Interviews

UPSC interview, Sanjay Verma board, 19 Mar 2024 (Rajasthan)

19 Mar 2024

Name -- "I am Batman" -- Smart work lab student.

Chairperson -- Sanjay Verma sir --> all male

13-03 Afternoon. 4th to go.

Lasted around 35-40 minutes.

DAF pointers -- Doctor, AIIMS Jodhpur, Chirons, Basketball, Nagaur, Rajasthan, Carrom and other things (questions weren't asked)

When I entered the room -- It was a round table. All the members were standing near their chair. I wished everyone.

Chairman --

1. Dr. Batman, I have heard that standing is the new smoking. What do you think?

2. So, we will stand and have our discussion. Is it fine with you?

3. Dr. Batman, I have also heard that sugar is the new poison. What is your thought on it.

If you don't mind, we can sit and continue our discussion.

All the members took their seat.

I took my seat after everyone and thanked the chair.

4. We are creating so many AIIMS. Don't you think it's a risk to the brand value of AIIMS?

5. Batman, what is your thought on life and death? Discussion on it.

M1

1. Were you practicing medicine post your UG degree?

2. Dr. Batman, we are given generic medicines as a part of our CGHS. As per your experience as a doctor, what do you think are the problems with generic drugs?

3. Do you know who started this system of generic medicine in Rajasthan? What were the advantages of it?

4. If it's such a boon, what can we do to improve the situation of generic medicine?

5. How could we have prepared better after the 1st COVID wave to prevent the catastrophe during the 2nd COVID wave?

6. But these are all general points that are applicable to the entire health system. Is there anything unique we could have done?

M2 (to my immediate left)

1. Whenever I ask someone about the things that we need to work upon. Everyone talks about 3 things -- healthcare, education, and skill development. If u were to choose something other than this -- what would be your focus? (I talked about agriculture value addition & food processing to make agriculture more remunerative)

2. Alright, now, if I ask you to pick one niche area among the 3 fields that I mentioned earlier. What would be the one key area that u would focus upon in them.

3. Don't you think malnutrition is a bigger problem as it led to a life lifelong burden on the child.

4. How do you see the development in Rajasthan. Is it equal in all parts of Rajasthan or are there any regional disparities.

5. But don't you think that tourism is well developed in western Rajasthan.

6. Alright Dr. batman, how do you plan on developing the southern part of Rajasthan than?

M3

1. What is aggregator economy? Give me some examples.

2. There are also other things like TATA MG. Do you know about it?

3. Dr, there is growing commercialisation if healthcare with new chains like apollo and max coming up. What do you think about them?

4. How can we prevent over charging by such hospital chains?

M 4

1. Dr, India has a lot of potential fir medical tourism, but we still lag behind it. What are the reasons that we lag behind in MT? What can we do to ensure that we take the lead in it?

2. Should we use essential commodities act to cap the prices of generic drugs?

3. Forgetting a few questions here.

Chairman again -

1. Dr, I feel that the Bengali elites played a double game with Indians. Initially, they laid the red carpet for the britishers as they benefited from British trade and the new learnings they gained. Then, they took up all the government jobs under British, wrote poems and enjoyed their lives. Once, britishers started targeting them, they took up the lead in the national freedom movement and took credit for ousting the britishers. Don't you think we should call out on this clear double standard?

2. I agree that the common Bengali suffered but the Bengali elites enjoyed. Do u think there is anything fundamentally wrong in me saying so?

3. Compare and contrast 2 states of India -- Kerala and west Bengal BUT don't use any healthcare indicator.

4. Is there any political similarity that you see in these 2 states -- Kerala and west Bengal?

Batman's experience -- it was a once in a lifetime experience, thoroughly enjoyed it. The board was very attentive all throughout. Things felt like a conversation and was NOT like a question answer session at all.

What really helped? --

1. discussion of my mock video with *Anupam sir (smart work labs) * was really helpful & gave me great insights.

2. My interview group discussion with peers -- "left, right & centre" helped me to form opinions and to think quickly

3. My AIIMS J mates (YLBB) who helped me with my medical questions

Utility of mocks --

I gave around 10 mocks.

1.I found Chanakya Mandal, Chahal and 99 notes really good.

2. Rau's and vajirao had a lot of questions that matched in the final interview.

3. Discussion of these videos with Anupam sir (SWL) helped me to gauge my actual performance as sometimes coaching’s are hesitant to criticize.

4. One on one with khan sir and Ravindran sir towards the end was a great motivator too.

Hope to come out of this Chakravyuh real soon. Adieu