Interviews

UPSC interview, Suman Sharma board, 22 Jan 2024

22 Jan 2024

UPSC CSE 2024

Date of interview: 16/01/24

Afternoon session

Chairperson: Suman Sarma

Daf keywords: History , St Stephens, JNU, Debating, Historical drama and documentaries, Assam,Piano

Duration: 30-35 mins

Chairperson

Okay so you are from Stephens and you have studied history.

1. Have you heard about the PMI?

Who publishes it and what is India’s position?

( I said ma’am I just know about the full form that is Purchasing Managers Index but I am not aware about the details)

2. What are the contribution of the different sectors of the economy?

3. Is it a good thing that the service sector is doing well?

( Felt a little interrogated as the chairperson was trying to provoke a yes or no answer)

4. If you are the Revenue secretary, what are the three suggestions you will give to the finance minister regarding the budget?

( She made a remark about how my points were very generic and that she already knows this points)

5. Why has India not been able to fulfil its CAPEx targets?

M2

1. Do you think that the number of parliamentary seats given to the states be frozen or there is a need to redraw them?

2. You said we need to redraw them, don’t you think that it will unduly benefit the states who haven’t co trolled their population?

( I tried to give a balanced answer , but he kept of nodding his head in disagreement )

3. What do you know about the chicken neck corridor?

4. What are the implications of india Bangladesh relation on Assam?

5. Do you think there should be a free economic trade corridor between India and Bangladesh?

M3

1. The mongol empire , which is considered to be the biggest empire in the world could not sustain for long. Why?

2 why did the Ottoman Empire expand towards west but was not able to do it towards east in India?

3. All major civilizations like the Egyptian or Mesopotamian civilization could not sustain, but why did the Indian civilization

4. If you are the defense secretary, what measures will you take to secure the borders in NE?

Asked a few more history related questions and follow up questions.

M4

1. Tell me something about the Architecture of Rose city?

( I said I don’t know ma’am)

2. Okay then tell me what you know about Machu pichu?

3. Tell me three things special about Assam?

Follow up question on where else Rhino’s are found except Kaziranga. Where they have been translocated recently

4. Tell me something about the tea industry?

5. Why were so few G20 summits were held in north east?

( I did not understand if they asked why so few or so many)

6. Recently North east has seen many connectivity projects , especially in railways, can you comment

M5

1.It is seen that western countries has low growth rate , but India has a higher growth rate. Is there a need for india to slow down?

2. What is the relation between inflation and employment?

3. Should inflation in India be more around 10 percent? Because if it is less won’t growth get compromised

Follow up question on how high inflation can hurt the poor

There were many follow up questions based on what I was saying trying to provoke me to say yes or no or to contradict myself

4. It is often said history repeats itself, but economics never repeats. Please explain

Chairperson: you may now leave

My personal feedback

1.The entire interview felt knowledge heavy

2. The person who went before me said the board was very cordial and made you feel comfortable , but I did not feel the same. What were clearing making their disapproval of what I said clear or saying that my points were very generic. Never felt comfortable throughout the interview , felt like questions were being no Bombarded and I was being interrogated

3. The last panel member spoke in a few low voice and was not legible. Had a lot of difficulty understanding the questions despite asking twice. Finally the chair had to paraphrase

4. Two people focused solely on economics which was nowhere mentioned in my daf. Have no economics background and they tried to go deep into economic issues

5. Questions on Assam / history were on predictable lines

Hello sir, this is my transcript

Name: Poorva Agrawal

Board: Choubey sir

date: 17/1/24 (afternoon session, 5th to go)

daf: economics, chhattisgarh (no ques from other key words)

Chairman - be comfortable, this is just a friendly conversation (typical choubey sir pleasantries)

1. What is electoral bond? what is the controversy around it? What are your views?

2. Wont making doner's list public reduce their incentive to donate?

3. Wont it lead to witch hunting by parties against donors of rival parties?

Member 1

1. Tell about india-nepal relations.

2. Why did relations nose dive in 2015?

3. What are challenges in india nepal relations today?

4. What is china's interests in nepal?

5. Tell about tourism potential of lakshdeep

Member 2

1. Asked two vague random questions on the plight of indians stuck in israel due to the recent conflict - chairman asked him to re articulate his questions - when he rearticulated chairman seemed irritated at his vague questions and requested him to move to other questions

2. Impact of houthis attacks in red sea on india

3. What is marble trail in your neighbouring state Madhya Pradesh?

Member 3

1. Why were you given this award? (referring to an award mentioned in my daf 7th entry)

2. What is adult literacy? Steps taken for it? What is its importance?

3. Do you know about recent changes to definition of adult literacy?

4. What is regional disparity? Will you allocate more resources to backward states or well performing states? I said backward states - so then she asked - Wont it be like punishing them for good performance?

5. What do you think of gay marriage?

Member 4

1. What are the limits for election spending by candidates of lok sabha and rajya sabha?

2. What changes do you suggest? What steps must be taken to ensure this?

3. Do you know about bemetara in chhattisgarh? Why was it in news?

4. What is the status of malnutrition in cg? What steps have been taken?

Chairman - (again typical choubey sir question) - Our questions are over. Do you want to tell us about something we've missed?

Overall experience - choubey sir was very motivating, encouraged me to speak, cancelled vague questions by member 2, and was nodding and taking interest in what i was saying. Overall it was a very pleasant experience. From the security guards at the entrance to the chairman of your board, everyone will treat you with full ijjat 😂

mock experience - no mock was even an iota of what my actual interview was like. But taking mocks did help me to break my inertia to speak, improve fluency and get used to to handling unknown questions

Interview date : 18 Jan

Shift: afternoon

Turn: 4th to enter

Board: Swain sir

Optional: Geography

Keywords : Faizabad , Lucknow, University of Lucknow, Mobile photography, short stories and poems, mentoring , volleyball, GEOGRAPHY.

Ch.person.: confirmed my name since in photograph I wasn't clean shaved

1. Asked about mobile photography

2. Why professional don't use the mobile phone

3. His monologue on how the cameras of mobile change the feature

4. Do you publish it?

He said he'll visit my insta page

Shifted to other members

M 1 (lady):

1. Short stories and have you read O. Henry (said no)

Asked about premchand

2. What makes premchand's writing special ?

3. Lucknow speciality

4. Any other country with population comparable to up where you want to go

5. Why Norway?

6. How has geographical attractions of Norway

7.Cuisine of Lucknow and its special features

8. Do you know dam pukht?(knew it but refrained from guessing, she herself explained

9.Wajid Ali Shah who was he?

10. Why was awadh annexed ?

Passed on to m2

M 2 :

1. You missed one thing about Lucknow speciality what was it?

(It was dialect and tone)

2. Why were imambaras built?

3. How is geography awadhi cuisine and imabara related.(Answer specific to these three aspect)

4. How is lucknow metro doing?

1 to 2 more question don't remember them

Passed on to M 3

M 3 :

1. Why geography optional? Gives an edge in exam.

2. Climate issues what are they?

3. Global warming and what is it actually?

4. Is india doing enough ? Development and ecological conservation where should india lean?

5. What are problems faced during combating climate change

6. Defend india at global stage wrt to its emissions

Passed on to M 4.

M 4 :

1. Tell me any short story you wrote?

2. Do you generally write comedy stories or any social message is there?

3. University of Lucknow has beautiful campus so no space issue why is it lagging in ranking?

4.What is underprivileged for you? What problems they face like any example?

5. Isn't it more like helping?

6..how many have you mentored till now?

7. How has volleyball contributed to your life? What positions did you play?

8. Cpec what is it?

9. How is india countering it? Any recent effort

10. Imec full form and its stretch?

Time: 30 min (no clock in there so it's a rough estimate )

Ch.person. : your interview is over.

Board was as said by many quite cordial.

Prepare daf you can use it multiple times.

Optional's practical should be done properly as application based question were asked.

All best everyone