UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 19 Feb 2019 (3)
19 Feb 2019
SURAJ PATEL
Sujata mehta ma'am board
After noon ( 19 Feb , 5th in 6 candidates )
My profile : mechanical , IRS , IPS ( uttar Pradesh ) , now undertraining at NPA .
Chairperson :
1- would you like to Introduce yourself . About your education and job experience.
( She asked about my cadre , and said that it's good that you have home cadre )
2- why Police image in UP controversial ?? ( Encounter not mentioned )
: My response started with the fact that yes mam there are many media reports about it.
3- Do u think it's not based upon truth . It's a fake impression ?
:: No ma'am , I will not say that it's an incorrect impression largely .
4- Why buland shahar incident happened ? What are your views ? If you wish you can deny to answer that .
Answered .... Police public gap , less empathy in mind s of people for police , multi level systematic failure causing SHO death etc .
5- Recently in Hyderabad an airport officer was manhandled by an M.P , police officers who die in line of duty are not supported by system. Why system and people don't support civil servants ??
:: People have high expectations and people support us a lot too . But sometimes when people 's expectation are not met they go into a state of confusion / dilemma about our image. And when such situation repeats they usually take an anti civil service side .
Member 1 :: health policy as secretary ? As there is precarious situation in hinterland and tribal areas. ?
2- Pulwama attack , how u will avoid ? If u r DG CRPF ?
3-What if you don't have intelligence ?
4-Why ppl join services even when everybody criticise ?
Member 2 ::
Crpf case study : u r an SP and CRPF people killed someone , and you came to kNow about this later and rushed to that spot with few men. Thee crpf people surround you and demand that you give in writing that you gave this order else they will kill you . What to do ?
What you think about evolution theories ?
Member 3 ::
Do you think India's credibility in science have reduced ? Some Nobel laureate have made some comment ?
Should we talk to Taliban ?
Should we talk to Pakistan in current situation ?
Stages of human evolution ?
How to use big data in policing ?
Member 4 ::
Questions on ncrb . :: Who have police data ? Do states have such organization ? What are the issues in predicting crime by using this data ?
Many questions related to ::
flexible persons are compliant and more suitable to political bosses , why you will be straightforward ?
Why straightforward people are sidelined ?
Recently in chattisgarh last 3 chief secretaries were those who already spent some time in jail . Your views ?
Delhi police have launched good community based policing measures . What you think ?
What you think about solid waste management ? How to manage that in Kanpur or in any other big city ? Or for that matter how to deal with any kind of waste ?
When police image is bad , why ppl want to join IPS ?
Any question you want to ask ?
:: Yes mam , last year also you took my interview ( she said ohh is it so ) ...And I wanted to ask this question then : what is the one quality a leader must possess ?
( Chairperson responded that she had been through her interview ...Lol )
Overall an average experience. Could have done better . Sujata ma'am used to frame questions in 6-7 lines making them vague and complicated .
Best wishes to all of those who are going to appear .
Regards
For any queries or comment or suggestions please drop me a mail at suraj.patel@gov.in