Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 5 Jun 2023 (Kerala)

5 Jun 2023

IFS Interview Transcript (5th June 2023, Afternoon)

Board: Smitha Nagaraj

DAF Details

Mechanical Engineering, Working as a Faculty, Worked in Cold Chain sector, Place: Kannur, Kerala

Optional: Geology and Forestry

No questions regarding hobbies or leadership or prizes

Asked permission to enter, wished everyone on the board. Took the seat when permitted.

Chair:

1. What is this Edsys Labs? (Where I work) Who started it? Are you a shareholder? Why didn't you take it? So, now you are just an employee.. (She told me I should have taken it as it was a good opportunity.)

2. Silent Valley Project. What happened to it?

3. Any guidelines you can remember to regulate the degradation of the environment?

4. Reasons for floods in Kerala. (First said about landslides, then zeroed in on floods) How much can be attributed to Climate change.. do you have any research literature or study to support that?

Member 1

1. Do you think tourism damages the environment? Do you support more areas being opened up for tourism? Why couldn't Kerala develop a successful Tourism model (as it has so many other models)?

2. You come from Payyanur in Kannur (Kerala). Tell me what's famous in Thalassery (another place in Kannur)? What else is famous in Thalassery? What's its etymology? Then you can arrive at the specialty.. (Didn't know- so he explained it to me)

3. You have worked in the Engineering sector? Where did you work? Was it (the product) fish? What product in food processing? Why did you leave it? Why are you so into (he used another word which I was not able to hear or understand) civil services?

Member 2 (spoke with a thick Hindi slang; had a hard time understanding)

1. What is Ocean Acidification? (Before I could answer) what is the pH of the ocean? It's salty, it's basic.. have you heard about Coral Reefs.. why are they being degraded? What is the pH range needed for its growth? What are the salts present in the ocean? Can you give me what percentage?

2. What is Atlantic Conveyor? Yes, it's a circulation - From where to where? What is thermocline? Does it act as a barrier?

4. Why did you pick Geology as your optional subject? Why civil services after mechanical engineering?

5. What type of rock is coal? What are the types of rocks? Tell me some igneous minerals. Where is copper mined in India? Is Malajhkhand an open cast mine or underground mine? Where are the copper smelting units in India?

Member 3

1. Why is the monsoon delayed in Kerala? Have you heard about El Nino? What is it? Wouldn't that affect the monsoon?

2. You said about Kerala's biodiversity. What are the threats to marine biodiversity? Today is World Environment day - what is its theme? How can we substitute plastic?

3. Let's say we cut down forests in Kerala and do compensatory reforestation in Rajasthan? Do you think it's a good idea? Why not? You are cultivating spices there- so why not?

4. Since you come from that part of the world (Kerala), elephants go violent and kill people in temple festivals? What's your opinion on it?

Chair:

(Called me by name) Do you think people of Thrissur will allow 'Thrissur pooram' to happen without elephants? Do you go by their lead? Because we have banned them from circuses.. earlier they used animals there..

Ok.. Thank you.. you can go..

I thanked the chair and the rest of the members of the board and took my leave.

PS:

Most questions were lengthy and were accompanied with monologues. Sometimes I couldn't hear or didn't understand the demand of the question. I have just written the gist here.

Some of the questions I am not able to remember.

Felt like the interview got over too soon but I think I was in the room for at least 25 mins (by the clock outside).

Two candidates were absent and hence I was the fourth and last candidate to go.