UPSC interview, Bharat Bhushan Vyas board, 24 Feb 2019
24 Feb 2019
Pakkiresh Badami
Date - 21/02/19
Board - B B Vyas
CM
- Tell me about yourself.
- so you are getting training in tax matters. what are the important challenges before GST council
- What is the issue related to under construction housing and GST.
- Tell me why india is lagging in defense manufacturing.(i quoted new draft policy on def production)
- Do you know about new defense production policy. Tell me about it
- is it accepted or in draft stage
M1
- ok as you are an electronics engineer, tell me whether evm are hackable?
- why are we not able to manufacture enough electronics hardware to meet our needs.
- We all know that climate change affects agriculture. You tell me how agriculture affects climate change
M2
- As your optional is literature, tell me about book 'sanskara' and about its author?
- when did this modern literature movement in kannada see its peak?
- ok as you have worked in voluntary sector, can you tell me what was your work profile there.
- what did you learn from your work experience there?
M3
- As you have talked Mr U R Anantmurty, tell me something about Kuvempu also.
- when we think about Karnataka, we only imagine about Banaglore as if there in nothing other than Bangalore in Karnataka. Why this skewed development
- so as you say there is imbalance in development of north karnataka, shouldn't we go for a seperate north karnataka state.
- why there were so much of complications while implementing GST. (I said any big reform of the nature of gst is going to face some difficulties, challenges were mainly practical in nature.)
- If difficulties of gst were operational and practical in nature, there should have been more planning.?(howsoever meticulous planning we do, we cannot take all possibilites into account while planning. Also india being such a diverse country, there will be some challenges which will come up only during implementation.)
- Why IT Dept doesnt face such problems while GST is facing so many challenges. (Its not that IT didnt face any challenges. IT systems have evolved over time and have reached stable state now. Even our e assessment has created lot of challenges on ground and its evolving now like gst)
M4
- As you are undergoing training now in IRS, what are the changes we need to bring in terms of tax rates.
- You have done lot of extra curricular activites. We will pick one. What kind of music have you presented in DD and Akashvani.
- Is your gharana and gharana of Bhimsen Joshi same?
CM
- Ok let us talk a little about your experience in voluntary sector.
- I'll ask you an important question. I want a frank answer from you. Should we hold NGOs accountable. (No instituion can go without accountability in a democracy. But the issue is to whom these NGOs should be accountable. They cannot be held accountable by govt bcz it is NGOs who are supposed to hold govt accountable. We should instead have an autonomous body like press council of india for this purpose. But NGOs should be accountable to govt to the extent of funds recieved by govt if they are getting any funds from govt.)
- Now suppose I'll make you DM of a district. Your district has multiple disaster hazards and also it is a backward district. There are lot of NGOs willing to work with District Administration. How will you utilise them. In what all roles?
- One last question. Say your district has 5 NGOs working at ground level. But all of them are concentrating on one taluq leaving aside other taluqs. How will you resolve this. Because we in this board have faced it on ground. (I didn't know how to answer this. So i said sir I'm not able to give any solution at this point, but given time, I'll definitely find a solution for that.)
- At this point he said well you can talk to them as a first measure. - I said yes sir, thats always a solution bcz i believe there is no problem which can't be solved by talking.
- another member quipped smilingly at this point - does this apply to pakistan also.
- I said in short term it may not, but in long run that's the only solution we have.
- Chairman smiled "your interview is over"
Yogesh Choudhary:
Yogesh Choudhary:
Bhonsle sir board
Transcript: I was the first one to go, forenoon session on 21/02/2019
Chairman:-
You are opener, so what are the challenges for an opening batsmen in cricket.
Attitude or skill/aptitude - which is more important. I have said both. But he asked about which is more important. I have said skill.
But he said that there is another view that attitude is more important. Skill is more important for lower clerical jobs and attitude is for decision making jobs. Then I agreed with sir.
Rajathan 10 problems 10 strength
M1
Is India a weak state? And counter question on this issue. Later he asked on crypto currency, block chain technology. He also asked about low child sex ratio and how to improve it.
Your hobby is jogging. What are the other things you do? I said that movies music and recently I have been going to gym. Then he asked me about heart rate for cardio exercises. Here I was not able to answer appropriate heart rate but I have told that I exercises at about 170.
M2
She asked about a book "a glimpse of world history". (Optional history). As I haven't read the book. She then moved to artificial intelligence and asked about some examples.
M3
Afghanistan issue. Why countries after countries are failing there.
Can US solve it by using all military power?
I said that it would not be solved till people of Afghanistan own that process.
M4-
You have studied Sanskrit in 10th. What do you understand by sanskriti.
Explain unity in diversity in India.
How to improve tourism in Rajasthan.
Chairman-
Republic day speech of president where president talked about forthcoming election and completion of 70 yr of Independence. What does he mean to say that we should vote with collective wisdom and collective action.
I said that first voter turnout should be increased to show that out democracy has matured. Second various election documentries mention about vote on religion, region, caste issues. So as collective wisdom we should vote for thinking of India as a whole not these small issues.
No questions from my graduation
Saurav
Optional - PSIR
21st Feb
Board B B Vyas - Forenoon - 3rd to go.
Duration - Approx 30 mins
Chairman -
Changes in india's foreign policy in last 2 to 3 years
On what basis foreign policy of country is based ? Explain with examples
Is removibg MFN status from Pakistan is symbolic ? What are the other economic punitive measures taken by India <200 percent duty hike thing>
Why are we connecting aadhar, bank account and pan card ? What we are going to achieve
M1
What is cooperative federalism. Explain with example
Issues between West bengal and central government
CBI vs West bengal ?
What is general consent in CBI case ?
How the CBI vs State police could have been handeled ?
M2
What is GST ? What we achieved
Was demonitisation a success ?
Difference between CBI and NIA
M3
What is trump wall ?
Which Finance Commission is this ? Who is heading it ? What was the issue <Census 2011 thing> ? What is the article number of FC ?
M4
Difference between bengaluru and west bengal culture
Jobs related question
What is BREXIT ?
Board members were very cordial and supportive .. Specially chairman sir.
Extremly sorry for posting the transcipt late
Rahul Mandiwal
25/02/2019(Afternoon Session)
B.Tech (Chemical Engineering)
Optional - Hindi Literature
Sathyawathi Ma'am Board
Chairmen
1. So do you read newspaper( My Hobby)
So which newspaper you read?
2. What are today's headlines.
3. Which page of a newspaper do you read very first.
3. Why civil service aspirants prefer the Hindu a lot?
3. Which one is last English novel that you read (Hobby)?
4. What do you think about M S Dhoni? Is he a burden on team India?
Member 1 -
1. What is ICBM?
2. Difference between ICBM and Cruise Missile.
3. What is first strike and second strike?
4. On which technology Nuclear Bomb works? What is there that makes nuclear bomb so much dangerous?
Member 2-
1. Why did you opt Civil services instead of career in Chemical Engineering?
2. How would you justify that Chemistry or Chemicals useful for us and at a same time pollution creating agent. And what action will you take for this?
Member 3 -
1. What is tripod attack?
2. Nuclear bomb capabilities of India.
3. What do you think about pollution in Ganga.
Then he said answer this in three formats
A. What are causes of pollution in Ganaga? B. What is govt doing about this?
C. What is your idea about cleaning Ganga?
Member 4 -
1.So which newspaper is your favourite?
2. Which Novel you last read in Hindi and what did you learn from that.
3. What will you advise our PM on Pakistan at this time?
Is war an option ?
4. So Rahul imagine that you have one minute and you have to explain that why should we select you as an IAS officer then what will your reply?
Then after he said that you 10 seconds to think about it.
After answering thus question Chairman Ma'am said Thank You Rahul. You may go now.
Overall interview board was very cordial.
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «So finally CSE 2018 Personality Tests are going to begin from today. We wish All the Best to all for their respective D-day. Just be optimistic, confident, smiling and reasonably honest in your answers. That's it. Please DO WRITE AND SHARE your interview...»