Interviews

UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 20 Apr 2023

20 Apr 2023

Board- Shukla Sir

Name - Pooja

Graduation in Physics Hons, Jaipur (Raj), RTE awareness campaign,spoken word poetry, sociology (optional)

Chairperson - Remove mask..(verified photo, mam asked me to remove it fully as I was having cough and sore throat, I decided to keep it on)

Q- What's special abt Jaipur - only History ?

A - historicity, cultural legacy, jpr is Rajasthan in miniature and also mentioned Jpr foot which is a revolutionary kind of thing in field of prosthetics

Q- Long monologue on Rajputana tradition of Rajasthan..is it contradictory to modernity?

A- Some traditions like Sati, child marriage are contradictory but some parts of culture like folk dances and all are important in encouraging tourism which is imp in modern times

Q - Sir asked What lessons can we draw from it or relevant today?

A- 1. Fight for country (gave ex-many army commanders are from Rajasthan)

2. Also to speak against injustice and ask for what we deserve to know (gave ex- RTI movement which started in Rajasthan only)

Q - Should we revisit history? (Long monologue)

A- I said yes as new facts, new interpretation then sir asked abt political and ideological biasness and controversies..my stand was just to have stakeholder consultation and discussion with diff scholars, experts with different ideologies so that new results won't have any biasness

M1 (Mam was extremely sweet and cordial)

Q- being a Physics student, why socio any specific reasons?

A - 3 reasons - 1. Availability and accessibility of material as I was preparing by myself (mam asked no coaching, I said no mam)

2. Always interested in knowing nitty- gritties of society so socio enabled me to delve deeper

3. Application in administration

Q- As DM, your approach for women empowerment?

A- will work for women led empowerment and development, will see it as multidimensional problem.. On economic aspect, capitalise SHG..on political, mahila Sarpanch sashaktikaran (mentioned I can arrange regular meetings with blo and give them strict instructions to report whenever a man sees as functioning instead of women)..Also I mentioned abt women led energy Transition (gave a case study of dungarpur district)

Q - Why only jpr is famous when it comes to tourism and not other places in Rajasthan?

A- normal reasons like- it's recognizability as capital, economic contribution bt we are promoting other places also?

Q- what are those places nd how we are promoting?

A- Explained Ranakpur rural tourism case study (a remote village in Pali) experiential tourism, tribal festivals,etc

M2

Q- Asked abt German Sociologists and their contribution

A- Weber, Durkheim (said more..I said Marx, sir asked before that, I replied Hegel)

Q- Hegel's dialectics? (Explained)

Q- Marx vs Hegel..have a quote and asked to explain

Q- Marx's thesis and antithesis (I got confused and said sorry..sir told me to make an attempt..I explained..(thankfully it was correct😅)

Q- What is this type of poetry you have written (spoken word it was😂) and what's inspiration, why you do this only?

M3

1. Implementational challenges in RTE and what changes can be done?

A- 1. Dysfunctional school management committees and they can be reformed by making volunteer cadre of youth who will educate parents

2. Certain departmental instructions aren't available in Public domain so parents are unaware abt them..(here I explained my own experience what I observed)

3. Explained how cbse schls in Tamil Nadu are denying admission to students due to difference in academic calenders so will make it mandatory for all to implement RTE act

Q- What powers should be given to Panchayats?

A- mentioned abt autonomy, funds and functionaries, etc

Sir said- it's theoretical..just give me some practical solutions..how can we increase power and performance of Panchayat?

A- under ABP, we should make panchayats as sole leader to implement different schemes, start their own initiatives..gave ex- How Panchayat s in South India are doing good in implementing Pink toilets initiative (explained mechanism)

Q- what if Panchayats are supposed to pay salaries of govt schl teachers?

A- explained benefits- decrease teacher absenteeism, community involvement in teaching

(mentioned Lok Jumbish Project of Rajasthan)

Q- Who'll oppose this and why?

A- Teachers as they'll be at the mercy of Panchayats and if any conflict occured then their salaries can be cut so first it should be start with a pilot project and then we can scale it by analysing outcomes and stakeholder consultation

M4

1. Who can take good decision as district collector- Science student or Non science student as you have been both(sir was smiling )

A- sir depends on situation

Sir again stressed me to choose one smilingly, my stand was- sir I can't comment as it depends on situation, resources and assessment of options😁

(Mam and sir both started laughing)

Q- what are qualities of a civil servant? (Gave gs4 answer😅)

CP - All the best..you may go now

Experience- board was cordial,Shukla sir was neutral in expressions, other members were expressive..overall a feeling of satisfaction

Lasted for 20 min while for others, it was 30 minutes

Gave 10 panel mocks(unacademy, byjus, study iq,next ias, drishti) and o2o with Ravindran sir..all were good helped in preparing ques bank

Thanks to the community for sharing transcripts :))

All the Best..Hope to see you in Lbsnaa😇