Interviews

UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 15 Mar 2024

15 Mar 2024

Date - March 13, 2024

Board - Raj Shukla Sir , afternoon 2nd last to go

Background- IITD, Job, Varanasi, Civil Engineering, Sociology

Nothing asked from hobbies.

Duration: 35-40 mins

Chairman:

1. So you are from IIT D , Btech in which Stream?

2. Why civil services? Said 2 words when Sir interrupted, tell me about reform required in Civil services

3. People from rural background argue thay they need more attempts and time, why you want to reduce no of attempts in exam,,?

4. Cabinet Secretary earns a meagre salary compared to pvt sector employees at such high post( talked of Satya Nadella), should salary of civil servants be increased?

5.Doesnt civil services loose out on talented individuals who prefer Private sector for higher salaries ?

6. Other reforms at macro Level?

7. If You are an officer and fail to perform would you be happy if you are laid off?? (Based on previous answer)

8. Shouldn't we have a new system where instead of giving preferences for each and every services, one should only opt for 1 service, so everyone gets only into service he/she wants to go in and has a clear mindset before giving the exam itself?

M1:(lady)

1. You are a graduate from Civil Engineering, tell me about Master Plans for Cities? For what Durations are master plan prepared in terms of years?

2. Why master plan fail for cities? She asked to explain Bengaluru water crisis in this context.

3. If you are a sub collector at Village level how will you prepare a master plan for development of the village, tell the steps you will follow

4. What work you did at your last company?

5. Central Vista Redevelopment project, why? Is it good planning? ( Based on last answer)

6. Which parts of the project were given to TATA?

7. You worked with Tatas who are known for their quality standards and your client was also CPWD how did the quality standards differ between the two? How you bring about the compromise.

M2:

1. You talked of climate resilient buildings, isn't climate risks unpredictable due to limitations in Early warning Systems? How will you address the issue?

2. Shouldn't we address the root cause of Green House emissions to reduce climate risks than putting money in resilient infrastructure?

3. You are talking at domestic level, what about the global scale? India faces various climate diasters which are for no fault of India but neighbour Countries, how to address the issue?

4. Lets discuss on sociology, Durkheim was a positivists, what do you mean by positivism in Sociology?

5. Is Durkheim's theory on suicide still relevant in today's time?

6. Which category of Durkheim's classification would you place Suicide by students in Kota?

M3:

1. What is Advocacy?

2. You earlier talked of Master Plan for cities, what percentage of your entire budget would you keep for Advocacy?

3. Talking about the repealed Farm laws, it was a case of failed advocacy, govt failed to make farmer understand the true character of the farm bills, if you were a DM how would have you ensured that such advocacy issue does not arise?

4. How about using Social influencers? Should we use them or not?

5. During the planning period there was a specific department within government formed for the purpose to make people understand about various schemes of government, can you name it? ( Didn't know)

6. Can you guess which ministry it might belong to? I said IB , he said correct and then mentioned name of department, I can't recall now.

M4:

1.UNESCO, in one of its report said Education has 4 pillars, Learn to grow, Learn to be, Learn to live together, learn to do

Can you justify each?

2. If you are DM , how will you ensure these pillars are implemented in the district schools?

3. Learning to live together was an idea promoted by Joint Family systems, but now we are seeing nuclear families , how will children now learn the value of living together?

4. Society undergoes Changes in customs over time, now we see custom of Nuclear families , are joint families even relevant and feasible in today's world?

CP: Your interview is over

There was constant movement of people in and out of the room, bringing papers and food, lot of distractions. Shukla sir also left the room for sometime and came back later. Lady member was smiling throughout, Shukla sir kept staring with a very serious look.

Mocks Utility: helped in confidence building, actual interview completely on different lines than mocks, not relatable to any mocks except questions on job.

13th March, Forenoon session

BB Swain board, 3rd to go

Keywords - Economics, Chhattisgarh, diary writing, English

1. Name Thomas picketty's book

2. What is inverted-U curve of Kuznets and what were Picketty's additions?

3. ⁠difference between equality and equity

4. can there be perfectly equal society?

5. what is externality? How can it be internalised?

6. tell about CBAM, its analysis, intent, etc.

7. Taxing imports vs subsidising domestic industry, which one is better? (2-3 cross questions)

8. when is a subsidy regressive?

9. ⁠name of a famous diary

10. meaning of depreciation (two more terms which I didn't know)

11. contemporary indian authors

12. aware of a famous person who resigned from L&T, took sabbatical and wrote literature? (I said i dont know)

13. reasons for china's current situation

14. china's debt trap diplomacy

15. tell about cpec

16. ⁠benefits of cpec from China's perspective

17. ⁠difference between greenfield and brownfield project

18. ⁠which one is better? Why?

19. ⁠what is life cycle theory of capital?

20. Why is it considered?

21. ⁠tell about chhattisgarh demography in brief

22. ⁠chhattisgarh culture explain (i gave 2-3 mins speech)

23. ⁠what is bastar dussehra?

24. ⁠why is it celebrated for 75 days?

25. Structural reforms india needs