UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 4 May 2023 (Maharashtra…)
4 May 2023
Name- Silver
Board- Soni sir, date- 4th May, forenoon, 2nd to go
Education- 12th from Fergusson College, Pune; Geography Honours, DU; MA and JRF Geography, Delhi School of Economics
Optional- Geography
Hobby- Aquascaping and Backpacking
District- Amravati, Maharashtra
Interview almost entirely from the DAF. Was really scared of getting Soni sir’s board and eventually that is where I ended up. Can’t analyse how the interview went, everyone’s face was poker, a few members grilled. Chairman scolded me over mismatch of face and photo since I had shaved. Interview started on a very depressing note. I kept smiling and confident for the rest of the interview, nonetheless.
Chairman sir-
1. What does your name mean? (It means Silver) Follow ups- What are some uses of silver? Where is it found in India? Is it found naturally?
2. Do you watch television? If you find any immoral or objectionable content on TV, where will you report?
3. Which Geographic characteristics of India help it in economic growth? (Apart from the location, monsoon, resources, I also mentioned about population as an asset), light grilling on this part. Is population an asset or an obstacle? (I mentioned skilling, demographic dividend and China’s success story)
Member 1-
4. You have unique hobbies. What does aquascaping mean? (Landscaping inside an aquarium to make it resemble an actual biotope) Do you practice it commercially? How many aquariums do you have?
5. Which landscapes have you created in these aquariums? I said East Asian (Mekong), South American (Amazon) and African (Lake Malawi)
6. Do you also keep Piranhas? Why not? What are the issues? Where do you get these exotic fish in India?
7. About this Mekong, where does it begin and end?
8. Your other hobby- Backpacking. What is it, where did you travel last? (Badrinath-Valley of Flowers and most recent stay-cation at Manali).
9. Let’s talk about Manali. Where did you stay, where did you sightsee? (Stayed in a hostel for 15 days and studied, only went for treks, no sightseeing). Where are these treks? Temperature there? Snow? (I was there for the first half of march)
10. Which river in Manali? Its geographic characteristics? Which other river? (Beas and Manalsu)
11. Who was Vyas? (I said maharshi Vyas, the author of Mahabharata) Something else about Vyas? Philosophy? I said sorry.
Member 2-
12. You belong to Amravati. Which part of Mahrashtra is it in? (Vidarbha). Which part covers Marathwada?
13. What is with the separate state demand for Vidarbha? (Reasons- Disparity, underresresentation, etc) (I said it has phased out due to increased attention and development in Vidarbha)
14. Is Nagpur comparable with Pune, development wise? When will it be comparable?
15. Which are the resources in Vidarbha? What is MahaGenCo? Which are the thermal power plants around Nagpur? How far are these? Do they lead to pollution? What should we do? (Koradi and Khaparkheda, earlier much outside Nagpur’s borders, now Nagpur has grown. We shouldn’t shun these industries instantly but aim for CCS and gradual shift to renewables).
Member 3-
16. Let’s talk about Amravati. Has Amravati given any President to the country? (I heard precedent and gave some other answer, she corrected me).
17. Which big industrial projects will help Amravati. Asked about a railway project.
18. Why does Taiwan have claims on South China sea even though it is far from there? (I mentioned UNCLOS and EEZ and right to exploration)
19. China and Taiwan have issues. Who claims what? She added, Taiwan claims that China belongs to Taiwan and that’s why it claims South China sea.
20. You are a Project Executive of water supply scheme in a block. There severe shortage of funds due to non-payment of dues by the people. Scheme is difficult to be managed without finances. What will you do? (I focussed on cpntinuity in water supply apart from recovering the dues legally. Getting finances through other legal channels. (She was expecting a focus on community participatory approach in convincing the defaulters).
Member 4-
21. You are from Fergusson. Did you see these NDA aspirants? (Had no clue)
22. Who is Barack Obama? Why famous? (First African-American President of the USA.) Which African country did he belong to?
23. There is some other Barak in India. A river. Where? (Mistakenly said it originates in Assam, he grilled over it on how can a geography specialist get this wrong). What is its specialty? (Most species of fish in a single river-2000. Didn’t know.)
24. There are river dolphins. Where are they found in India?
25. Difference between Gangetic Dolphin and Indus Dolphin? Where is Indus Dolphin found in India? (Beyond Harike in Beas, extinct in India).
26. You are newly posted as an SDM in a town. The local MLA invites you over tea as a courtesy call. Will you go or will you ask him to come to you? (I said I won’t go and I.ll politely say I would ask him to meet when the formal occasion so demands). He said politicians may hold grudge against you and not cooperate in future. I said I’ll not go at loggerheads with him but gently inform him that we’ll meet when the occasion so demands.
27. Should compulsory military service for youth be followed in India? (I said we have a large population unlike countries such as Israel where this is done. We can make military like training in schools mandatory to imbibe discipline, but not force people to serve the military).
Chairman sir- We are done, you may go.
Spent the next 2 hours proving to the officials of UPSC that I am the person in the photo.
Recommendations on mocks- will give it if I get good enough marks to back that recommendation up.