UPSC interview, M. Sathiyavathy board, 26 Mar 2023
26 Mar 2023
Date: 21/03/23
Board: Sathyavati Mam
Job profile: Corporate Lawyer, Supreme Court Advocate, IPS
Key words in DAF:
1. PIL for Persecuted Hindu Minorities from Pakistan
2. Case on Child Welfare Committee, Securing the Children from Sexual Offences
3. WTO Internship, EU Diploma from Lisbon
4. Anti-Dumping Investigation in Ministry of Commerce
5. Internet Censorship Paper in Oxford
Optional: Law
Time: 36 mins
Chairperson(~10 mins)
Read aloud the DAF for 1.5 mins. Asked about the current occupation. Board turned investigative and interrogative when told about the service, as I could have perceived from their reactions.
1.Discussion on Basic Feature of the Constitution, Why not defined, Should it be defined, why certain feature are in Basic Structure not others, Conflict amongst the Consitutional institutions, Separation of Powers.
2.Judicial Appointement, NJAC, Improvement on the System, If Parliament oversight and inclusion in appointment process is done, would it create equilibrium, Increasing Judicial efficiency etc
3. EWS case in which I worked:
i. Why exclusion of SC/ST/OBC from EWS?
ii. Is Only economic criteria for reservation unconstitutional?
4. Why not stayed back in Legal Career?
5. Why only IAS not IFS?
M1 (~7 mins, Male)
1. Condition of Pak Minorities living in India particularly in Jaipur
i.Relief given by Jodhpur HC, Supreme Court
ii.What more can be done?
2. Work done in Child Welfare Committee
i. How we rescued those children?
ii. Safety, Security and Education of these children
iii. Criminal motions against the Culprits.
3. Asked about Sri Kailash Satyarthi and Bachpan Bachao Andolan, Trafficking issue, Missing children, Child Labour etc
4. Why there is a percieved gap between Law and Justice? How will you fill this gulf?
5. Policing issues, Reforms required, Psychological impact on people after interaction with Police, Improvement required.
M2 (~ 8 mins, most interrogative, Male)
1. Use of Law in Economic Diplomacy.
2. Legal Recommendations in G20 outcome documents.
3. Training ITS Officers for Trade Negotiations.
4. State of WTO- Failed or Successful, Doha Round Stalemate.
5. Conflict between RTAs, FTAs and WTO Agreement.
6. PMLA, Cryptos, Financial Crime enforcement.
M3 (~6 mins, Female, Amenable Lady)
1. Apart from Legal enforcement, what changes would you bring in terms of governance and administration?
i. Discussion on Health Governance.
ii. Education and Skills.
iii. State of Teachers in Primary Schools in Rural Areas, Non-core duty burden on Teachers etc.
2. Situation of Rural and Urban:
i. Differences in their interaction with Police?
ii. Improving the interface of Rural Women with Police, Measures to improve
iii. Women, SHGs as a changing agent.
With less time on hand, Satyavathi Mam started knocking the table with Pen to indicate the Member to move on.( Member felt sad!😐)
M4 (~5 mins, Male, Good Guy)
At the outset he complimented about the cases I dealt, appreciated Public Spiritidness.
1. Motivations behind the PIL and removing social sufferings.
2. Discussed about the Constitutional Law classes, inspirations from the cases etc.
3. Situation of rescued deaf and dumb children who were subjected to sexual cruelties etc.
Again, Mam started knocking.
I told Memeber that all these cases have the capacity to shock the conscience of any society and I was no exception. I got to learn a lot and it will immensely help me in administration.
Mam again urged the Board to ask further questions. No one did. She bid me Thank You.
I left the room on a happy note!