Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 28 Apr 2023 (4)

28 Apr 2023

Name: Itachi

Date: 28.04.2023 (Morning session)

Board: Smita Nagaraj Ma’am

Key words: MBBS, rural service, IFS 1st preference.

Chairwoman:

1. So, you are a medico? How will you use your medical knowledge in foreign policy?

2. Have you heard about the recent protests by wrestlers? People are saying that it affects India’s “image”. What does it show? Why so concerned about Image?

3. What is the image that you would like to project of India as a diplomat? (mentioned Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, inclusive growth.. Taking everyone forward together.. Global south)

4. What should India’s role be wrt “global south”. Should we be “leaders” or “partners” or try to use the position to raise our own stature? (In course of answer mentioned that .. in areas where India has expertise can act as an “elder brother” to guide them ..) ... Member 1 immediately started scribbling something and passed on a piece of paper to Ma’am.. Which will be question No.6.

5. Do you think India is inherently good to other countries in diplomacy? Is India so unique in this respect? Is there no other country doing such good for other countries?

6. Some of Indian neighbours complain India of behaving more like an “Older brother”. Why has it been so?

7. Can you give some instances where India had taken any such steps which made other countries feel like we are behaving like “older brothers”?

8. Is it always some other countries’ fault or sometimes it's India’s fault as well in diplomacy?

9. What do you think we can do to better wrt our neighbours in our foreign policy?

Member 1:

- Monologue on NEP and teacher empowerment. What can we do to empower the teachers?

- Do you think increasing salary can be a way of empowering teachers? (in course had mentioned.. Teaching is a “noble profession” and its empowerment should not be narrowed down to just financial remuneration...)

- Is there any profession which is not noble?

- So, you are basically agreeing that almost all professions are noble? Now, tell me why civil services is NOT a noble profession?

- Whether it is noble or not depends more on the person or the profession?

- Have you heard about Ig-Noble prizes?

Member 2:

- You were talking about a noble profession and salary. Although medical is a very noble profession and you despite working in the rural sector, I see in your DAF that your salary was low. Don’t you think its an insult to a doctor?

- Don’t you think underpaying doctors in rural sector is an issue?

- Can the diplomats contribute to economic transactions and trade between countries?

- Don’t you think private corporates like Tata already have all such data and information. Why the need for govt. Or diplomats to give such data?

Member 3:

- Recently, there was agitation by some doctors. You aware about it?

- What was the name of the bill?

- Do you think it was right for the doctors to hold such strike?

- What were the issues with the Bill?

- Do you think there is a doctor pharma nexus which works in such a manner that actual treatment of diseases like Diabetes, HTN are not focused upon and instead they work for temporary relief?

- Recently, a high ranking US personnel visited Taiwan. Can you give me the name of the person? Why is China so worried about that visit?

- What is India’s relation with Taiwan? Do we have trade ties with it?

Member 4:

- What has been India’s stand wrt Non Proliferation Treaty?

- Is that stand based on some principle or there are some other reasons for it?

- You aware about the nuclear deal between India and the USA? Does it have an advantage for India or we stand to lose something in its return?

- If USA someday decides to withdraw from the deal, don’t you think we stand to lose a lot about investing so much into building those nuclear plants?

- Why has the export of Indian Tea been reducing? Have we done enough to promote tea or organic tea as a whole.

- Do you know about Gandhi’s social Sins?

- Tell us about SDGs? What are those? Who makes those? Whats the objective?

- Can the Judiciary amend the Constitution?

Chairwoman: Your interview is over. Thank you.

Experience: more like a conversation.. building on whatever words were used in previous answers. Cordial environment. Around 30 minutes

Utility of mocks: Helps build confidence.