UPSC interview, Preeti Sudan board, 17 May 2023 (PSIR, 2)
17 May 2023
Name- Girish
Date- 17th May (2nd in afternoon session)
Graduation- BTech Mechanical
Optional- PSIR
DAF- Non-fiction Books, Vipassana, Contract Bridge, Chess, Rubik Cube, Guinness World Records (nothing asked)
Work Ex. - Commodities Trader 2 yrs
Home State- Maharashtra
Entered the room - greeted all with smile. Sat on chair after ma'am asked to.
Chairperson (Preeti Sudan Mam) Girish, this is just a conversation. Be comfortable and ask again if you don't understand the question.
1. You've worked in Hyderabad, went from Beed&Pune. What cultural changes you saw ( okayish answer)
2. Have you ate Hyderabadi Biryani and had Irani chai?
3. Why Irani chai is called Irani chai? (Said don't know)
4. You've worked for 2 years as commodities trader. Why did you switch to civil services?
5. You're Student of PSIR. Tell me when will the Ukraine war stop?
6. Who is the real beneficiary of this war? (Said US and Arms industry)
7. Isn't China the beneficiary? (I said yes, but it's mixed for China - gave 2 benefits and 2 losses for China)
M1 (Little grilling but gave hints as well)
1. I will start with Commodities trading. Which commodities did you trade in?
2. Who regulates commodities trading? (SEBI)
3. Who else? (Said MoFinance and RBI have a say as well)
4. Who else? (Sorry, not able to recall)
5. Hint: Heard of GIFT city? (Then answered)
6. Heard of Harshad Mehta Scam? What was it? (Decent answer)
7. What fundamental changes brought after that? (Told 2 changes but he said he needed fundamental change)
8. He himself told - Demutualisation - explained the term and asked Do you think Demutualisation should be brought in News Media ownership? (Gave my opinion)
9. Which corporate owns largest stake in news media?
10. Tell me what principles are there for trans-boundary rivers internationally? (said don't remember exact principles)
11. You can guess. We have Indus, Brahmaputra etc. (Told 2 principles that I could there - he was satisfied but felt like he needed more)
12. Do we have waterways in India? (Told Waterways Act - 111 waterways / National waterways 1,2 - interrupted)
13. Okay, so tell me which stretch of Ganga has maximum commodity transport? (Didn't want to risk guessing - said don't know)
Preeti Sudan Ma'am - Thank you, Girish. Your interview is over. ( I was shocked 😁 - was thinking how to politely ask and tell - that other three members are remaining. M1 came to rescue and told Ma'am - Ma'am realised)
Sudan Ma'am - Sorry, Girish Sorry.
I said No Ma'am. I can understand (in polite manner to highlight that interviews have been going on since Feb)
Sudan Ma'am: Thank you for understanding Girish. (Then went on to explain to others that this happens when interviews are going on since Feb
M1: Even Girish is laughing inside. (Everyone laughed, I had light smile😁)
M2 (Just as he was about to start, I requested for a sip of water - he said yes yes)
1. How come you came to commodities trading from mechanical engineering? Isn't it domain of commerce?
2. Okay, So someone buys and someone sells at the same price - does it influence prices?
3. Where did you do the trades? (told Stellar software - M1 was nodding)
4. You said RBI also has a say - I say it doesn't. What role does it have in commodities trade regulation? ( I went blank - said sorry sir I had read but not able to recall)
5. Okay so, tell me what other regulators are there in financial services sector? (Couldn't get - so he gave hint like RBI is there for banks and NBFCs - then answered - M1 also nodded)
6. Any scam in last 3-4 months? (is it about Hindenburg report sir? > No it's not scam - anything related to NSE)
7. Yes, Yes NSE Co-location scam.. what was it? Why was MD guilty? What is Co-location? Is Co-location possible in commodity trading? (Answered all except last one)