UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 13 May 2023 (Jharkhand)
13 May 2023
Name - Ritwik Mehta
Date - 11/05/23 (Afternoon) 3rd to go
Board- Smita Nagraj Ma’am
Optional- Geography
College- Kirori Mal College, DU [BA Hons Geography]
Profession (if any) - Not mentioned in DAF
Hobbies - Nothing asked (Blogging, Cricket, English comedy movies)
Achievement - Remote Sensing essay (among others) - 1 question
Interview started at 3.05. Entered and wished good afternoon. Ma’am asked me to take a seat and asked me whether I had joined police services somewhere? I said “No ma’am” and she laughed and said - “I’m asking because you were standing in attention with your thumbs pointing down.” I said - “No ma’am, again” and laughed. I thought that the interview would be like a conversation from here but boy was I wrong!
Smita Nagraj Ma'am:
1. What is Subaltern History? [Me, a geography student] - I was smiling but was very concerned that she has read my Optional wrong. But since I knew it well, I replied.
2. So, you come from Jharkhand. Now, if we have to present a subaltern view of what the local inhabitants of Jharkhand, the tribals experience in today’s world. What would such an account be? [Me - :O] - Started by saying there is some improvement - but she cut me short and said -
3. No. Forget that. Not our view of development. Their perspective on what has happened? [By this time, I had got time to think so I answered this pretty well pointing out challenges in their lived experience but ending on a hopeful note that even tribals groups would appreciate the benefits of political representation, FRA and development after centuries of exploitation. Also, I added a few “geographical hooks”, aiming to take the conversation away from this. Thankfully ma’am took this.]
4. Ok. I noticed you mentioned Trickle down. So tell me is this theory and what are the limitations to it. Also, what are the issues with collection of kendu leaves? [Explained trickle down and added more geographical pointers with concepts like Growth Pole, Myrdal etc. She stopped me after a point and said -]
5. But do you really think trickle down is still an viable developmental model seeing how it has been challenged? [Responded with balanced view that while we have to also shift to bottom up, participatory models of growth - trickle down still makes economic sense - couldve added some discussion from Economic Surveys on this but didnt reach there]
6. Ok so back to my question. Kendu leave collection issues? [Didnt really know the issues with collection but gave a few points of marketing infra missing, over reliance on forest department and middle men. I was not satisfied with this answer but I really couldnt think more at that point.]
She said Ok. Thats it from me. [Said thank you ma’am.] So far so good. The whole subaltern thing came a bit out of the blue but I was feeling good. After this, it was pure carnage. It seemed like Chaube sir’s board had transported into the room.
M1 [sitting directly to my right - was a bit grumpy and in grilling mode. Visibly bored]
1. What is parallel cinema? [Sorry sir, dont know] - Couldve asked for taking a guess but decided against it.
2. What is meaningful cinema? [Sorry sir, dont know]
3. Dont you have any interest in cinema? [Yes sir I do but I havent heard these terms before.]
4. What is the difference between storm, cyclone, and hurricane? [Me again confused because storm is a generic term and the only difference is of intensity with respect to cyclone. While cyclone and hurricane are different only in nomenclature. However I gave this same reply but it became long winded and resulted in some back and forth :(]
5. How are cyclones named? [Answered]
6. Earlier, cyclones had feminine names. Why? [Said dont know but asked for a guess. And here is where everything can get potentially dangerous for me. I guessed that maybe some misogynistic view of destruction being associated with women could be to blame. And as I said this, I saw M4 looking to the Chiarperson with a large smile. This threw me off completely and I thought I messed up.]
7. But, even if you look at Greek mythology, women have been associated with creation and life? [Took this opportunity to clarify that yes sir I am unaware and maybe my guess is completely wrong. I will have to learn more on this. Thank you.]
8. What is NCPCR? [Answered]
9. What do you understand by child rights? [Answered generically]
10. What is the law for protecting children from sexual offences? [Answered but fumbled with the POCSO Act]
11. What is right to defamation and right to damages? [I knew defamation, I knew right to damages but “right to defamation” stumped me. I didnt have the courage to say that sir I dont think there is any “right” to defamation so I simply said I dont know and left it at that.]
By this point, I’ve said I dont know thrice and potentially messed up on a question. So when he pointed to the next panel member, I couldnt say Thank You and turn away fast enough. :P
M2 [sitting to my left - seemed like someone with Defence, IR specialization. Neutral demeanour - calmer than M1]
1. What are the technologies needed in Remote Sensing? [Answered]
2. What is weapons diplomacy? [I asked to take a guess and answered this well enough. Included India’s approach in neighbourhood and US Washington Declaration.]
3. Ok so we hear about North Korea conducting these large tests. Even recently it did one. So how does it get the technology and funding for it? [Me = :O - How am I supposed to know North Korean funding. But i responded with internal economy + potentially gets help from China, Russia. Could’ve included some aspect on proliferation from Pakistan, weapons trade etc but didnt remember in the moment.]
4. Is North Korea really a threat if it has these weapons? [Responded with it not being a responsible state actor, sparking arms race etc.]
5. What is the National Security Council’s composition? [Didnt remember the composition so I only said it is headed by NSA and outlined its functions.]
6. What are three factors of rural development? [Answered]
He said thats it from me and passed on to M3.
M3 [sitting to the Chairperson’s right - neutral demeanour but random questions]
1. India’s rank is 132nd on HDI. What is HDI and how do we improve it? [This had so much content potential that I had to stop myself from speaking after a point as he seemed bored.]
2. Has NEP been able to target these interventions you talked about in improving education? [Gave a generic response]
3. What are Intellectual Property Rights? [Answered]
4. Ok so Russia Ukraine was has been going on. Now India has abstained from voting against Russia. So can you tell the historical basis for India’s abstentions? [I started giving reasons about strategic autonomy and India’s view that this is Europe’s war]
5. He heard some and then said yes but what is the historical basis for not voting agains Russia. [I apologized and replied with historical ties, Russia standing up for India in UNSC and defence and diplomatic support etc.]
6. President Zelensky has given a 10 point peace plan. Do you feel this can end the conflict? [Said I dont know what this plan is.]
7. Ok China has also given a plan. Can that bring peace? [Dont know China’s solution either -_-]
8. Can India help in bringing peace? [Answered this well.]
9. What is the state of forest in India as per the latest report? [Answered well with data]
10. Which states are underperforming? [Said dont know exactly which states :( ]
11. What is Intanglible Cultural Heritage? [Answered]
12. Is there any ICH from Jharkhand? [Thanked Vision ka prelims mocks of the past 4 years lol - said Chhau dance and relaxed a bit]
He passed on to M4 and I was glad this was over. I looked to M4 who was smiling and I realized that I too have to smile xD. So that happened.
M4 [sitting to the Chairperson’s left - pleasant and cordial.]
1. Continuing from ISFR, who prepares this report? [Answered]
2. What technologies are used? [thankfully remembered the satellite used and added generic terms like sensors, GPS, ground truthing data etc]
3. So we started our Nuclear program years ago and yet - Ok tell me what is the status of Nuclear in India? [That morning, Indian Express editorial had the number - 6780 MW which has stuck with me. I said this figure and he smiled and said stop stop you know. So, continuing - ]
4. So what are the challenges? Why are we not able to expand nuclear? [Answered with raw materials, civil nuclear liability issues, environmental concerns etc.]
5. What is the performance of Ayushman Bharat? What challenges is it facing? [Really couldnt remember a lot. Said onboarding of hospitals as an issue but beyond that I havent looked into performance]
He said thats it from me. I looked over at the Chairperson and she said - “Ok that is it, Thank you.” Thanked them and came out.
Total time - 28 mins approx.
Overall experience - Cant say as the interview was not really as conversational or cordial as I had been expecting. Almost nothing came from the prepared list of hundreds of questions I went with except maybe ISFR, Nuclear, Rural Development and Remote Sensing. Nothing repeated from mocks other than one different question on Nuclear. Initially I felt it was terrible but as time is passing, I feel it was more or less fine. Not very different from what I was doing in mocks. Also, the 2 members sitting directly to your right and left makes it very awkward and eye contact is very unnatural xD
PS - Just kidding but whoever had put parallel cinema as their hobby did me a great disservice lol. Next time se sab log apne hobbies PT verified group pe daal dena taki baki log bhi prepare kar le ye sb -_-. Mera cricket pe kiya hua 4 month PhD, useless ho gya.
Utility of mocks or O2O (if any) - Took around 10-12 mocks as this was my first interview and I had too much time. However, apart from the ability to withstand the urge to make multiple guesses, I dont think there was any tangible bearing on the final interview. But this couldve been very different had questions in the interview been different. O2O with Khan sir was the highlight for me but apart from this, NACS, Chahal, Vajiram, Raus, and Vajiro were good.