UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 20 Mar 2024 (PSIR)
20 Mar 2024
Name- abc
Board- Honorable Raj Shukla Sir (all male members)
Date- 20-03-2024
Optional- PSIR
DAF Pointers- Bihar, Jharkhand, Delhi University, Optional, Acid attack, College Name (no question on hobbies), Edsarrthi Student
Chairperson-
1. So do you belong to Bihar or Jharkhand?
2. What about you education? Kaha se kia?
3. Delhi University is known for its quality and curriculum. Is this the reason you came here?
4. If I would have given you the option to study either in Bombay or Delhi, what would have been your choice and why?
5. Okay so talking about political Science, politics pe kya vichar Hain aapke? Is it good or bad in India? It is said that it is the last resort of scoundrel. Do you agree?
6. Think and tell any 2 problems in current system of politics. This was followed by a discussion of 3-4 mins with 2-3 cross questions.
7. Don't you think India's opposition is not strong now. It is unable to pressurise the ruling party?
8. Consensus building takes a long time. Security sector requires immediate implementation. India now has transformed so much which was not witnessed earlier. What are your views on this?
9. Do you think role of judiciary has shrinked in India?
10. But CJI in the past said that we will not interfere in the domain of legislation. Is it justified?
11. I agree to what you are saying but what has been the need for this separation of powers and check and balance mechanism?
Member 1-
1. What is euthanasia
2. Do you think right to die should be legal?
3. Is it legal in India?
4.difference between active and passive euthanasia.
5. Which euthanasia is allowed in India?
Member 2-
1. What is the peaceful method of resolving conflict through communication?
2. Do you think it is applicable on Pakistan?
3. Do you think India should engage in communication with Pakistan?
4. The current relationship between India Pakistan is not able to end into a peaceful solution. How long do you think this would continue?
5. What is BRI and CPEC
6. What impact does it have on India?
7. Is BRI a part of CPEC?
8. What is the route through which it passes?
9. What is the alternative to it?
Member 3-
1. What is sanatan dharma? (College name)
2. Don't use any technical terms. I am unable to understand, please explain it in simple words.
3. Do you know the controversy regarding this between South and North India?
4. Why was it accepted by North Indians but not south Indians though caste discrimination was present in both areas?
5. Situation based question on acid attack and encounters (gave me the role of SP), 2-3 follow up questions on that
Member 4-
1. What is the meaning of your name?
2. I gave the answer and sir smiled and said that I can see that on your face.
3. So why are indians unhappy? A long discussion on that..
4. Gave A long monologue on the current state of jharkhand and asked me the reasons for that.
5. Who are dikus?
Chairman sir- okay your interview is over. Wish you best of luck. Thank you!
My assessment: all members were smiling but it is difficult to predict anything. My experience was not much different from mocks. There was no question from current affairs, the areas covered were my DAF, optional and name. They did not want any balanced answers as taught in mocks. Wanted to see my opinion.
Duration - 30-35 mins
Mocks- helpful ones- Next IAS (3 ques got repeated), vision IAS and Samkalp. All the mocks are good for questions but feedback should be taken very selectively.
O2O were the most helpful for me and I did many of them- Utkarsh sir and his strategy sessions (edsarrthi), Punit sir (somp), Sameer sir ( vision ), Khan sir, Ravindran sir, Saket sir