Interviews

UPSC interview, R. N. Choubey board, 10 Apr 2023 (Rajasthan)

10 Apr 2023

Transcript

Date- March 29th, 2023 – Forenoon session, 1st one to go

Optional: Commerce & Accountancy

Educational background: B.Com, CA, Actuarial Science (CB1, CB2)

Work Ex.: Barclays – Financial Analyst (< 1 year)

State: Rajasthan (Tonk)

Sports: Volleyball

Hobbies: Balcony Gardening, Abstract Sketching

Extra -curricular: Quiz, Elocution

2nd Attempt – 1st interview

Board- Chaubey sir

Chairman asked me to be comfortable by saying that we are friendly people to have conversation with you and not a police interrogation.

Asked me whether I am comfortably sitting

1. Tell us your educational background and work experience

2. Monologue – Since you are a CA, you are in good position to comment on Vijay Mallya case. Told about the case, that Vijay Mallya claims it to be a failure of Business Decision (Deccan airlines) while regulators claim him as wilful defaulter. What is your take on it.

a. {Vijay Mallya was in news on 23rd and 24th March}

3. Asked me to define “Layering of transaction” – mentioned in my ans. How it was done in Vijay Mallya case and other areas where it is employed. Mechanisms to do it.

4. Continued with Vijay Mallya Topic –

a. Whether we should place Bank in position to significantly control the commercial decisions of the organizations to which they extend significant amount of loan. (driven from my ans.)

b. Reporting transactions to bank is post event control mechanism, we should place Bank in management control position – I explicitly denied it, it will hamper the economy

c. Then, what should we do to control such wilful defaults

5. 1 more topic – not able to recall

Member – 1

1. Gram Panchayat – Reservation to women. Is it successful? – agreed partially, substantiated with examples

2. Panel member said these are just few examples, we hear problem of “Sarpanch Pati”, how could we resolve it? – I agreed, along with mentioned Punjab Govt. initiative to ban Sarpanch proxies.

3. Why India not came up with Gram Panchayat in original Constitution itself? And What would have happened if we had it in original constitution? - answered only 1st ques, then he stopped me.

4. One more ques., not able to recall.

Member – 2

1. Firstly mentioned about my CA journey from 2014-2018

2. Long Monologue on CA’s role in scams and defaults.

a. What are the provisions in Chartered Accountant Act for such acts. – answered that I am not aware of exact provisions of CA Act 1949, but we have Ethical code of conduct.

b. What is the maximum punishment to a CA? – wrongly interpreted it to be imprisonment. Further he clarified that he was asking about debar provisions from Register of Members. – I apologised for my wrong interpretation and agreed to the life time debar provisions in Chartered Accountant Act 1949.

3. Asked year of Benami Prohibition Act - answered could not recall.

4. Further asked about recent amendments in Benami Prohibition act – not aware of exact intricacies of provisions

5. Asked to define Benami and how can we do it. – answered.

Member – 3

1. Mentioned about ‘Business Administration’ – one of the subject in B.Com. Asked why CA and not MBA?

2. Monologue on MBA are over-rated, they are promoting products harming our planet. Should not we do away with MBA? – firstly I answered on Human resource part along with that mentioned about promotion of greener products.

a. But he clarified question is on operational part. – answered on C-suite positions held by MBA successfully, driver of cos. and economy.

b. He said his view is MBA is over-rated. Chaubey sir intervened. – answered we need MBA’s for economy.

3. One more ques., could not recall

Member – 4

1. Asked whether I know about ‘Debt trap’? – said Yes.

2. Asked to explain.

3. India also gives loan to countries, and China also gives. Then why people of those countries goes against India – where India is lacking, what should we do? – 1stly answered on India’s LT perspective – he clarified I am not asking that. – asked for some seconds to think on it

4. Why we are lacking on implementation

5. What should we do?

6. You heard of AI? – said yes

7. Asked whether I am following govt. initiatives on AI – answered no., because not able to came up with 3 AI initiatives in my mind at that time.

8. Asked about Human v/s AI in context of AI. – answered AI can take up basic work, not analytical.

a. Long discussion on it – kept my stand of Human(auditors) always above AI

Chairman – anything you would like to tell us, we not asked.

Board was cordial.

Please never lose your cool.

Mocks useful to gain confidence and to do away with habit of doing guesswork in answers. Also keeps you on track of your preparation

Khan Sir – One to One (most helpful) and Panel Mock (KSG)

Ravindran Sir (Vajiram) – One to One

Samkalp IAS, Chahal IAS, Vajirao Reddy, Next IAS, Shankar IAS, Unacademy – 1st mock (Menon sir pointed my problem areas and gave suggestions)