UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 24 Apr 2023 (PSIR)
24 Apr 2023
Date -24th april 2023
Board -Sony sir
Name - dr strange
Back ground - MBBS -indore , Ms (general surgery ) Safdarjung hospital delhi
Work experience-worked as senior resident at many institutions( govt +private )
Hobby - shayari , photography
Daf - Indore, delhi,Lucknow madhyapradesh ,Bihar
Interview-Totally based on health
No IR,no C.A. No economy
Entered the room - round table ,much distance between chairman and candidate,
2members very near to candidate
Chairman-
You can remove mask ,
(Watching very care fully the procedure to remove the mask .)
Would you like to Introduce your self as shayar who became doctor or doctor who became shayar
(Don’t heard the question properly ,said both after some time ) he said you dint understand the nuance of the question ( sunayi dega tab to sochunga sir )
Same repeat questions -
1.Why leaving medical field
2.Wasted money, someone could have done better in medical field
3.Do you read books also -I said yes sir .
Did you read the book everyone loves drought . ( low pitch voice , was not able to hear clearly) but mind worked b/c of high sympathetic stimulus)
Later some how I understood , I have heard that line 4. who is the writer - I am unable to recall
Q.-What does it mean -more chances of corruption ..bank gets more money , politicians get more money etc
Q. What are the features of drought , how do you know it’s drought - slow process , level of water body , decreases etc
Q.Have you ever seen the drought - no sir
Q.Doctor pt ratio -1:1456
Q. Ideal ration as per Un then corrected himself as per WHO
- 1:1000 ok then it’s low
Yes sir but govt said in parliament that it’s now 1:856
Chairman - but now it’s lacking ( assertive voice)
Me - nodded yes .(jo aap bolo Wo sahi hai Aaj to ) but govt ne to yahi data diya hai recent )
M1- only 2 questions
Q.What is life style diseases -gave definition , eg .sedentary life style causes increase fat which caused DM and HTn
( he was also too fat ,got offended ,I think -no body shaming ,just medically obese )
Q . Jhallahat Bhari aawaj main -
How fat causes DM and HTn ,explained-looked satisfied ,no questions after that
M-2
long monologue there is no health policy at present we don’t monitor the infection and out break , for someone doing pollution or infecting the water body that causes the spread of disease how will you make health policy for that
-I said there is already a system ,we have integrated disease surveillance programs that already monitor that emerging disease (1st I thought he is talking about , point source infection but he was asking something else ) then I said
one health policy and explained one health concept but he had no clue about that .
Expressionless face .
Then he gave example of disease out break how an Ias taken care diarrhoea outbreak in Gujarat(
Q.do you know that
No sir , but I know the way how to control it .
Mapping of the area,identify point source , pt detection ,early diagnosis and treatment , not much satisfied
Q. What is ethnomedicine?
Gave my concept of ethnic medicine then asked clarification what does he mean by it ?
It’s tribal and traditional medicine ,it’s said to cure cancer ?! What do you think about it ?
I said there is no randomised control trial at present but there are claim that it prevents and cure cancer ,
M-3.
Q.Country transitioning from infectious to NCD .
What diseases India facing the , how will you make policy for that .
Told the triple burden of disease India facing with data , told about my policy based on preventive and primitive health gave eg of Health and wellnEss Center
Q Southern Indian satiate performing the best in health indicator .
Should we have two health policy in India , one for north and one for south ( trap question)
Said no , should learn from South Indian states and implement it in north India .
Q. Right to health bill which state brought , is it right ? Your view , why protest , is it right step .
How to cut expension of health
Very satisfied with answers
M4
Q asked Some famous photography book - sorry sir
Q. Health expenditure very high, if we heard that someone staying In hospital for one month then we don’t believe , how to decrease health expenditure ( I already answered in previous questions, non attentive panel member )
Someone come to you after orthopaedics implant, after one year, many remove it many left it as it is , what will you do
( they would read DAF carefully,I am a general surgeon and not a orthopaedic surgeon )
I said would decide on case by case basis .
It get fibrosed usually
Q.some people said proper continuous use of water can cure all disease then corrected himself ,ionised water can cure all disease ,even cancers with help of ionised oxygen
I said I am not aware of that
Q.Do you know Tamil
I said no sir ,
Q. which language you know I said Hindi,English , he said English is not a language and smiled ,(l thought to remind him official languages of country but got the gist he wanted to say that everyone know the English it’s that common )
I said I also know the dialect like bhojpuri, Nimadi, Magahi .
Q .again but you don’t know Tamil !(bhai main South Indian nahi hu ,bas naam hai South Indian )( Soni sir laughed at this point😂 , I controlled 😊thought bhai Kaha se aate hai ye log )
Q. how would you work if you are posted in hospital in Tamil Nadu , I said many go there after UG and learn the language within 4-5 months , I would take the help of colleagues in understanding the the language and learn the language .
I the last Soni sir said something ..again very low pitch voice ,like your interview is over, enjoy your day —was not able to hear it properly,
said thank you sir to all , have a good evening .
Experience - 2panel members were attentive , two were just finishing there job , chairmen was assessing. Or searching something on tablet all the time
Utility of mock -
Helped a lot in articulation ,structuring , and countering the fear of interview ,went fearless ,baki to number batayenge )
Transcript:
Board: Preeti Sudan Ma’am
After noon Session
DAF: Kerala, Software Engineer, IRTS, IPS, Malayalam literature
Chair: So ur name is pronounced as ?(said without h)
I said mam it is...
So, tell me u r from science background, but has chosen literature y
Said, CS not an optional, literature being my favourite and felt it would be scoring
U worked in IT, then railways, then IPS, tell me what difference you found in IT and railways
I said, motive (profit vs service) , professionalism, team work vs hierarchy, resistance to change vs innovation( felt shouldn’t have said this as my answer showed railway work culture in poor light 😅)
So ur cadre is out.. said yes, Odisha
So if u get North East in IAS, will you go? Said yes, then asked Y?
I said willing to work in all cadres, service more important than where for me
How is the routine of NPA?
Passéd to M1:
1) so u r from Kerala, tell me about the history of Kerala before independence
Started with the administrative divisions, M1: since Kerala is very elongated u can tell me from where to where for these divisions: I explained about travancore, Kochi , malabar
Difference in Southern and Northern culture:
Here I talked about Mappilas
And next question : when did Muslims arrive in Kerala
Is there a difference in number of migrants in Southern and Northern Kerala. I talked about Diff in destination, pattern
So how is remittance positive to Kerala?
So does it have impact on real estate?
So when Covid happened what was the change? Talked about reverse migration and rehabilitation schemes
So are these expatriates in Kerala or went back? Talked about job losses due to conflict
M2: So u r in NPA, do u like the training?
Are u an indoor or outdoor person?
After u joined NpA, any personalities from police visited NPA?
Who is present director?
So, if u were posted in Up and u had the responsibility of taking Atiq to hospital, how would you handle?
There was already a threat perception, he even filed a case, so how would you?
If u were there how will u respond in that situation?
So won’t u save the person who is dying? Even if he is a criminal, he is a man. I said , definitely sir, but first needs to take charge of situation for that?
How many rounds did Police fire at the assailants?
He then said, it was zero? What did they do? They caught them only when they surrendered, do u think that was the right way?
Why didn’t police take him in jeep till hospital?
M3: So tell me what preventive policing methods will u take in ur district?
Recently even courts coming under attacks, how will u tackle this situation?
What about the sections that are subjected to crime?
U r focusing on criminals, how protect the victims?
How to make more people approach Police?
Did u read today’s newspaper? Naroda Masscare case?
Tell me the details of the case?
M4: again, why took literature optional?
Name 3 people who contributed to Malayalam literature
Who got Jnanpith? I asked sir, it is about first time?
Talked about G Sankara kurup? Question on which work?
On what themes does he write?
Have u heard of police revolting at times? Examples? Didn’t know this
Tell about police reforms? Vague and open ended question
What is the limitation of AI? I said we should instead ask to what extent it can grow? Bcoz of recent discussions of AI and sentience
And then talked about current limitations
Chair: interview is over, all the best
Overall: the entire board kept poker face so no idea 😅
Utility of mocks: to know our own strengths and weaknesses,and for confidence building
Took KSG, NextIAS, Fortune IAS(Trivandrum). All three were good.
One on one discussion with Vinay Sir(Insights) helped a lot.
Date and session of interview- 21st April forenoon
Board- chaubey sir
Optional- psir
1st to go
Chair:
1. Tell education and work experience
2.Difference between radioactivity and nuclear fission (follow ups)
M1:
1.My opinion on PM's statement that Buddhist teachings can prevent climate change
2. Opinion on Macaulay education system
M2:
1. India Bhutan relations wrt china
2. Chicken neck
3. Views on Chinese border infra development
4. Inter state border issues
M3:
1. Something from companies act (didn't know)
2. Recent space related event (spacex)
M4 (woman):
1. Preventive vs curative care which is more important. What are we doing about it?
2. Main goal of education
3. How to do Character building
4. Why Indians don't follow laws
Chair: anything you want to say
Your experience in interview- cordial, almost nil cross questions. Short duration
Utility of mocks or O2O (if any)- good for getting into interview mode
Vajirao and Reddy(best), ias baba, vajiram, unacademy, forum, vision faculty mock
#Sharing_is_Caring
#sab_honge_kaamyaab
Date and time: 21th April (afternoon session)
Board: Gen Raj Shukla sir
Optional: PSIR
DAF keywords: Haryana,Uttrakhand,army,computer science
Chairman sir: Since you studied psir
Q1.in which direction current world order going on
(Talked about kindleberger trap)
Sir Interrupted aksed about
Thucydyes trap?
Then briefed about 12Nmiles and Usa violation
Asked about it.
M1
Recent happening in uttrakhand
Joshimath why and future.
Demographic dividend (quantity and quality debate)
Chat gpt use in public administration
M2
Why master in polity despite btech(cse) in graduation
Which subjects did you studied there
Marxism why didnot succeed
Counter question on
Lenin
Difference between leninsim and marxim
Why basketball not so popular in india
Usa player being heighted more will india be able to compete them
M4(lady)
Capitalism over Socialism
Can gdp alone can't be measure of welfare
M5
2 news about your home district
Comparison between ms dhoni and sehwag(why he was chosen the captain)
Army as aggressor
Experience: Very cordial board, no cross questioning as such but rather a buildup based on my answers. Little bit grilling by honble chairman sir
Utility of mocks: totally different than mocks
I didn't had good experience with mock