Interviews

UPSC interview, R. N. Choubey board, 27 Mar 2023 (Kerala)

27 Mar 2023

Date of interview: 27th march

Board: choubey sir (with an all male panel)

Afternoon session, 4th to go

Background: BA Econ, MA social work

Work experience: LAMP Fellow, Reliance Foundation, NITI Aayog

Home state: Kerala

Chairperson cordially invited to sit and mentioned that I should not hesitate to inform them if I'm not comfortable with any question or if I dont know the answer to any.

Chairperson (was smiling despite me being unable to answer few questions with precision):

1. Briefly mention your academic background and eork experience.

2. Define IPC, CrPC and Indian Evidence Act

3. How are the different from each other?

4. When were these formed?

5. What is the difference between the Constitution and an Act?

6. Why do we follow IPC, CRPC etc. Which were formed before our Constitution was enacted? (He said "Old habits die hard?") -could not answer this question too well so the Chairman moved on.

M2 (he maintained a poker face throughout with an ocassional smile):

1. Why is there so much superstition in our society?

2. Long monologue on scientific temper and rationality. Has our state been unable to foster scientific temper in our society?

3. Long monologue on man animal conflict with multiple questions: why it happens? Should humans take precedence over animals? To what extent it should be allowed? How do we manage long term? (I ended my answer saying the long term way ahead is to sensitize communities for peaceful coexistence and the member seemed to agree)

4. Asked if I could give an example of peaceful coexistence of humans and animals. (Could not recall at the moment and he gave a brief description of Gir forest)

M3 (very pleasant):

1. Difference between religion and superstition?

2. What would did you do at NITI Aayog (I described my work which also involved work on Global Hunger Index)

3. Follow up from GHI, he asked about GHI rank over the years and why it has been falling?

4. Does it highlight a failure of policymaking? How can we improve ourselves?

5. difference between planning commission and NITI.

6. Mandate of Planning Commission and NITI+DMEO (My ex-office)

M4 (looked pretty serious throughout):

1. I had mentioned about a data governance project that I was part of at NITI, so asked me about few data sources of the Government.

2. Which ministry published NHFS?

3. Any other organisation that helps in data collection of NFHS?

He asked one more long question that I can't recall now. But to this question, the chairman interrupted and said "In essence, this is what he means....." and reframed the question precisely.

M5 (very serious):

1. Why has Dharavi been in the news recently? (College and previous work in Mumbai for 7 years)

2. List out 5 salient features of Dharavi.

3. What made covid management in Dharavi so efficient?

4. Long monologue of how communities in the Konkan areas, especially women have been migrating to Mumbai for work. Asked me the reasons for it.

Chairman said it was good talking to me and that they are finished with the questions. He asked if there is anything I would like to share with them. I just thanked them for the opportunity. He asked if I was comfortable. I said yes sir and smiled. He said "Great, you may leave now".

Overall: Except for the Chairman and one panelist, the board was not very pleasant. No expressions from the board while I was answering. Two members tried to probe deeper but other two did not. They were neither cordial nor grilling.

Mocks: ShankarIAS (Trivandrum and Delhi), Byjus, Samkalp, KSG, NextIAS, Raus, AmritaIAS Trivandrum

One on one with Ravindran sir, Vinay sir, Bassi sir, Shinas sir (ilearn), Nitin sir (IASMentor)

Utility of mocks: Except at understanding few etiquettes, I think I would have performed the same way if I hadn't attended any mocks.