
DAF keywords: Piano, Boardgames, Law, IPS, insolvency
Chairperson:
1. How is an upright piano different from a grand piano?
- More compact in size (he asked real differences, to which I said I've no idea)
2. What is the difference between these terms: orthodox, conservative, extremist, terrorist?
- Orthodox: who rigidly applies doctrine; Conservative: who opposes reform; Extremist: who want to persecute non-adherents; Terrorist: who actually ends up doing violence
(Follow up: do you think police can apply such a distinction? I said no bcs it's really difficult to distinguish bw extremists and orthodox)
3. Besides law and civil services, do you read any books? I said Fiction. He asked two most impactful fiction books I've read,. I said Midnight Library (Matt Haig) and Siddhartha (Hermann Hesse).
- Siddhartha is one of my favorites too. Give a summary of it in three words. (I gave an answer, sir gave another answer which he thought was right. I liked his answer more than mine, frankly)
Member 1:
1. Tell me the differences in European and Indian models of insolvency (I had cursory knowledge which I told them). What about the US model? (I just knew it happens under Chapter 11 Bankruptcy, and liquidation waterfall mechanisms are similar to IBC)
2. What are some conventions on transnational organised crime? (I didn't know any). Have you heard about the UN-CTOC? (I said no)
3. You have worked on game design. Who is the founder of game theory? (I was halfway into saying I don't know when I recalled it was John Nash).
- when did Nash publish his work? (Probably 1940s-50s, he said yes 50s)
- Have you read the paper by Nash? (I said no. He said okay, do read it sometime)
4. What is the basis for the Indian Evidence Act?
(I said fair trial, but he asked me to go to the root of the issue, which I couldnt)
- What is the main issue with Evidence Act? Why is it in conflict with Indian ethos?
(there is a significant distrust on individuals and state both, however, many provisions can be dispensed with by giving reasons, and many provisions are not applicable in tribunals. So largely I think it's about safeguards against state excesses and individual deception, not against Indian ethos)
Member 2:
1. What are the changes in CrPC?
(mandatory forensics, digitised process, higher police custody time frame)
- Why is it under controversy? (I said because of the police custody norms)
- Do you think it is the right step? (I said yes, because accused can abuse the process by going to hospital in first 15 days, so custody needs to be spread out)
2. What are some trends in Left Wing Extremism, how do they continue to organise such mass scale attacks and what can we do?
( I said WHAM strategy has been very effective, LWE districts have come down from 100+ to below 40 lately; covert networks between naxals and villagers continue, which is why they can blend in with the civilians; there's a need to check arms and ammunitions within the domestic regions. Then I said I don't really know what steps are being taken on ground for such a complex issue.)
Member 3:
1. What processes in insolvency are flawed and what need to be changed? (I said it's a great reform but debtor-in-possession needs to be brought back to ensure more timeliness and less erosion of value, and RPs need to be scrutinised more)
2. How many cases are pending in courts? (I said 4cr)
3. Supreme Court wants courts to give bail. So many undertrials are in prison for 10-15 years. (I said there needs to be distinction between police and judicial custody during investigation and after chargesheet is filed. Trial courts shouldnt grant incessant extensions of custody, and police should not be allowed to file supplementary chargesheet)
4. How can we resolve backlog of cases?
(I said firstly, there needs to be an increase in judges. Currently, judge ratio 20 per million, required is atleast 50 per million)
- Is that all?
(No, we need judicial accountability)
- How?
(judges should be answerable for the adjournments they give and delays they cause)
- Should there be a timeline on cases? Is that desirable?
(I said yes. For extreme cases the reasons should be noted in writing for delay and High Court should sit in supervision, otherwise timeline-based action)
Member 4:
1. How long have you been playing piano? (I said since school, but focused more on bollywood songs since college)
- Then that is merely keyboard, not piano because it's not western classical (I said I have learnt western classical too, a bit)
- Which bollywood song has almost a direct symphony lifted into it? (I said probably Phir Le Aya Dil from Barfi)
- No, have you heard Mozart's 40th Symphony? (I said no) He said listen to it and you'll realise.
2. Why is there so much police brutality in the US?
(Probably because of low accountability, racial prejudice, risk of gun violence from civilians)
- why is there so much gun violence in USA? Why don't people listen to the anti-gun lobby?
(I said 2nd Amendment rights, people want freedom to protect themselves even against state excesses)
- is the freedom to bear arms meant to be used against the tyranny of the state? (I said yes as far as I recall that's one of the intended reasons)
- which other countries have right to bear arms but low gun violence? (I said idk, he said take a guess, I said probably countries with conscription like Israel and South Korea, but he said no it's Canada, go see why they don't have such high rates of violence)
3. Why does police have a bad reputation?
(undertrained and understaffed, custodial violence, rampant petty corruption, selective efficiency)
- Petty corruption? Do you think corruption comes in shades of grey? (I said yes it does, high level political corruption is more dangerous)
- Do you think there should be separate punishments for different degrees of corruption? (I said petty corruption shouldn't be treated with leniency, rather different penalties such as disqualification under RPA or other penalties can be stacked for higher corruption)
4. Have you heard of Oedipus Complex? (yes: no clue how this question arose).
- What did Oedipus do when he found out he had killed his father and married his own mother? (he blinded himself: I was really unsure if I said it right, but he nodded it was right)
- I will leave you with this parting thought, in light of your answer on petty corruption.
Chairperson said this was all, thank you.
It was a pretty long interview I think, more than 30 mins atleast. And no clue what people felt about my answers or my inability to recall facts, the board members were all serious.