UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 13 Feb 2019 (2)
13 Feb 2019
Interview-
Name: Rakesh Sharma-
Attempt- 1st
Pannel-
Time: Forenoon session - first slot
Education: B.A.Prog Kirori Mal college (DU,) Masters in Social Work Delhi school of Social Work (DU)
Work experience working as educational coordinator at Sambhav institution (NGO) 1year 8months
Hobbies: chess and swimming
State: Haryana
Chairperson –reading the details from my DAF-
1 you are working as educational coordinator- which kind of responsibilities you are assigned?
A. Ma’am my responsibilities are career counseling, computer literacy and life skill education.
2 okay, so what kind of students are there in your NGO ? ma’am some students are studying in school 10th and 12th class and some are studying at college level.
3 you also play chess. - have you ever played at some state or national level? Got some medals?
A. yes ma’am- I used to play at state level during my school time and got 7th place in one of the tournament but could not play much at college level so my ranking degraded.
Chair person ma’am Passed the baton to the 1st member
Member 1-
1 you have presented a paper on ‘civil society’s contribution in good governance. Which kind of role civil society plays in good governance?
A explained- RTI, MGNREGA, sexual harassment against women Act were brought with the pressure of civil society. So it plays a vital role.
2 if our government is doing so much for welfare. Why should we involve civil society in governance?
A they have grass root expertise.
B some people in NGO are from the community itself – so can better understand the needs of the community
C some areas are remote where government services either have not reached or lacking.
D NGO also provide funds for the development-
3 many NGOs are working in the same sector- like health, sanitation how to improve coordination?
A sir NGO need to demarcate their area of interest.
B government can also fund based on the need analysis- provide funds in those sectors where less NGOs are working.
4 some NGOs are not doing good work. Measures?
A sir there should be an overarching body which can regulate NGOs,
5 any recent initiatives for that?
A recently NITI Aayog opened Darpan portal where all NGOs have to get registere
6 what about CAPART?
A sir it is an umbrella body consisting of many NGO- I bluffed.
Member 2-
1 you participated in Tihar residential camp. What kind of work you were assigned?
A sir we lived and talked to the inmates. We had to identify some problems and also suggest some solutions.
2 what kind of problems you found there?
A many inmates were facing depression- counseling facilities were not adequate.
2 legal help was not available.
3 what kind of criminals you met. Have they been convicted?
A. Sir most of them were under trials.
4 what they were saying. We have done some crimes or we are arrested by the police without any crime?
A. Sir they were sharing about their crime details. And they also said that we have committed some crimes but at least we also deserve some rights therefore we should be provided with legal help and other facilities that are needed.
5 In UK some persons have take shelter as fugitives. They are saying that our jails are not humane so we may face torture. What do you think about Indian jails.
A. Sir as per my experience at Tihar jail- it is a model jail and there are various facilities like library, theatre, factories for skill building.
6 what are your service preferences?
A Indian administrative services
B income tax accounts-
7 you are posted as DM- what would be your priorities?
A sir would visit the district and talk to the people-
B would make a SWOC analysis- - strengths, weakness, opportunities and challenges-
C would take up those problems which are disastrous for the State.
8 how would you do public interaction. So many people in the districts?
A would talk to leaders- religious leaders, Sarpanch teachers, who can enlighten me about the issues.
9 how would you ensure that the information is up to the mark. if they are telling a lie?
A sir I would cross check the information from multiple sour
ces
. There might be some government officials who are working in that area, so I would ask for their inputs. Also.
Member 3-
1 there are some paralimpians who have became grand masters.. are you aware of that.
A sorry sir, I am not aware of their names.
2 okay no problem. You talked about positive side of RTI but don’t you think it is also creating problems for the officials?
A. Yes sir, sometimes there are RTIs with mollified intentions and government officials have to respond to them which consumes a lot of time. so it harms the efficiency of the government.
3 government has brought many policies for PWDs. What are those policies and programmes.
A rights for persons with disability Act 2016
B accessible India campaign-
C pre metric and post metric scholarships –
4 what kind of solutions do you want to give?
A sir recently our honourable PM took dinner with PWDs after they won prices at Asian games. It is a good initiative.
B. Accessibility should be given more attention-
C. Inclusive education must be emphasized-
5 are you talking about only visually impaired or all persons with disability?
A sir persons with disability from all categories
Member 4-
1 do you listen music? Bollywood songs?
A. Yes ma’am sometime- I was thinking why questions on these since not my hobby.
2 do you know about some cricketers who have made some ugly comments at some show?
A yes ma’am in coffee with Karan.
3 so tell me why such comments. Do we need to book them for such kind of acts?
A definitely ma’am because movies are widely seen in the society and they have an impact on the people so they should be responsible for their acts.
4 do this literature or music, movies represent the reality of our society?
A yes ma’am- if there is a demand then these kind of literature is produced. And therefore bollywood is the mirror of our society.
5 how to correct the value system. Should it be corrected by the government, schools or family?
A ma’am family is an institution where basic socialization takes place, so primary responsibility belongs to the parents. There should be gender neutral norms in the homes.
B ma’am government and schools are also responsible. The recent BBBP scheme has helped in changing the perception with regard to girl child.
Again chair person-
1 do you know some of the chess players from India?
A ma’am Vishwanathan Anand –
B Parimarjan Negi –
2 okay Rakesh we are closing your interview.
A got obsessed with so many mocks 13 or 14 and expecting that they will say something you have performed well or feedback but that was an imagination only, so had to stand up from the chair and leave the room With saying Thank you ma’am
Overall- very cordial board, very friendly, there were no questions on current affairs, Haryana, or graduation subjects. The interview mostly revolved with DAF section.
Name Gubi
Computer. Science Engineering
Hobby - no question
Board - Sujata mam
( a lot of question on HR side by members)
Chairwoman :
0. Introduce yourself
0. How much work experience
0. Was it difficult to adjust in Surathkal (college)
0. Do you think Skills of people are not recognised and given any responsibility, in government set up (work exp based)
0. What was your role in the job
0. Why do you want to come into civilservices
0. Isn’t the chief or vp of MNC are given greater decisional making power? How’s that different from a civil servant ?
Member 1:
0. You have mentioned cryptography in your subject, How would you use it in Administration
0. At policy level whether your advice would take precedence or an experts
0. What is the most important quality You have
0. Difference between moral integrity and financial integrity and give examples of both from your personal life
0. Which rifle did you use (medal)
0. Which is your favourite swimming style and what is your best time (medal)
Member 2:
0. What is encryption
0. What is IP address
0. How many bits, how many ip addresses in32 bits
0. Good qualities of an administrator
0. What is emotional intelligence can it be measured, Having emotions is a good quality or bad quality
0. In this world how do you update yourself how do you improve your knowledge?
0. Last book you read and What does it say
Member 3:
0. What is most important thing in your life
0. Then a case on it .
0. Stretching the case further
Member 4 :
0. A lot of money has been invested in PSU, not performing well, what is the reason .
0. What should be done
0. Do you know how much money has been invested in PSUs and How many PSUs are there
chairwoman
0. Evm, can they be tempered
0. Why , why not
0. How to restore the faith
Thank you .
BB Vyas Board
February 13, afternoon session, last to go in (04.55 pm)
Duration: 35 minutes
Chairman:
1. Tell us something about yourself.
2. Major changes in Indian Foreign Policy since 2014
3. Economic Diplomacy. Hasn't that been a major change as well?
4. Major Challenges in India Pakistan relationship?
5. How to overcome them?
Member 1 (lady member):
1. What is the role of the Indian Information Service? How is it relevant today?
2. Do you think the service is fulfilling it's role in the era of fake news?
3. Have we found a solution to the fake news problem?
4. You've studied the German Language, and you're a mechanical engineer. Why do you think Germany is the world leader in automobiles while India can't even produce a flagship vehicle beyond the Ambassador?
5. Difference between Germans and Indians (in attitude)
6. Tell me 3 positive things about Hitler i.e. how did he benefit the world?
Member 2:
1. You made a passing reference to Indian agriculture largely being a failure. Do you stick with that statement?
2. What was the objective vis-a-vis agriculture at the time of Independence?
3. We have achieved food self sufficiency. Then how can you say it is a failure?
4. When was SAARC formed?
5. Objective of SAARC?
6. Where is SAARC HQ?
7. How many members in SAARC? Can you list them?
Member 3 (lady member):
1. Why did you decide to study the German language?
2. What can we learn from the Germans?
3. You've stayed in Mumbai as well as Delhi. How do you compare the attitude of people from the two cities?
4. What is the impact of the Mumbai based film industry on Maharashtra?
(She asked a few more questions which escape my recollection.)
Member 4:
1. What do you know about the term "Hydro-diplomacy?"
2. Give the some examples of cross border river conflicts
3. Give me one example each of India as an upper reparian and lower reparian state.
3. What is the crisis regarding the Brahmaputra?
4. What is the policy doctrine based on which China justifies it's dam building activities on the Brahmaputra?
5. Which is the richest municipality in Asia? (Mumbai) what is its annual budget (32,000 cr approx)?
6. If tomorrow you're made the municipal commissioner (of Mumbai), how will you utilize these 32,000 crore? Give me 5 areas upon which you'll focus (could come up with only 4)
7. Don't you think rehabilitation shall be included as a top priority, given Mumbai's migration and slum problems?
Member 2:
1. Let's go back to SAARC. Do you think SAARC is a viable mechanism for resolving the development and other issues in South Asia?
Chairman:
1. We've discussed enough about the land. Let's discuss India in the sky. Give me three achievements of India in this field over the past few years. (Discussed ISRO, Missile program, IAF etc.)
2. If tomorrow, you have to write an article providing a roadmap to sustain India's growth, what 5 themes would your article be based on?
Thank you, your interview is over.
Bassi sir board
Optional : medical science
Interest and hobbies : learning about countries, watching world news
Chairman:
It started with utkarungal... am I right? Or utkaruppa
Me : Utkarungal is more respectful sir. You can say utkarupa
C : then I shud respect you as you may become a bureaucrat!! (everyone laughed)
Read aloud my interest
C : tell me about Malta.. Wer is it? Capital ? famous for? Economy of Malta
C : capital of marshall island
C : Tell me about Timbuktu? History? River passing through it?
Whether the river passes through it or around it?
C : how is blood stored? At what temperature? criteria to select donors..
(Here only he came to know that Im from medicine)
C : here's my fav question.. what is tympanic reflex?
Member 1 (mam was so cordial)
Koovagam festival and TG rights
Tamil nadu and diplomacy with other countries
Asked about some countries
Cancer is increasing - what can be done for men and women to reduce the incidence of cancer
M2
What changes will you do to health sector if you become health secretary?
And follow up questions came
What is digital India
(I forgot few questions)
M3
What is Tanjore famous for?
Details of big temple
Tell me about your personality
Follow up questions
(Here he insisted to add more..)
M4
Phcs are not performing well. What changes can be done?
Can we privatise or can insurance be allowed in it?
Flourosis and treatment
Which is the best method for providing fluoride free water
Chairman
Fossil park in Tamil nadu?
Venezuela crisis - explain?
Good or bad for India?
What should India do?
Thank you! Interview is over
(I couldn't recollect some questions)
All the best!!
Kumkum joshi.
(12-02-2019)
Uttarakhand
Homescience graduate, Social work in mental health post graduate(TISS)
worked in NGO, for homeless women with mental illness.
Hobbies- blog writing, floor art making, handknitting.
BS bassi sir board.
Afternoon session, 3rd to go.
Board came 45 min late.
Bassi sir(BS) - So kumkum, you are a specialist in homescience, what should I ask you? Does it cover nutrition also? I do not know much about it, why dont you tell me about a scheme for women's better health. Also tell me some measures for reducing MMR and IMR.
- Why our MMR and IMR is so high (i told in previous ans that it is very high)
M1(lady member) - smiled and said So you have worked for the Banyan, wonderful! Can you tell me the banyan model of mental health care and how it could be replicated in north india.
- Tell me special problems of elderly, and govt's measures.
- You are from a beautiful state, tell me most highlight problem of mussorie road
- Do you think it could be curbed (illegal construction of resorts and hotels)
M2- (serious looking guy) meanwhile bassi sir kept staring me, I smiled at him in between,he didn budge.
- tell me the qualities of a leader. (Told 3)
- tell me some more
- one more current affairs women related question. Forgot now :p
M3- So kumkum you have worked in chennai, tell me if you see any pattern on gender sensitivity in north and south.
- ok now tell me why north india is not very safe, is it anything related to having sisters in house?
- Which is better, north or south. (Told personal experiences)
- Ok, homescience!! Tell me if home schooling is better or hostels? Is Coeducation good or not?
(Lady member exclaimed in middle, TISS is a good institution)
-Tell me what peculiar problems muslim women from lower socio economic background facr. (Told about family planning constraints, first time Little nod from him)
- you write blog, what do you write about
- what is kumaoni floor art aipan
M4- Do you know what trade services are(the candidate before me was from ITS)
- tell me about RERA
-Tell me the parametres of smart city
-tell me specific problmes of slum dwelling women.
- If we make you secretary of urban development how are you going to solve these issues.
- (told some measures) Tell me some long term solutions , these are all short term.
- (told about decentralized rehabilitation etc, ) They do not agree to go to new places, tell me an innovative solution to this problem of slum (Told one, he was not satisfied).
Bassi sir - loud smile, I observed you have hand knitting as a hobby, do you make designs also?
- tell me the most difficult design
- is jaali design tough(i said yes) Yes, i think jaali is very tough and kept smiling
- what did u knit last
- (i knit a sweater in January) which was the toughest part for you in the sweater.
- Looking at all members, and said very unique hobby, Will you knit in offic if we take you in? All started laughing loud, including me.
- I said No sir, i guess there will be some conduct rules, BS- no, but conduct rules does not stop knitting, sly smile
I Said I will have a lot more work to do, i will knit at home in free time, lady member was very happy now.
BS- Finally before you go tell me why saudi and qatar fighting.
BS- Gave me smile, good good, Kumkum wonderful, you may leave now.
(Cordial board, most from DAF and past work, no questions from Anthropology, mainly women related questions)
G:
Date 13.2.19
Second to go in
Optional anthro
Delhi home state
Sujata Mehta Board
Nothing asked from Home state, Optional, Hobbies, or Recent current affairs and only 2 questions from graduation.
Cordial board
Didnt give time to explain a lot. Sujata ma'am would cut in after first few words in case she understood what I was saying.
No stress questions and very few counter questions based on what i had replied. No controversial questions either.
Chairperson
* Introduce yourself
* So you've not taken up another job after graduation? Why the attraction for civil services?
* You've lived in an urban area for a long time. Do you think domestic help should be regulated?
* Why?
* Should it be regulated more urgently that other kinds of informal work?
* You spoke of the construction sector. Tell me one structural defect in the construction sector and one crisis?
* Was demonetisation also a crisis? How?
* Did it effect the labourers? How?
M1
* You spoke of agrarian crisis (i had not), tell me what is the biggest issue with the agrarian sector?
* What about the MSP? MSP is rising yet farmers are not getting benefitted, how long can this go on?
* What areas would you like to work in as a young officer?
* You mentioned pollution, how would you control that as a DM?
M2
* Can i ask you some simple questions from your graduation subject?
* What are the four nitrogenous bases in DNA?
* Who discovered the double helical structure?
* If not IAS what would you rather be?
* Oh yes you've also done rock climbing, how did you get introduced to this?
* While honesty is important, is it also important to be seen as honest?
* How can you do this especially in todays world with the media?
* Are you impulsive or calculative?
* If someone is impulsive, how can that be justified?
* Would you rather be nice or firm?
M3
* You mentioned water conservation, how would you do it in a drought district?
* I went off on a tangent here, so she said- no no i'm talking about a drought district. Have you heard of fasal bima yojana?
* How effective has it been?
* Then the water conservation question repeated?
* Okay and anything regarding crops that you can do to conserve water?
M4
* Two major incidents happened in 1989, can you tell me what they are (No clue)
* It was the fall of the berlin wall and the Tiananmen square protests in China
* So tell me about them? How were they significant?
* Do you forsee democracy coming in China?
* But in the long run can economic growth triumph over political aspirations of the people?
* You've studied evolution, tell me two books written by Darwin
* Why were there massive protests against the books?
* Not just the church, even the scientific community protested, why?
Chairperson
* Talked about Air India case in which MP was put on no fly list and recent murder of policeman in line of duty in bulandshahr. Do you think the Government protects its employees against these incidents?
* Let me rephrase- There is a concept of exemplary punishment, do you think it should be given in case someone hinders a public servant in line of duty? Or should we just let it pass by?
* Why does the government then let it pass by?
* Is there anything else you would like to discuss with us?
B Tech. Mechanical
Optional: Anthro
Last one to go
B. S. BASSI SIR BOARD
CHAIRMAN
1) Tell me benefits of automobile industry?
2) industries dependent on automobile industry?
M1
1) Tell me about Tadoba Tiger reserve
2) Why Murud Janjira famous ?
M2
1) Tell me your strengths ans weaknesses
2) asked me to organise auto expo
M3
1) asked me about Unnat bharat abhiyan ( mentioned in daf)
M4 ( lady member)
1) Asked me about Dr. B R Ambedkar ( in daf)
His contribution to constitution, society, women.
2) how will you ensure women safety in your district?
CHAIRMAN
1) Continuing with discussion he asked my opinion that should we thrash a person involved in eve teasing.
He asked around 5 min on that...
25 minutes
Pramod singh
Board:. B.B vyas
Profile: textile technology
Chairperson:
1Tell me in breif about textile sector in India.
2)silk sector problem and solutions
3)schemes for welfare of weavers
4)diff bw insurance penetration and density
5)problem in PMFBY and weather based insurance
Members
1)khadi sector problems and solution
2)textile sector pollution, and solutions
3)work of central silk board
4) technological textile scope, schemes, indias status
5) why math called exact sceince
6) impact of gst and demonetisation on textile industry
7) why so diverse hobby weightliting, shotput and cricket.
Ayush Jain
14/02 , 3rd to go
Mechanical Engineering
Hobby - Watching F1 races
Board : Smita Nagaraj
Chairman
Let's start with your name, Min of Ayush, Tell me pros and cons
Should bridge courses be introduced?
What are merits and demerits?
M1
What is added to rubber to make it hard?
In engine mounting, rubber pads are used, what is added in it?
What's so special about F1 tracks?
Are tracks more sophisticated than F1 available somewhere?
M2
Spoils system in US?
Summoning of Jack Dorsey, JPC members do not take oath, how are they doing this?
Why only now?
M3
Why SAE BAJA is becoming popular?
What is the learning?
Roll cage design?
Do you think it is becoming money centric? Where is the innovation?
M4
Why periodic table was in news?
Tell me some things due to which society suffers
On Google, how they predict what you write beforehand?
Tell me some e governance initiatives?
Is there any one single app?
Full form of UMANG app
Chairman
Have you visited any village?
Met any farmer there?
Why the agricultural distress?
Solutions to handle
Should free electricity be provided?
Views on agricultural tax