Interviews

UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 20 Apr 2023 (3)

20 Apr 2023

Date- 20 April, Morning Session

Lt. Gen Raj Shukla Sir’s Board

DAF keywords relevant- Chess

Education, work experience, optional- Medical Science(Maharashtra)

Irrelevant DAF keywords-Coffee, Photography, NCC

Chairperson-

DAF reading for members

• You play Chess. So tell me is life a game of decency or game of chess? Followup are opponents inanimate?

• Between individuality, competition and collaboration what will you choose?

• What do you think is the difference between self reliance and self sufficiency? Can we achieve that in Chips?

• Do you know how many borders that chip has to cross in production? From Sand to final product, will need multiple agreements, develop emerging technologies so it is difficult for India to achieve dont you think?

• What is supply chain state craft?

• Has 5G arrived in India?.Do you think it is linear growth or exponential growth over 4G? Any other benefits than these two? Why was there concern regarding huawei supplying hardware?Can we mix match hardware and software, huawei ericsson?

M1( keenly observed throughout )

• Long monologue on health and education but India still has challenges, performs poorly. What is your opinion?

• Picked IIT from answer, Difference between IIT and ITI both provide technical education. First tell me what is ITI?

• As you’ve been trained in Medicine, do you think society is losing on valuable resources invested in you? What if you don’t get to work in health sector?

• What do you think about compulsory rural service. Tell me pros and cons.

M2(seemed not interested)

• As you’ve worked in public hospitals how will you improve their conditions?

• Should govt hospitals employ managers like private, do they have?

• What is Mohalla clinic, many say not successful, what do you think?But don’t you think decentralisation of health care will increase corruption?

M3(smiling, comforting ma’am)

• Your internship got over during COVID, Maharastra(home state) faced problems in 1st wave. Then shifted to 2nd wave was more deadly why do you it happened how was preparedness? How would you have used your medical knowledge to tackle it?

• Population news surpassing china, your view?How should be the population policy, coercive like China?

• Recently MH had incident where deaths happened. Maam is it heat wave related deaths in an event? Yes so do you think we only focused on COVID but are not treating other problems appropriately. How should we have managed it better?

M4(probing further, didnt let me talk more than 1-2 lines)

• Do you think Corruption is the largest problem for India? Have you faced forceful corruption?

• You are good in academics, medicine; why civil services?

• I got that from earlier answer. But this exam is uncertain what will you do if it doesn’t go your way?

• But medical service is also good. As you must be knowing the prestige, status it provides. What do you think?

• Okay tell me between power, money, philanthropy what will you choose?

CP- just nodded to indicate it has finished.

What helped?

1. Self reflection, honesty

2. discussion and practice with peers

3. Highly recommended One to one sessions with- Utkarsh Sir SOMP, Vikas Kanukollu sir, Dr. Khan sir, bureaucrats in service.

4. Mocks recommended- Nextias, Samkalp, Onlyias, Vajirao

Wishing everyone all the best!