UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 4 Apr 2023
4 Apr 2023
Date - 24th of March, afternoon session, 2nd to go.
Board - Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla
DAF points
1. BA Pol Sci, Fergusson college
2. optional - Anthropology
3. Hobbies - Baking healthy dishes, kathak
4. Nashik, Maharashtra - no questions.
5. DANICS service - no question
CHAIRPERSON
Sit down and remove your mask, read some parts of my DAF
1. Name, graduation, you are from Fergusson College. How is Fergusson doing now?
2. Does Fergusson also feel privileged to have you.
3. Question regarding ethics and probity in governance. Should we learn to say NO or go all out. Everyone is compromising something or should we stay put. Should we go all out and be aggressive in achieving our goals or otherwise?
4. How to deal with other wrongdoings, I am not talking about corruption, to that you should completely say No, but what about things that are contradictory. How do we handle that?
5. There is more corruption in state services, I mean state services are not considered efficient. How to we solve this problem?
Chairperson Went to the restroom
MEMBER 1
His phone alarm went off and he couldn’t switch it off for quite some time. Till then chairperson re-entered
1. Explained a very lengthy scenario about judiciary interacting with press and media. There was a recent conference attended by members of judiciary including the CJI. In the court room they have to main a decorum, they write 100 pages long verdicts and judgements, but in the media these are reduced to few words. Media is uncontrollable and can be misused. What is your take on this?
2. Some follow up question – which I don’t remember.
3. What is faceless assessment?
4. How is it done?
5. Where does the assessment take place? Regional office or centralized office?
MEMBER 2
1. You have studied Political Science but taken up Anthropology, shall I ask you about Political Science?
2. In India’s neighbourhood, there is political turmoil and chaos. Do you think there is a need to renew the social contract? Due to accent problem, I requested him to repeat the question. He graciously did.
3. Who gave the concept of the greatest good of the greatest number
4. Indian constitution is restrictive on the government. Do you agree?
5. What provides flexibility?
6. When was the basic structure doctrine introduced?
You are so good at political science, why did you take up anthropology. I was ready to answer but it was more of a comment.
Member 1 intervened
1. If the constituent assemby was alive will they have introduced basic structure?
2. And what if the constituent assembly was alive will they have removed the basic structure?
And we moved to lady member on my right.
MEMBER 3 (FEMALE)
1. What are the steps taken by government for reducing corruption?
2. Is that it? What about CVC? What does CVC do?
3. Who is a whistleblower?
4. Where does a whistleblower blow the whistle? Where exactly does he go?
5. What is 3D cooking? (hobby – baking healthy dishes).
Chairperson again went to the restroom.
6. You have studied anthropology? Why did you change the subject?
7. What do you like in anthropology? – I said socio-cultural anthropology, but no further questions asked on it.
8. What is litmus test? I confirmed – whether in chemistry? She said yes
9. What is litmus test otherwise?
MEMBER 4
His voice was bearly audible. He kept making faces when I answered his or other members’ questions. He always looked unsatisfied.
1. We have talked about corruption in public sector. Let us talk about corruption in private sector. How to solve it?
2. What is energy security?
3. What about affordability? Can we supply it at any random price?
4. What are the steps government is taking to promote it?
5. What is green hydrogen?
CHAIRPERSON
Ok thank you. Your interview is over.
I collected my mask and left the room.