UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 20 Mar 2024
20 Mar 2024
Name: Alan Shore
Date of interview: 20th March 2024, Forenoon Session, 6th (last) to go
Interview board: Lt. Gen. (R) Raj Shukla
Daf pointers: Jamshedpur, BA (H) Geography, Debating (other pointers not asked)
Interview transcript:
Chairperson -
1. So you're a debater. What according to you is the principle behind debating?
2. There's a Hindi saying "असहमति का साहस और सहमति का विवेक". Do you believe it is true? Is Indian political discourse today reflective of this? - From here on it became a discussion in which both he and I said almost the same amount of things. It revolved around - ideological differences, echo chamber, radicalization etc.
3. Don't you think such poor quality of debate also exists in other sections of society such as media? - Again a few cross questions based on my response.
4. Won't AI further exacerbate the issue of misinfo, disinfo and fake news?
5. How will debate lead to common ground and truth then? How will you (as a good debater) navigate this when everything is false? - I gave a slightly idealistic answer based on hope.
6. Is that all we can do? Rely on hope? - I answered that no sir, tangible steps can be regulation of AI with global consensus.
7. Is there a possibility of splinternet?
M1 -
1. What should be Indian Population Policy? - Cross questions based on response that went for a while including discussion on demographic dividend etc.
2. Should India wait for population to start declining like in Germany and Japan? Won't that be another issue?
3. Should the Population policy be the same for all or should we have difference based on rich and poor?
4. What is floating solar policy? Which states have adopted it?
M2 -
1. What was Sri Lanka's economic crisis? What happened and what is the status today?
2. Did India provide any help?
3. Why do Russia and China not want USD as a reseve currency?
4. What can be done as a solution?
5. If we choose any other currency such as Yuan, what will happen then?
M3 -
1. You used a term "schadenfreude". Do you think it is visible on social media? - Cross questions based on it.
2. You used another term echo chamber. What is it? Are WhatsApp Groups echo chambers? - Cross questions based on the same.
3. You come from Jamshedpur. Can you differentiate it from Ranchi in terms of urban governance?
4. Can this industrial township model be applied to Ranchi? - a lot of cross questions and debating based on this. I actually got a bit confused as to what he really wanted but I was able to answer almost everything well enough.
M4-
1. Which among the following is most important to you - Physical Geo, Economic Geo, Political Geo, Human Geo?
2. Why Physcial Geo?
3. What is forced migration vs economic migration?
4. Can economic migration by push factors be considered forced migration? Why? Why not?
5. Which UN organizations look after both forced as well as economic migration?
Time - 30-32 mins.
Your assessment of the board - Board was very cordial and carefully listening to my answers. Most questions were framed as discussion and hence total number of questions in the transcript may not reflect exactly how many questions were asked. After facing a random GS rapid fire in Nagraj Madam's board last year, this interview actually came as a very pleasant surprise. Largely DAF based.
Mocks - Only gave one mock at VisionIAS.
Assessment of performance - Mujhe kya? Shukla ji jaanen.