Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 14 Mar 2023

14 Mar 2023

Name : Anon

Interview date : 14th March forenoon

Board : Smita Nagraj mam

Last to go, around 1.30 pm

Approx 30-35 mins

Daf : nothing asked

Optional : psychology

Graduation: civil engineering

Place : Pune

Chairwoman,:

1. How are you today?

2. Why did you quit engineering and coming to civil services?

3. 2 problems which you would like to solve

4. How will you solve?

5. Why we are not able to solve?

6. Liquor prohibition- do you support?

Member 1:

1. Psychology optional - how will you use it for person who comes to you for help? (Long monologue before)

2. What about motivation?

Any motivational theories?

3. What are the problems we are facing as a nation?

4. What about corruption?

Member 2(lady)

continuing from member 1-

1.Tell me something about civil contracts

2. Corruption in civil contracts

3. Tell me types of corruption in civil contracts

4. If you were under immense pressure to hire a contractor who you know is not good, what will you do?

5. (After asking clarification regarding my role and discretion,)

Do you think in bureaucratic setup , discretion is there?

6. if immediate senior is also under pressure, then what will you do?

Member 3: (lady)

1. Mob lynching by women who are being harassed by a person and tired of it, they lynch him (Mumbai incident) - rule of law not followed- what do you say

2. Why are people doing this?

3. Where is the problem in our governance?

4. What should we do?

Member 4:

1. Started with history of Pune

I will tell you 5 things - you just say two sentences about each of these things

2. Adil Shahi,Qutub Shahi,Imad Shahi (said can't recall at this point)

3. Was Shivaji Maharaj secular?

4. One more question about some ruler, whether he looted or it was his sovereign right...

5.Shivaji Maharaj's father - whose court ( I said I cannot recall exactly but as far as I can remember it was Adil Shah - he said you're absolutely right and everybody laughed at this point)

( At this point, all of them were looking at the clock and chairwoman was pointing out but member wanted to ask one more question)

6. Question about spy balloon - china and USA - what did India do in this case- what should we do?

Chairwoman

Referring to my previous answer - how can we find out whether it is enemy state or friendly state unless we shoot it and take it down(the baloon) - I said technology- she said you're a tech person , which technology,. Answered

Said okay, your interview is over.

Thank you, all the best.

Experience - Good. But couldn't make out panel's satisfaction or dissatisfaction.

Most questions had a context and monologue or were built on what I had answered previously.

Felt retrospectively, could've replied better to some questions.

Overall good experience.

Mocks - 6

Good - KSG, VajiraoR , Samkalp, UPSCPrep (most honest), Only IAS

Ok - EdSarrthi (online)

One to one - Ravindran sir , Khan sir (both excellent)

Overall tried to maintained calmness and composure till the end, questions were quite unexpected, none repeated from mocks as mocks focus mostly on DAF.