UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 12 Jun 2023
12 Jun 2023
Name: Chintu Cheetah
Date: 12 June, forenoon session
Board: Lt Gen Shukla sir
Duration: 30 mins
Optionals: Geology & Forestry
DAF: M.A. Anthropology, no Q from other details
———————
Chairperson:
Read out my full name and asked if it is correct.
Q. Where are you from?
Q. Views about cheetah reintroduction
Q. What are the concerns in general with regard to translocations?
Q. But in the past the princes did import cheetahs that too via road/sea and they did survive in India so why so much concern with present relocation?
Q. Cheetah cubs deaths
Q. Female cheetahs gave birth to cubs, so can we call it a success?
Q. At present how many cheetahs are there in India?
Q. Cheetahs will evenutally fight with each other over territorial dominance because of limited space and resources of Kuno so did we not think about it?
Q. Possibility of cheetahs coming in conflict with humans and what could be done?
Q. Cheetahs unable to find preys in India what could be the reason?
Q. Can we relocate preys for cheetah?
Q. Long monologue...ultimately we how can we extract economic gains by conserving species like tiger, cheetah, lion?
Q. Views about hunting, is it a good sport or a cruel sport?
Q. But Jim Cobett and all did hunt so what is the problem?
Q. Can we apply the hunting model of conservation in ?
Q. Some q on lion conservation...unable to recall it
Q. Important of tiger corridors
Q. Are all tiger reserves connected to each other via tiger corridors?
———————
Member 1: (Most probably, an IFoS officer)
Q. Long monologue about need to balance economic development and environment conservation...you have studied engineering now tell me where would you position yourself?
Q. Specifically as with regards to forests and as a forest officer role can you play?
Q. Some successful species conservation project other than Tiger.
Q. (As I mentioned about Indian Rhino) member 3 intervened and asked the names other Rhino species
Q. Any other project where a species was on the brink of extinction and we were able to successfully raise the population?
Q. Some Q relating to Rhino relocation in UP
———————
Member 2:
Q. Name some anthropological sites in Maharashtra and oldest sites in India
Q. Before I could complete my answer, he asked what about Bhimbetka?
Q. Name some tribes which are on brink of extinction.
Q. Jarawas being negatively impacted by some road project. Views on it.
Q. As a forest officer what could you do to aid in the development of tribals?
———————
Member 3 (I could read his badge, he was a Professor)
Q. What led you to do M.A. in Anthropology after B. Tech?
Q. By focussing on beautiful species like Tiger, lion, cheetah, etc are we doing partiality towards other animals?
(As I'm just about to answer, Shukla sir accidently played a youtube video on his PC 😅)
Q. I'm very confused with these terms, can you tell me what are Umbrella species
Q. I'm still confused, now tell me what are Flagship species
Q. I'm again confused, now tell me what are Keystone species
Q. You mentioned ecological niche, could you explain it?
Q. Long monologue describing some technology and in the end asked if I could identify the technology (it was remote sensing)
Q. Again a monologue and some q in the end. 🤔 I asked for clarification if he wanted me to explain the working principle of remote sensing to which he said yes
Q. Examples of softwares using remote sensing used in forestry
———————
By now I was expecting that it would be the turn of member 4 to ask Qs. But I heard the words "thank you" from the chairperson.
Untill then I had not even realised that there was an extra member in the panel (he was Shri Bidyut Bihari Swain)!
———————
Overall experience:
The board is very cordial and all members listen to the answers keenly.
Members give signs of appreciation for good points.
Carefully listening to the monologues is very important to understand what exactly is the question. Most of the times the monologue starts with a Q and by the end of the monologue the demand of the Q has been totally changed.
Selected Candidates Marks CSE 2022.pdf
16th June - Afternoon Session
First to go
Shukla sir board
Approx 30-35 min
First Observation: Very pleasant room , members sitting randomly.
No welcome monologue, nothing...Just said , Good afternoon, Sit and directly started with Hobbies.
Chairman :
So you have adventure profile , did parasailing and all. Tell us what all have you did.
Where did you trekked. To what distance and height. Will you continue after service ?
Started with a monologue China and India population and Population control measures.. Tried to change statement alot of times.. On this question discussion went long.
Finally he wanted to ask (what I understood)
- Population progressing , surpassed China , Is it good ?
- If good , then why are we promoting population control measures.
Did a bit grilling on that. Looked at the watch behind and said thank you
Member 2 :
So you like cooking. What kind of cooking
Which chinese dish was originated in India
Passed a joke on chinese food and said no offence to china but they can not eat Indian food at all.. Then asked Why ?
Then passed a blatant statement ,India is good for nothing...No where in any field it's progressing. What is your stand. ?
Grilled on this question for sometime ( At last I thought he was little expressive, so by his expressions I could judge he was satisfied )
You live is Rajasthan , we always hear that desertification is bad and all that . tell me some benefits Thar is providing to Rajasthan. ( i said 2 points , he helped with 2 more.)
Have you heard of Aerial seeding , what was that and where it was done.
What is the importance of Prosopis Juliflora.
If it is important fuel wood , why can't we just cultivate it even if it's invasive.
Said Thank you and passed the baton to third member.
Member 3 : Can't recall many of his questions.
Asked Demonetisation..What is the difference between now and then ?
What issues people are facing now. ?
Asked about work profile. How much Cairn is contributing to Indian economy.
Oil sector issues
Member 4 : (Difficult to hear questions from him , so I had to say pardon 2-3 times )
So you are a bhatnagar , which award is given wrt this surname , what is the criteria and in which field )
So you live in Rajasthan, Don't you think there are too much focus on Tiger and Great Indian Bustard is neglected.
I started why so , but he said no I am not asking this , now my question is , any conservation efforts for GIB ?
What population ?
Any success in conservation? etc
Have you heard of Dolphin ?
Where it is found , what is the speciality.
Is it a fish , a insect ...What is it..?
I said sir Mammal , then he asked characteristics of mammals. I said mammary glands.
Then he said have you seen it yourself or just telling bookish thing.
Where in India it is found.Tell me the exact places and location not rivers.
Any important place in Bihar ?
Any where in Himachal ?
Have you read about it ? Any scientific basis ?
Overall experience - Board was cordial and helping. Member 4 asked a lot of factual questions.
Chairman asked his set of questions and started working on his PC..Last me he said Good, thank you and All the Best.
(Also one person was coming inside, taking some documents again and again..Noisy Gate. Because of which at times it was difficult to hear the questions. happened to me when Member 3 and 4 were asking questions..)
16th June - Afternoon Session
First to go
Preeti Sudan board
Approx 30 min
First Observation: It's a conference room with 4 members sitting around the big round table
welcome greetings by mam,
She said , Good afternoon, Sit and we are here for normal conversation and. There is nothing you have to worry about it.
Chairwoman :
1. You have done graduation from Electrical Engineering from reputed college and that too with very good marks, then why did not you continue your carrier along engineering stream, why to choose this service.
2. Also, your DAF mentions about panna national park
So tell me, I want to visit the panna national park, is it a good place to
visit and why and what are It's attractions.
Thereafter some follow up questions
Member 1 -
1. Tell me about the flora and fauna of panna national park.
2. What are main species found there.
3. What are the avifaunna there.
4. Which part of forestry subject you are attracted most
5. Tell me about the silvicultural system of forest
6. Name of some species found in upper and lower canopy.
Member 2 -
1. Have you heard about pollution
2. What is water pollution and their constituents.
3. Namami ganga program and what are the constituent of leather industry pollutants.
3. What is air pollution and it's main source of pollution
4. Source of methane emission
5. What are wetlands and why they are so important
6. What are the importance of shrubs and lower trees.
7. Which type of forest in your opinion is good for environment
Member 4 -
1. Justice delayed is justice denied
Do you agree with that and why
2. Suggest some innovative solutions , being an engineer, to reduce pendency of cases
3. Visit of Nepal PM in india
4. Manipur violence, immediate reasons and mains issues surrounding theses
5. Implications of granting ST status to meiti and why kuki are protesting
6. One issue was also there, it is related to illegal cultivation of some crops which is also involved in organised crime (He is talking about poppy cultivation)
7. Which particular rights is kuki tribes is most worry about it ST status is granted to meiti.
Finally the chairwoman said
Your interview is over and all the best
Overall - discussion on diverse topics and issues ranging from DAF to Forestry to Current affairs.