Interviews

UPSC interview, Preeti Sudan board, 24 Mar 2023 (PSIR)

24 Mar 2023

Name: M

Board: Preeti Sudan Ma'am

Date: 24th March, 2023 (Afternoon)

Place: Tirupati / Nellore (AP)

College: St. Stephen's (Political science, Economics), JNU (IR)

Optional: PSIR

Service Preference: IFS (nothing asked explicitly)

Hobbies: Social Service volunteering

DAF Key Words: NET-JRF

Chairperson:

Take your seat. This is just a conversation

1. So, you are born in Nellore? (Brought up mostly in Tirupati though)

2. Tell me why Tirupati has high number of child marriages and cases of domestic violence

3. What will you do to curb it? (Education, Awareness involving the temple admn was one suggestion)

4. Is education enough to tackle these problems?

5. So, you are from JNU and Stephen's

6. Compare these 2 institutions

7. Since you are a JNU student, tell me what learnings you did while in college and how will you use them as an administrator. (I was in Online-COVID batch, but told whatever learnings I had)

8. Good, you have a NET also, why don't you pursue teaching? (Told that I am not sure about teaching, but research will continue irrespective of my career choice)

M1:

1. What grievance redressal mechanism is there for telecom related complaints? (I thought he was asking of portals etc and then he only suggested TRAI)

2. What other mechanism you know? (He mentioned some other name I couldn't recognise; I said I don't know)

3. How and what research you would pursue? (Mentioned about applying for PhD program and on wait list currently for the seat)

4. Have you submitted thesis? (I said it's still at proposal stage)

5. He inquired what it was?

M2

1. Argue in favor of the statement - India will be a developed country by 2047

2. What are the main road blocks that prevents from that road

4. Status of infrastructure in India

5. What financing options we have for infrastructure

6. What are the global implications of the Russia-Ukraine war? What has changed?

M3

1. So you said you are volunteering in the social sector; tell me about the what we could do about persons with disabilities? Firstly tell me all the disabilities you can identify(Mentioned both Physical and Mental disabilities and types I could identify)

2. What are the key issues?

3. What provisions do we have? Heard about the PwD Act?

4. Apart from Reservations what other schemes are there?

M4 (Lady Member)

1. Do you agree with the statement that we are having worse ties ever with our neighbours ? (I said mixed view about the statement and explained why so)

2. What about Nepal? (The conversation on these 2 questions went on for a while)

3. What are the foreign policy measures that you commend or not commend?

4. Internationally, name 3 personalities who have impacted global affairs. (I said Mikhail Gorbachev and why, Indira Gandhi)

5. Indira Gandhi is more of national leader, tell me internationally (I said also international because impacted the course cold war, signed India-USSR and liberation of a new country, Bangladesh)

6. Third personality? (I said can't think of anyone else)

7. She suggested, Heard of Henry Kissinger? (I said Yes, Mentioned a few reasons why & she added a few more points)

Chairperson - Thank you, you may leave now

Overall Experience: It was a good conversation that captured most of my interests. Smooth experience. Felt happy afterward.

Utility of Mocks: Chahal, Vajirao, KSG was good. Rau's I enjoyed even more (The IFS member here actively took interest in my words, spoke to me in French as well).

Vision Faculty Online Mock helped me prepare well (through some grilling)

Mocks helped me work on my formal speech, gestures, greetings etc. Helped me pick the right saree for the day as well. Some Mocks were held in big hotels. This helped me maintain composure and not be overwhelmed even after seeing the grandeur of UPSC Bhawan as a first timer there.

O2O Discussions: Mohan Sir of IAS Baba, Vinay Sir of Insights helped me shape some answers and perspectives. Khan Sir cleared last minute doubts. Vision DAF Analysis session was very detailed.

All the best!

Curryyy:

Name- Wardell

Date and session of interview- 23rd March 2023 (Forenoon | 3rd to go)

Board- Raj Shukla sir

Optional- Not asked anything

College- Some IIT

Profession (if any)- NA

Hobbies- Speedcubing, Mentoring aspirants, Listening to Ghazals and Qawwali

Your experience in interview- Did fumble in 1-2 questions. Overall goood.

Utility of mocks or O2O (if any)- Gave ~10 mocks and 2-3 one to one interviews.

Went inside. Sir told me to sit down before I finished greeting the board. Shukla sir was sitting at a distance almost double that of the other 4 members.

Chairperson

1. What is speedcubing? [no follow-up]

2. What are you doing these days?

3. You also mentor students. How do you do that?

4. Don't you think that with YouTube, relevance of teachers has decreased?

5. But if one can get 10 different videos on internet on a topic, isn't it better than having a teacher?

6. Has the respect for teaching as a profession decreased?

7. Why there is a disconnect between Eductation/ teaching and government? What to do to revive that?

8. Let's talk about the push to renewable energy. We shifted from wood to fossils a long time back. What will drive the push from fossils to renewable energy today?

9. What factors will determine the shift to renewable energy?

10. But isn't renewable energy also harmful. We have seen instances of whales dying on USA's coast where wind turbines are located?

11. Isn't that what climate sceptics are saying? How will you counter them

12. How to decide what renewable projects should be persued? There are cost/benefits associated with everything.

13. Isn't is hypocritical that dignitaries come to climate summits in their private jets?

M1 (Female)

1. Since you look like a committed supporter of Climate change, what steps Delhi govt is taking to reduce pollution? She herself said GRAP

2. Why are we not focussing on 2 wheelers much while thinking about pollution from vehicles?

3. What is AQI? constituents? Which is most harmful?

4. What are climatic impacts of space tourism?

5. Can you compare fuel emissions of commercial aircrafts and jets of space tourism?

6. Tell me something about Sardar Patel?

7. You also play basketball. It is a sport not very famous in India. Why?

8. What to do to promote basketball. Why can't we have a league like IPL?

9. What other sports do you play?

10. You mentor students. What don't you go in teaching as a profession?

11. What is the difference between a ghazal and a qawwali

M2

1. Ghazals was earlier for/by elites. Who brought it to the masses?

2. You said you played TT. Do you remember the recent controversy [Manika Batra and her coach]? Also the wrestlers protests! How to make sports administration better?

3. You studied from DAV. Tell me the person on whose name the school is named?

4. How are his teachings relevant today?

5. You are from Bhojpur. Tell me the reasons why film stars in south and well as Bhojpuri movies come to politics?

6. Tell me something about Ujjwala scheme?

—- forgetting 1-2 questions!

M3

1. Have you heard about Agniveer? You are entitled to have your opinion. How do you see the scheme?

2. You said it is progressive. Can we have something like this in civil services as well?

3. Follow ups on that!

4. Lets talk about disinvestment. Which PSUs can we disinvest?

5. Does govt have any business being in business?

6. You sound contradictory! How can PSUs attract more money if they are loss making?

7. You studied in IITX? Tell me the issues there and what would you suggest to improve the curriculum?

—- forgetting 1-2 questions!

Shukla sir got up and went outside for 10-15 seconds.

By that time, I think 30 odd minutes were over. Shukla sir came back told me thoda on Agniveer and how it is goood. He agreed with me that 'it's a good initiative only if it delivers on ground'. After that he nodded to me that my interview is over. I looked at M4 and Shukla sir was like 'Oooo, aapne nahin poocha!'. M4 was like "It's okay, we can end this here".

M4

1. What is International Solar Alliance? How can India leverage it?

2. What is the share of renewable energy in India? I said it's close to 40%. He said it's 18% . I humbly accepted that I'll have to go back and check.

—- 1 more question

Shukla sir nodded and told me to go!

Experience

1. Was cordial. They did not try to corner me on any question apart from some follow-ups

2. M4 asked only 2-3 questions. Usme bhi renewable mein 18% kahan se aaya I don't know. But interview duration was 30-35 minutes!

3. Everyone was attentive for the most part.

4. Shukla sir doesn't ask us to introduce ourselves. Also, he doesn't ask any final question after all members have finished. At least that's what it looks like from the transcripts.

5. I did zone out during a long monologue of Shukla sir. Gathered myself quickly after that.

6. Have fun. All the best :)