UPSC interview, Dinesh Dasa board, 1 Mar 2024 (Bihar, Delhi)
1 Mar 2024
Date : 01/03/2024
Afternoon Session, 3rd to go
Board : Dinesh Dasa Sir
Medium of Interview: English
DAF Pointers : B. Tech, IIT Delhi (2020), Katihar, Bihar, Physics Optional, Research Internships, University of Sydney, University of Groningen, HPAIR Conference Harvard University
Nothing else was asked from DAF (5-6 more pointers like contemporary dance, cricket, NSS, etc.)
Attempts: 3rd, 2nd Mains, 2nd Interview (Not recommended earlier)
Service Preference : IAS-IPS-IFS-IRS
Chairperson
⁃ You are from Katihar, done your B. Tech. from IIT Delhi have done internships in Sydney, Groningen and attended Harvard conference , now tell me : while arguing in a Supreme Court case examining state’s right to identify backward classes, one of the lawyers argued that it will lead to the balkanisation of the caste list. What do you mean by balkanisation and what is your opinion on that?
⁃ 3 global problems that the world is facing
⁃ Non-state actors in India
⁃ Are Khaps non state actors?
⁃ 1-2 more questions I am forgetting.
Members (in no particular order) - All male
⁃ How are you?
⁃ Explain Physics, Engineering and Engineering Physics.
⁃ Tell me what all things you did in Sydney, Groningen and Harvard. More conversation on this
⁃ What all did you learn from your research experience?
⁃ We have been focussing on cutting edge research while we still face the issue of poverty, hunger, etc. Do we really need that? Good- said the member.
⁃ Is Russia a European power or an Asian power.
⁃ Sweden became the 32nd member to join NATO. What can be the implications
⁃ Was it correct for EU and NATO countries to jump to support Ukraine in the war
⁃ 1-2 more questions on Russia (No no this wasn’t Russia PSC exam)
⁃ In the starting, how many members were there in EU? I said I am not aware.
⁃ A country has constantly been applying for EU membership but hasn’t been granted yet. Which country is that and what are the reasons behind the same?
⁃ You talked about the role of non-state actors in the north east region of India, what problems did non-state actors posed to USA in the aftermath of 2003 Iraq invasion? I said I do not have sufficient knowledge about Iraq issue.
⁃ What is I2U2? What are the focus areas? Do you think after the events of 7th October, the grouping has been jeopardised?
⁃ Groningen or Netherlands in particular has this culture of bicycles, problems of it being implemented in Delhi? Can shifting to bicycles help the problem of poor AQI in Delhi? Have you gone through the AQI study conducted by IIT Delhi? Good- said the member.
⁃ Asked about some traditional rainwater harvesting system which I was unaware of and said that I do not know, similarly one question on Green Term Deposit Scheme.
⁃ Which book did you read last, apart from your preparation books?
⁃ What is constitution? What is the role of constitution?
⁃ What is Free Movement Regime? Is it still there?
⁃ How can we improve the efficiency of public service delivery? Good- said the member.
⁃ As a District Magistrate of Katihar, what will you do?
⁃ What are the powers of Zila Panchayat?
⁃ What was the 73rd CAA?
⁃ How are PRIs working in Bihar/Katihar?
⁃ How often do you visit Katihar? What changes have you observed?
⁃ You did your schooling from Scottish Public School? Is it still affiliated to Scotland? I said there was never any connection. So they just named it like that, interesting. Smiled and the chairperson said thank you.
⁃ Few supplementary questions in between which I can’t recall.
A significant difference with mocks was that they gave sufficient time to speak without interrupting at all, only to be seen in Vision Bureaucratic Mock. The quality of questions (and not content) were comparable to those in Samkalp (although in 1 Sankalp mock 3/4 members asked from physics as if it were a phd recruitment interview). 2 mocks in Samkalp from last year and 1 mock from this year were very close. Chahal and Vajirao were also very good.
Date of Interview: 28.02.2024
Board: Suman sharma mam
Daf pointers: Economics, Law, Delh, Cricket.
Chairman
1. After perusing my daf while I entered: So there is this notion that rich people feel that they are cheated for paying taxes. What are your views on it?
2. Dont you think they are doubly taxed?
3. Shouldn't they be exempted from GST?
4. No of people filing returns are increasing but no of tax payers are not. Your views?
5. Resource, geography and importance of MENA region? (I asked what is MENA? She said Middle East North Africa. I gave random answer to which she was not satisfied).
6. What proportion of fossil fuels reserve are there in MENA?
7. What are renewable energy resourse there?
8. Who won the Grammy awards?
Member 1
1. Stakeholders in implementation of new criminal laws?
2. Challenges in implementation?
3. 2 imp changes in New Evidence act?
4. Why does it take so much time to decide cases?
5. Who pioneered PIL?
6. Its relevance when SC has so many pending cases of its own?
7. Shouldnt laws be made by Legislature and not SC?
Member 2
1. Which country said it will send troops to ukraine?
2. Which countries apposed?
3. What was Russia's response?
4. Consequence of such war?
5. Should we have bilateral series with pakistan?
6. Should nt we seperate sports from Foreign policy?
7. What kind of fans will appose such kind of match series? (From my previous answer)
Member 3
1. What is happening in Rakhine?
2. Indias connectivity initiatives in Rakhine?
3. Security issues and China's army role there. I had no clue about it.
4. Imp of Balochistan?
5. Geography of balochistan?
Member 4
1. Status and performance of UN.
2. Suggest some UN reforms.
Overall the board was cordial. It was more like a conversation and wanted my opinion. Chairman Mam wanted very specific answers which at times I could not give. Also she asked me to shorten my answer with Member 2.
Mocks: Team MIP, Samkalp, Vajirao and Reddy, Chanakya Mandal.
020: Mohan Sir at IAS Baba.
Utkarsh Shukla Tg Putnam:
28th Feb 2024: Afternoon slot
Edsarrthi Student Transcript
👇👇👇👇👇👇
BB Swain sir Board
Daf keywords- UP, Meerut, Sociology, Manufacturing technology, IFS, Mindfulness Meditation, Penpalling
30mins
Chairman sir- What is the significance of Meerut with respect to freedom struggle ?
Why was Meerut chosen as the starting point?
Member1-
1. Why have you chosen IFS over IPS?
2.If you become the foreign secretary how will you try to manage the Israel and Hamas crisis?
3. What is the evacuation plan of Israel?
4. What is US's stand ?
5. What is penpalling and how do u do it?
6.What is the difference between European nations and Asian countries?
7.Why did you chose those particular countries?
8. What is Mindfulness Meditation? What is Mindfulness ? Elaborate
Member 2-
1. What is Manufacturing technology? How is it different from industrial engg?
2. What are the famous products of Meerut under ODOP ?
3. Important industries of Meerut, reason for success?
4. How will you use AI to improve the various sectors of Meerut?
5. What are your learnings from college?
Member 3-
1. So you mentioned about particular sectors , why did you chose them and what is their current status in UP.
2. What are the various issues that you feel with respect to education sector in rural areas of UP?
Follow up on the same
3.What will you do as a DM to make education inclusive ?
4. Why there is a low drop out of girls in secondary education?
5. What innovative steps would you like to take to make education better?
Member 4- Ma'am
1. So you talked about women led development what do you mean by that?
2. Where in India do you see women led development?
3. Women reservation bill criticisms.?
4. Concept of Sarpanch Pati? Why do they still exist ?
5. Number of seats reserved for women by political parties?
6. As a DM How would you work towards women empowerment at ground level?
Chairman- Do you want us to ask anything we missed?
I said No sir thankyou 🙂
Chair-Thankyou, Your Interview is over.
All the best.
Overall experience- cordial panel and in a conversation mode , so listening patiently without much cross questions,
Mock experience- Given 7 panel mocks, 3 one on one..
Utility- helped to structure answers
One on One with Utkarsh sir (Edsarrthi) , Puneet sir ( SOMP) and Khan sir was very helpful in confidence building and tackle situation based questions.
Vajiram, KSG, Samkalp, Chahal were on similar lines as the real interview..
Name - xyz
Date - 28/02/2024
Session - forenoon
Board - Hon’ble Suman Maam
Places mentioned - Patna , Bihar, West Bengal , Kharagpur
College - IIT Kharagpur 2019
Optional - Geography
Work profile - Consulting
Hobbies - watching Warfare documentary
Achievements- Reseach intern in USA (relevant) etc
———————
Chairman
She started with reading my Daf and highlighted some keywords like IIT , Mining , Consulting etc
1. So you worked for Big 4. Do you know aby recent controversy regarding it ?
2. Tell me about gender budgeting
3. What is composite license
4. How many Ev were sold last year ?
5. What is your opinion regarding Elections in colleges ? Dont you think it creates a ruck us and hinders the administration ?
M1
1. Tell me about panchayat
2. You mentioned Self governance - so is it being effective in Bihar ? Told them about Jeevika and some SHGs in South bihar with slight clue from my mining background
3. Do you know Quad ?
4. What countries are there in Quad ?
5. Why did they formed abother grouping if they could have engaged bilaterally? What was the need of a special platform
6. You are from IIT , dont you think brain drain is an issue ? What should be done to stop it - i gave some general answer inspired from budget and also mentioned my personalied experience
M2- in Grilling Mode
1. Why west bengal is so noisy as far as elections are concerned
2. What is tje govt doing
3. How to channelise the energy of youth and women ( inspired by answer regarding comparing WB per capita income and national avg , unemployment rate and politically charged environment)
4. What is Kanyashree scheme
5. Tell me about the paddy seasons of West bengal
M3
1. You watch warfare documentary- tell me about why Israel failed ?
2. What strategy Hamas adopted in warfare ?
3. How did they break through iron dome
4. First indian in space indian
5. I told Shri Rakesh sharma ji so he asked me the recent technology of Gaganyaan
6. Name the 4 shaktis of Gaganyaan ( it was in news that day)
7. What is the difference between the first soace mission and the latest one
M4
1. What are the ethical considerations in AI ?
2. You are a technical person , tell me about the tokens in AI and be technical
3. What are the algorithms used in Data analysis- i have previously mentioned K means algo and some regression techniques
4. Tell me which statistical distributions i will adopt in administration to analyse the population data set - i said normal and posissons distributions, so he asked me about the confidence intervals and the expected mean - i didn’t remember the formula
5. What is your view about Deep fake ?
I told abour the Rashmika case etc
6. Tell me the technical solution to it - i told them about the solution and also moved one step further and gave them an innovative solution which i noted from the WEF Davos meet ( kimd of industry academia linkage )
Suman maam - you interview is over mr xyz. You can go
I stood up, took a few steps back and said - thank you maam , thank you hon’ble board members .
Experience- maza aaya ( pahle thoda load tha ) but it was a life time experience
Board - they listened to me very patiently even if i gave long answers . 2 board members said very good
Mock utility - Samkalp ( sitting arrangement), Chahal was good
Vajo rao - faltu ka grilling
Vajiram and Vision - good question were asked related to daf
Sleepy classes online - it is the worst panel , a faculty of geo wanted to prove her knowledge
Advice - stay away from negative panel members , there is a famous personality now a days (female )., she will try to pull your legs under the garb of asking good questions
All the best guys ! I have mentioned all the questions to the best of my knowledge.
Special thanks to Satyam Jain sir ( for motivating me and inspiring me ). His regular news paper sessions and immense experience is worth learning from.
2. I would also like the thank Utkarsh sir from edsaarthi for his tireless efforts in his sessions and constant push before and after tje interview.
3. My peer group with whom i had regular discussions