UPSC interview, Dinesh Dasa board, 22 Mar 2024 (Haryana)
22 Mar 2024
Name: Itihaas
Date of Interview: 22 March 2024 Afternoon (1st to Go)
Board: H'nbl Dinesh Dasa Sir, 35 minutes
Optional: Public Administration
Hobby Interest: Training AI models, (Not asked: Vipassana, coursera courses, journaling)
DAF: Haryana, IIT BHU, Merit in Metallurgy, Startup cofounder
95% daf based- AI, Startup, Metallurgy, Public Administration. 1 situation, 1 current affairs which I said I don’t know.
Chairperson:
1. Spoke my profile to others... hometown, education, work experience (everyone had a copy of daf. They had circled things on it with pencil)
2. Is AI boon or bane? (I said boon if used responsibly)
3. But earlier we used to go to libraries and read even unrelated things and hence AI is stopping people to learn and grow. ( I agreed that AI is making people dumb)
4. How to make sure it doesn’t?
5. If you were education secretary, how would you make a policy integrating AI that it doesn’t make our children dumb?
6. Are you aware of the 12 skills needed for the 21st century? (I couldn’t locate where the question is from)
7. Like critical thinking, etc? (No sir, not 12 specifically)
8. Farmers cannot sell produce in any other APMC. Shouldn’t they be allowed to?(yes sir, farm laws were progressive)
9. Why don’t farmers see that? How would you persuade them of the benefits?
10. Farmers in Haryana are agitating, but it is not so much this time. Why is it so?
Member 1:
1. Civil servants join to become change agents. Are you also joining for the same?
2. Aren’t bureaucrats status quoists?
3. There are 3 important requirements of public administration are capacity of the state, rule of law and accountability. Do you think India started with Rule of law and accountability before developing state capacity? (I said accountability is also important)
4. But these institutions like CVC judiciary don’t let bureaucrats take decisions? (Courageous, risk taking civil servants needed)
5. What is rule of law?
6. Why is it needed?
Member 2:
1. How would you reverse engineer Rafale if you have to?(I told material characterisation and wanted to speak of other areas. He was interested in characterisation part and metallurgy as such.)
2. How would you characterise?(xrd, sem, phase identification, microstructure, identifying elements and their composition, etc steps)
3. Why startups not in Metallurgy?
Member 3:
1. What was your startup CRI about?
2. What is the difference between a startup and a normal company?
3. Do you still have stakes in it?
4. You could have been a unicorn. Why did you leave?
5. Would you go back to startup again?
6. Are civil servants paid enough?
7. What is the ratio of higher to lower civil servants salaries?
8. What is this ratio in private sector?
Member 4:
1. Situation: you and your friends are celebrating on terrace of your home. A gamla(plant) fell on neighbour’s daughter (not intentionally but by mistake by a friend’s hand) and she got killed. You are not on good terms with neighbour. He wants to implicate you into intentional murder case. What would you do?
2. MP excavations have happened. What are the contentions?(sorry sir, I am not aware of the issue in enough details)
Chairperson:
1. Is there anything else you want to say? (“Yes sir, I want to thank you”)
2. No no we should thank you.. a b c.. is there any area you feel we didn’t touch and you were prepared very good.. that you would tell your friends that if this topic comes I will do wonders.
(I said gratitude for family friends country.. and explained my preparation process of speaking to over 50 leading people in AI, startups, research, etc)
Mocks Given: ~25
Utility: I went to mocks to have conversations with senior people.. to judge the panel... better than making my own list of questions was to let panel ask questions and I can build upon that.
Another strategy was to divide mocks into 2 phases. 1st phase was without preparation(just a raw conversation). 2nd phase after some reflections on previous feedback and preparation.
Date of interview- 21/03/2024
Board- Dinesh Dasa Sir
Homestate- Assam
Graduation- Electrical Engineering
Work experience- PowerGrid Corporation
Optional- History
Hobbies- football, short stories (not asked), visiting historical places (not asked)
Chairman Sir:
1. So you know Bhupen Hazarika, give me the Assamese version of 'Ganga Behti Ho Kyun'
2. Sing one of his songs. Explain it's meaning.
3. Do you know from which place does Hariprasad Chaurasia belongs?
4. Why do you think that great artists like B Joshi, Bismillah Khan, H Chaurasia don't emerge nowadays? Has something changed?
5. Why do you think China has been better able to preserve its culture compared to India?
6. Has the Great Wall of China played any role in it?
7. What difference to India would it have made if we had constructed such a wall along Khyber Pass?
8. Do you think that all Muslims in India are converted?
9. Tell me why only the places of West Bengal, Kerala and Goa are famous for football in India?
10. Why are we not able to progress?
Member 1:
1. Like the Chinese BRI, should we construct say a tunnel directly from Tamil Nadu to Sri Lanka across Palk Strait? Asked few counter questions to my response.
Member 2:
1. What is the main difference in functionality between Powergrid and other state grids?
2. Give a SWOT analysis of Powergrid Corporation?
3. Why are Govt privatising even profit making PSUs?
4. Can you give me an exact idea of how many PSUs are doing well and how many are not?
5. Can you name me some Chinese PSUs?
6. Give me the figure of our fiscal deficit.
7. What are some tax reforms the Govt is planning in the future?
Member 3:
1. Why should people in places like Delhi be concerned about CAA while it has nothing to do with them?
2. Can you name me the exact community which will be most affected by CAA in West Bengal?
Member 4:
1. What is Augmented reality?
2. What is blockchain technology?
3. What kind of computers will be most used in future?
(2-3 questions I am not able to recall)
Then Chairman Sir said thank you and I greeted them back and came out.
Overall- a good experience although I couldn't answer a few questions and was not satisfied with a few answers that I gave. Members were coordial and they didn't counter much expect M1.
Mock- gave around 8-10- Chanakya Mandal, Chahal, Samkalp, Vajirao, Vision were good (rest were also helpful in generating more questions)
O2O- Raveendran Sir, Khan Sir were good. Sessions with Prosenjit Basak Sir (Vision IAS) were very helpful
PT date- 20/03/2024 forenoon 2nd to go
Chairperson- Hon'ble Sheel Vardhan Singh sir
DAF keywords- JNV, Agril. Engg, Anthropology, Surya Namaskar, Vipassana, Maharashtra
Chairperson-
1. What is language?
2. What is dialect? Tell me different names of 3 Indian dialects and one English dialect.
3. Names of 7 chakras?
4. What different types of mantras are pronounced while doing suryanamaskar?
5. (About sound) I don't know about it..
Member 1-
6. What different leadership roles did you play in jnv?
7. What initiatives do you take?
8. What you learned from it?
9. What is the function of nano urea?
10. Who made it?
Member 2(lady)
11. What is growth and development?
12. What do you understand from the point of economy of any country?
13. Which country is facing negative growth?
14. What is deepfake?
15. Do we can call voice cloning as deepfake?
Member 3-
16. What is vipassana?
17. What are the different names of asanas in surya namaskar?
18. Who brought vipassana to India?
19. What we should do to make India developed nation?
20. Why government schools are not preferred by parents? What is issue with it?
Member 5-
21. What should India do to be developed nation?
22. Should we continue with cross subsidy?
23. Don't you think it's promoting injustice in society?
Few questions I'm unable to recall..
Overall it was good experience 😊