Interviews

UPSC interview, Sanjay Verma board, 27 Mar 2024

27 Mar 2024

Name- DR Sodium

Panel: IFS Sanjay Verma Sir

Date: 27/03/2024

Duration: 25 minutes

Entered the room and greeted the lady member and then the males with NAMASKAAR.

M3 said- Your suit looks very good. Did you buy it readymade or got it stitched? (Sir, I got Stitched)

Chairman- How much did it cost? (10k sir)

Including cloth and stitch? (Yes Sir)

Where did you get it from? ( Sir, Kamla Nagar in Delhi)

Which Shop? (Sir- Raymonds)

OK, tell me what is the fabric quality and thread count of this suit? (I was expecting a bomb question after all the friendly previous convo – I smiled, I do not know about that sir. Thanks for the compliment though.)

He then started reading out my DAF – BSC, MA English, Sociology, Photography, Cycling, NCC, Extempore and Essay Writing.

What essay did u get a prize for? ( Sir, I wrote an essay on farmer’s suicide)

Don’t you think farmer suicides are overhyped viz-a viz women and student suicides? They do not get any attention? ( Sir, all suicides are avoidable, but farmer’s distress is largely due to economic reasons. It depicts a deep structural issue that needs to be tackled.)

But student suicides do not get any attention? (Sir they do get attention for eg. Kota suicides and IIT suicides)

How does sociology help in understanding suicide? ( as I started speaking of Durkheim he intervened)

You sociology students for the past 40 years talking of Durkheim only. Do you know of somebody else who has worked on it? (Yes sir. Ramachandra Guha has worked on a study on suicides in India. At this, all members smiled and nodded. Didn't ask anything further)

You have won a prize in extempore as well. What did you speak about? ( Sir, In NCC Camp we were given chits of topics and I got the opportunity to speak on Demonetization)

Was demonetization Good? ( yes Sir, it was a move with good intentions)

What were the reasons? Tell crisply. ( To counter black money, fake currency, terror funding. The hidden benefit was the digitalization of the economy.)

M1

You are from KUK.( Long Monologue 2-3 minutes) It's funded by govt. Should we now privatize such institutions? ( Sir, graded privatization can be looked into after due trial. The immediate need is not there)

Why do we need govt institutions? ( high fees in pvt , Development need of the nation for higher education.)

Fees fix kardete h private ki 100 rs. But the volume of students will rise. So it will become profitable. What do you think? ( Smiled, If it is so, their quality will not be up to the mark. Govt will have to subsidize so this is exactly what happens in aided and govt colleges)

Some more questions about this theme... can't recall.

M3

You are from Haryana. Highlight the participation of Haryana in the war of 1857. ( told factual in the end I said, “I am not very sure but there was some involvement of Ambala Cantonment as well”). I think he wanted to hear Ambala and He started a long monologue on Mangal Pandey, Meerut, Ambala, Barakpore) I could have answered well here. Missed an opportunity.

Earlier sports policy in Haryana was of giving Policing jobs to medal winners and now we are giving them jobs in the sports department to promote their sport. Which one is good? ( Sir, in those times ‘Padak Lao Nokri Pao’ initiated sports culture in Haryana. This led to the growth of sports complexes and individual games. Current policy is more effective for today as Neeraj Chopra’s talent will be used to train more Olympians.)

High Per capita income in Haryana yet very high unemployment. Why is this dichotomy? ( People have high incomes, so refuse to work at low wages and due to lack of marketable skills are unemployable. )

What’s the solution? ( two-fold measures – develop capabilities by skill training, quality education and create opportunities by infra development, food processing.....)

M4

You do photography. Which competitions have you participated in? ( Sir, I am an amateur photographer and like to click pictures. I have not participated in any competition, I am learning.)

You were an NCC Cadet. Give an extempore on NCC. ( Spoke 2 min non-stop on NCC – my forte.)

Why did’t You join the Army if NCC is so good? ( Sir, I gave SSB. Always got screened in but unfortunately could not get recommended. So I opted for Civil Services)

Did you fly any plane in Air WING? ( Yes sir. We had 3 sorties in microlite aircraft.)

Did you participate in the RDC- Republic Day camp? ( Sir, I was not very good at Drill. I was good in essay writing, extempore and academic activities. So I participated in those camps.)

We haven’t lost any war except in 1962. Then why do we now need CDS? ( Sir, for coordination between the tri-services and optimization of resources. )

Haven’t you seen Border Movie? It is shown that the army and airforce worked together. ( Sir, It was a movie. The procedure for getting approvals for joint ops could not be shown.)

No, it is a well-known thing that tri-services cooperate. Still is there a need for CDS? ( Sir, in the Kargil War 1999 there was a delay in the deployment of the Airforce due to which the Army had to face huge losses. To prevent any such event from reoccurring trilateral unified chain of command was brought in and is very much needed)

M5- Lady

Do you know anything about blockchain technology? ( Maam it's a decentralized data storage and access mechanism. Used in cybersecurity and cryptocurrency)

Why do we need it? ( Decentralisation of data, reducing vulnerability)

What will you do if corruption is reported in your department? (Maam, I will first verify the claims. Then I will take suitable actions as per the laws of POCA ; for long-term solutions I will do sensitization training for the entire staff and develop transparent& accountability mechanism in the department. )

Won't you give any punishment? ( Yes Maam, as per prescribed laws and Acts)

Chairman

You have studied at St Francis Xavier School and Dayanad College. Compare and contrast St Francis with Swami Dayanand. ( Big smile, Asked permission for some time to think on it. Then told- St Francis was a Christian missionary on a mission to spread Christianity in the east, while Swami Dayanand was promoting people to look into their own culture, go back to Vedas, and take pride in their roots. ST Francis emphasized conversion to Christianity while Swami Dayanand wanted to bring back the converted people to the Hindu system through the Shuddhi movement. However, in today’s time educational institutions run by their organizations are providing secular, good-quality education throughout India.) *was a peak movement for me as I had to create the answer on the spot*

You have mentioned motivating others as a hobby. Do you motivate students or common people also? ( Sir It was during my college in mathematics association when I started helping juniors in maths. I have continued it in UPSC prep as well)

If you go on like this Someday you will become a Godman. All panelists laughed and looked at me keenly seeking an explanation. ( Sir, I consider motivating others and helping them as a passion and not a profession. I would still pursue Civil Services)

Thank you. Your interview is over you may go now.

I joined hands, wished them Thankyou sir, Thankyou ma'am and bowed for Namaskaar- walked out.

NO questions on cycling and literature, BSC

Mostly focused around DAF

Mocks – Help in understanding one's frequency and sensing the air of questions. Samkalp ( best) , Vision Ias (v good), baki sab theek hain- far from reality but trains the mind for grilling.

Big thanks to my discussion group Mayank Rai, Shagun Bhai, Mudra and Girisha.

Hon’ble Sheel Vardhan Sir’s Board

Background Economics

Optional Sociology

Chairperson

Started with usual pleasantries. Welcomed me to the conversation.

1. What gives you joy in life?

2. What’s your dog’s name?

3. Have you heard of the term “raining cats and dogs”? What does it mean? Where does it come from?

4. Why do more people prefer to keep cats over dogs in the UK?

5. What’s the one thing that excites you about AI and the one thing that worries you?

6. If you were to constitute a committee for AI regulation as an administrator- who all will you include?

7. Have you heard of stepwells? ->> I mentioned water conservation + baoli (agrasen ki baoli particularly)

8. How about rani ka vav? Where is it? What’s special about it other than water conservation? - I said that it’s in gujarat but..didn’t know what’s special other than water conservation

M1

1. You mentioned Harari. Mention any two lessons from his book.

2. Do you think it’s fair to reserve seats for women in the metro?

3. Not talking about separate coaches but seats in the general coach. Opinion now?

4. What are tectonic plates?

5. What’s their relation with earthquakes?

6. Any place on earth where we can see tectonic plates on the surface?

7. Which is the largest tectonic plate?

8. What do you understand by smartgrid?

9. Which technology goes behind smartgrid?

10. How can government help in afforestation?

11. Which technology can the govt use to detect green cover?

M2

1. One revolutionary idea that nobody else has ever thought of..all the 25,000+ bureaucrats combined..that you’ll implement.

2. Do you think India lags behind because of its low R&D expenditure?

M3

1. You studied psychology in class 12. So, who gave the concept of id, ego, superego?

2. Can you elaborate on all 3?

3. What is parapsychology?

4. You mentioned resilience to one of the members. How to build resilience?

5. Could yoga be used to build resilience?

6. Is resilience the same as EI?

7. You mentioned a lot of professionals that you’ll include in the committee for AI regulations to the chairperson - shouldn’t philosophers also be a part?

M4

1. Have you been to a village?No not such urban villages. What difference did you see?

2. Your view on subsidies?

3. How about power subsidies?

4. Subsidy vs cross-subsidisation?

5. No pick only 1.

Cp- thank you, your interview is over.

Self-assessment — Overall, cordial board. The board was very attentive and patient.

However, the interview was nowhere along expected lines..hardly any questions from background, optional or daf ~ these were the areas that were covered extensively in mocks but the actual interview was very very different in terms of the range of questions. Never expected questions from history, geography and psychology...But that’s probably where the beauty of this exam lies...it’s full of surprises.