UPSC interview, Sheel Vardhan Singh board, 14 Mar 2023
14 Mar 2023
CSE PT-2023
Sanjay Verms Sir's Board
14/03/2023, Afternoon Session 1st to Go
Name - John Wick
Home District and State - Alwar,Rajasthan
Graduation - B.Tech. (ECE), MNNIT ALLAHABAD
Optional - Anthropology
DAF Keywords - Workshops on Ethical Hacking and Drone Making, Reading Non-Fictional Books ( No Background or Keyword in DAF for Banking )
I entered and Wished them. They were sitting quite close to me and It was a round table sitting arrangement but chairman was a little far.
Chairman : (Full of Positive Energy)
Asked me to sit. Offered Tea or Coffee. I politely refused as I already drank outside I told.
1. So You read Non-Fictional Books. Which are the awards given at national and International Level for Books ?
I answered - International Level is Booker Prize.
2. Interrupted Me and Asked,What are the categories under Booker Prize ?
Sorry Sir I don't know.
3. Tell some other Awards ?
At National Level Sahitya Akadami and At State Level given by state governments for local language promotion.
4. What are the names of state level awards ?
In Rajasthan it is rajasthani sahitya akadami but I don't know exact name in other states Sir.
5. Tell Some Private Sector Awards ?
Sir Media Foundations like The Hindu and Indianexpress give but I don't know exact names.
6. What Does This year's Economic Survey says about the status of indian economy ?
I was about to answer it in general terms but luckily I remembered that Since It is interim budget year, Economic Survey is not presented. ( He was like yes - this is what I was looking for and gave the turn to other member to ask questions )
Member 1 : ( Below 3rd and 4th Question were quite unclear)
1. How can Ethical and Hacking go together when Hacking itself is illegal ?
I told sir under IT Act,2000 hacking is illegal but that is due to unauthorized access and In Ethical Hacking the person is hired by organizations to scan vulnerabilities in system so he is duly authorized to do so. It is formally Called ' Penetration Testing' within IT Sector.
2. What do you mean by ethical hacking - Data Security or network security or both ?
Answered it is both.
3. How can we make a system full-proof ?
Sir Nothing can be full proof in digital domain permanently for example current strongest algorithms can be solved by Quantum computers in minutes. So we have to constantly stay ahead and keep upgrading security of digital infrastructure.
4. How to make a system secure from hacking ?
Sir It depends on objectives and usage of the digital system as well as the cost available with us to provide cybersecurity and sensitiveness of the data being transferred.
5. So you play badminton regularly ?
On weekends when exam is more than one month away but if less than one month to exam I shift to other hobbies.
6. Tell me why badminton is becoming so popular ?
Recent success of players and good network of academies of former champions, adapting to indian conditions just like street cricket now being played street badminton too, government support to players and emphasis on creation of infrastructure motivates players too.
Member 2 : (Quite Disinterested Face)
1. So you are from electronics background, tell me how does LLM ( Generative AI Model) integrate with Quantum Computing and how can that be used to tackle climate change ?
Sorry Sir, I don't know exact integration of LLM with Quantum Computing
2. So You have background in ethical hacking and drone making, you must have read about drones in detail ?
I clarified that these were just one day workshops but since drones have become such important part of our socio-economic environment,I have studied about them.
3. In a Drone,which is more important payload or structure ?
( I asked for clarification)
I told sir it depends upon the usage of drone - for example if it is being used in defence or e-commerce delivery then payload is more important but In surveillance, intelligence gathering,ISR Operations - structure becomes important.
He told that Payload is more important as it has sensors but anyways moving on.(I felt he was wrong as sensors has nothing to do with payload but are considered part of drone structure but I replied Thank You for informing me Sir)
4. Tell me difference between Drone Deterrance and Drone Dissuation ?
Sorry Sir I don't know , I will read about it.
Member 3 ( Couldn't Understand any question of him and it was not due to feeble voice but more due to framing question in such ways - it may have been deliberate)
This is what I inferred and replied to
1. Government was doing bank privatization at one point but now they are not in that much enthusiasm about it. What is the status now ? What is going on ?
I replied that Sir Bank Merger were initiated.... he interrupted me
2. I am not asking about Bank Merger but ownership of banks
I replied recently there was a proposal for Corporate Ownership of Banks but RBI was not in favour of it.
3. He was dissatisfied and said I am not asking that. Tell me which banks are better administered private or public sector ?
I told Sir it depends on skills of administrators as Both can be governed for maximum efficiency and national development.
4. Tell me the difference between Private Owned Banks and Public Sector Banks ?
Sir In public sector- more emphasis on financial inclusion, connecting to remote areas, they can be more easily aligned to Government priorities as government has more control over them. But In Private sector it is more profit-oriented but efficiency and technology infusion maybe high.
5. What model of bank ownership shall we follow in india - private or public sector ?
I told Sir combination of both should be used in India as they can complement each other.
6. USA is known for its banking and financial system but It doesn't have a single government owned bank, so why we need them in India ?
I told Sir USA has different socioeconomic environment and stage of economic development than India. India has quite different socioeconomic environment and stage of economic development and Public Sector has been an important factor in our economic growth and continues to do so so and unique historical legacy too for India
7. When did Bank Nationalization Happen ?
I am not sure Sir but I think in 1969 and 1981.
Member 4
1. Why Rajasthan is so famous for tourism ?
I said government efforts like First state to give Industry status to Tourism and It has separate tourism policy and efforts of tourism department in promotion. Along with this Unique Advantage of High Number of Heritage Hotels and Historical Forts and Architecture are very popular. Recently destination wedding concept getting popular and when high profile people visit here - gives more popularity in social media- attracts more tourists.
2. Difference between forts of Rajasthan and Maharastra ?
Sorry Sir, I don't know about specifics of Maharastra Forts but Rajasthan forts are known for their Strategic Locations and Impenetrable defences. For Example - Kumbhalgarh has second longest wall of World and Lohagarh fort couldn't be won by even british.
3. If they couldn't be won then why did they surrender ?
Sir Any state is dependent on people and it cannot survive without them working in tandem with it and when these states were increasingly surrounded by british and they started controlling people,economy,polity and nearby states, these states made treaties with them.
4. So You are from Alwar. Have You heard about 'Waterman of India' ?
Yes Sir he is Rajendra Singh from Alwar known for his work in River Rejuvenation.
5. Which Award he has won ?
Sir I am not sure but I think he won Raman Magsaysay in 2014.
6. Why is he called Waterman ?
Because He makes the areas water surplus from water scarce or water deficit.
7. What is water surplus ?
Situation Where we recharge more water than what we extract. For example - 100 litres a city is extracting from groundwater then it must recharge more than this amount.
8. How exactly he makes rivers flow again ?
With help of traditional water harvesting systems for recharge and with help of panchayat he removes obstruction from river path by Consensus building.
9. What are Traditional water harvesting techniques ?
I told 'Johad' in my area and he was quite satisfied by it and Pond,pokhar,lake,tanka etc.
10. Have you heard about 'Tilonia' ?
Sir I am not sure but I think it is in Barmer. He told it is in Ajmer. I said Sorry Sir, Thank You for Correcting Me.
Thank You, Your Interview is over.
I thanked them and came back.
These are the answers given by me and might be factually incorrect in few cases but I am sharing these so we can understand randomness of interview.
Observations - Couldn't Judge if it went well or not, I couldn't answer many questions. I felt deliberately number of questions were unclear.
Mocks - Gave Total - 7
Good - Vision IAS, CMP - O2O with Dharmadhikari Sir, Samkalp (Offline), Statecraft
Below Average - Shankar, Unacademy
Not Recommended - Samkalp(Online), Vajirao
Utility of Mocks - Just to keep the preparation going and be familiar with basic interview room environment, Otherwise Final Interview was in no way similiar to any of The Mocks.
Sheel Vardhan SIR
Name : Agent AK
DATE : 21/03/2024
4th to go.
DAF Pointers : History Optional , EEE
Hobbies : Writing letters to the Editor, Martial arts ( Silambam)
Chairman
1. what do Friends call you ( AK)
2. what is silambam. Could you elaborate about it. Why you taken such martial art.
3. Which Historical figure you like most.
4. Don't you think Ashoka taken dhamma as official policy. Not from Change of heart.
5. What is the last written letter.
6. Span of Sangam literature
7. Where 3 sangams are held
8. What is the script of Ancient Sangam Tamil text ( Tamil Brahmi script)
9. Who is the most liked Cricketer for you. ( Former Indian Captain MS DHONI)
10. Which hairstyle of Dhoni you like most, Dhoni with short hair OR Dhoni with long hair)
He replied even then Pakistan leader Farveez Musharaf like his long hairstyle.
M1.
AK seems terrific name.
1. Lessons mankind learn from history
2. History is written by Victors. Do you agree .
If it's going to rewritten on what basis.
3. Whether Human kind learned from WW-2.
Still there is no major peace
4. I would like to argue to you, that peace is due to nuclear deterrent, not due to history's lessons.
5. KHelo India youth games objectives
M2 .
1. TFR VS Delimitation issues. Any suggestions from your side to tackle Delimitation.
2. why the Cotton candy ban and name of Chemical name inside it.
3. Green credits. ( I don't know regarding this)
4. Could you able to connect Ashoka policy of trees with today's date ( March 21)
march 21 - International Day of forests
5. Why out OF 55 Letters you wrote only 3 letters published. Less than 5 % success rate. Don't you get disheartened towards editor.
M3
1 . Meaning of Aravinth
2. whether it is Sanskirt name or Tamil name.
3. what is name of Lotus in Tamil
4. Tell me one famous greek ruler.
5. Elaborate with example of how inscriptions and coins are used as source of history.
6 . What are science aspects in Ancient history. How sciences are delineated
7. what are the different schools of historians
8. In which most of the Ashokan inscriptions are written .
9. What is the script used by Harappan people. ( Logosyllabic word, Boustrophedon ...Its still undeciphered..sadly it falls under Proto-history sir)
M4 :
Let me relieve you from history
1. what is Saubhagya
2. Tell me 3 initiatives under Digital India mission.
3. Tell me about Tiruppur
4. Challenges faced by Tiruppur industry
5. Strengths of Tiruppur to come back
6. Whether future looks gloomy for Tiruppur.
chairman Sir.
Good time with you.
thank you sir.