UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 17 May 2023
17 May 2023
PD:
Name: PD
Date&session:15/5/23,afternoon last to go
Board:Smitha nagaraj madam
Optional: anthropology
College:....++
Graduation: MBBS
Hobbies relevant:
Annamacharya sankeerthans,
Dare to diagnose competition
CP:(~10min)
1.You have done your internship during covid 19?
2.Did you do any productive work or it got washed out due to covid 19?
3.What about second wave?
4.Ok,you have completed your internship by then and started monologue about covid management and asked what I have done personally and as a team?
5)We had lot of crunch of man power and lot of load of patients,Did you really convince and counsel them individually?
6)Now that you have mentioned about foreign medical graduates, and started monologue about quality in FMG and y still Indian students go there?
7)Which countries provide on par health education with India? Told Norway etc ..
8)Ok,changing the discussion.....
Monologue about doctor shortage,integration of AYUSH with allopathy and urban -rural divide in docs! Asked opinion about this...answered with American health model
9)America doesn't have health model.that is what I feel! What is your opinion.
10)Ok tell me what components are there that you want to bring into India?(mentioned insurance and payment to docs so that they ll work in rural setups)
11)So.you feel that payment is only the issue? Answered lot more challenges!
12) ok tell me ..you r from Kadapa district of AP, advise the govt ! How much you want for rural service? Answered 1.2L
13) Take 1.5L,do you still think docs ll go? Answered No. She laughed. Because I answered earlier that there are lot of challenges and mentioned about You quote we pay scheme of Uttarakhand and told we can't expect PG (specialised surgery eg: laparoscopy ) to go to rural setups and work because there is no infrastructure and loss of quality human capital!
14) I get your logic,but y shudnt they go? You are a doctor and you get a service tmrow, you will just sit and sign papers!
(It was a valid argument)
I tht I couldn't counter her..took break and told " Madam,This has opened a new dimension to my thought process!!
All members laughed!!
Finally, madam gave it to M1
M1:
Q1)PD, I can see you have dare to diagnose! What is it? And some questions ..very simple..
Q2) monologue on COVID management! Is it still followed?Tell me difference in management that happened in smaller towns vs cities
Q3)I am very fascinated by your hobby Annamacharya sankeerthans,tell me who is he? And which is your favourite sankeerthan?
Answered it ...simple one...
He told about his favourite sankeerthan!.... :)
M2: with mask and I didn't understand him.long monologue about something .
I heard only one word "insurance"
After his monologue got completed,I told him that I hadn't understood and asked him to repeat the Qn.
Madam asked him to remove mask and ask!!
1)I was asking about insurance sector,diagnostics ,Pharma having nexus with docs! How do you break it!!!
2) About Diploma in Medicine! Do you support it?if engineering has it,Y not medicine? And another question which was the same in a refined English language!
M3)
1.Do you think our laws are foolish in not curtailing BRANDED Generics?
2)Lets deviate from medicine!
He gave longest monologue on fiscal consolidation with technical words and bodies!
I haven't heard abt that body..
Told don't know..
Member: Ok ,no problem..
M4)
1)If you are not qualified in this attempt,what will you do?answered that I wud be a good doc at the end!
2)You have lost all the clinical experience and skill!! How will you be a good doctor?
3)Ok got it.Tell me why did you do medicine?
4)let's deviate to finance..
Tell me two major economic reforms in these 7-8 yrs
Answered ANBharat and Dig public Infra like UPI etc....He was expecting diff..
5) No ,I'm expecting diff!
Is there anything related to Tttaaaaxxxxxxx?
Answered GST
And then IBC...he was happy for that..
6)Tell me,you are posted in finance ministry or revenue service,What ll you do to increase direct taxes and indirect taxes?
7) Increasing DT ,wont it increase tax evasions?
Answered!
But at last,told sir I might be wrong,but with my limited knowledge these are the points that I can recollect R8 now!!
Smita madam nodded head....
Sign of get out!!
Utility of mocks or O2O:
Gave 7 mocks. Chahal ,Vajirao reddy were near to my original interview..
O2O with vivekananda sir,reflections ias personally helped me as sir is also doctor.
Kalyan sir,Hyd helped me to chisel out certain rough edges of my preparation.
Last : Peer discussion helped me a lot.Informally formal sessions with co interview aspirants was the best part of the preparation!
SOMP STUDENT TRANSCRIPT
👇👇👇👇👇👇
Date - May 16 2023
Chairperson -Honourable Preeti Sudan Ma'am
DAF keywords- Mechanical engineering, Female, Uttarakhand, Bundelkhand (Madhya Pradesh), Puducherry, Essay writing
Board was very sweet and cheerful
Chairperson - We are here to have a conversation. If you can't understand any question, do not hesitate to ask again. Remove your mask and be comfortable.
Chairperson: Tell us about your experience at HMCL
You yourself told that you were the only girl there and we have so less women in STEM, then why Civil Services
Oh so you're already selected...Tell us about Mahe
Why are the indicators there so developed
What was the Essay topic
Climate justice in Joshimath
M1:
3 fundamental changes in Mechanical
Additive manufacturing
EVs- are they green?
Unable to recall other questions
M2:
Ecology vs Development of Uttarakhand: How will you manage as an administrator?
UNFCCC
Rapid fire on UN Specialised agencies
UNSC REFORMS
Panchamrit target, you think we can achieve them?
Demographics disaster or demographic dividend
M3:
Financial nbfc- two wheelers vs four wheeler: Why four wheelers don't have it?
Difference between Manager vs Administrator
N Chandrasekhar a manager or administrator
AI application in administration
Areas in Uttarakhand where land is heavily protected
M4:
Additive manufacturing is democratisation?
Mechanical engineering is not Creative, what is your opinion?
If you're made a PM...Would you name your Ministry as MoForeign Affairs or Ministry of External Affairs
Special Marriage Act... what's so special about it?
How many marriage Acts are there?
Have you feel Repugnant by something in your life?
Chairperson - your interview is over.
Unable to recall all questions
Utility of Mocks/O2O: Helpful and confidence booster.
A very big thanks to Utkarsh Shukla Sir who guided the interview preparation in a streamlined manner.