Interviews

UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 6 Mar 2023 (2)

6 Mar 2023

Date and session- 06/03/2023 Forenoon

Board- Lieutenant General Raj Shukla

Optional-philosophy

Profession- IRS(IT)

Hobbies-Photography

Chairman-

1. How is your hometown doing?

2. Is it really doing good or merely aspiring to do good? (Hometown is an aspirational district)?

3. How is your state doing. Is it developing under new government?

4. What’s your ambition as a civil servant?

5. Don’t you want to earn a lot of wealth?

6. What do you think about those people who are making a lot of money?

7. Very long discussion on Ukraine war (questions were in form of lengthy monologues and involving multiple divergent threads and at times it was difficult to grasp the central question and to frame answer) – Roughly they revolved around-

A) What’s core reason of conflict? Will China do same in Taiwan?

B) Why is West this time so bothered unlike in past?

C) What’s the solution?

D) Had Ukraine been a nuclear power, Putin would have dared even then or not?

E) What assurance Putin and Zelensky can give to each other to stop conflict?

F) CIA reports say China is supplying lethal weapons to Russia. Do you think West will do same and things will worsen even further?

G) Will it become a nuclear conflict?

H) Do you think only NATO membership is the reason. What can be alternative then? And let’s suppose Ukraine promises not to join NATO and Russia again indulges in such aggression. Who will help Ukraine in future?

I) You talked about US-Japan security alliance. Why only US, why not Europe can come forward and take such responsibility in case of Ukraine?

Member 1-

1. You are civil servant working in field. Tell me some challenges which a civil servant faces.

2. What you are talking about is challenges at micro level. Tell me challenges at macro level.

3. How informal sector of economy can be brought to taxation?

4. How is your department managing such a huge database. Is private sector also involved?

Member 2-

1. So many wealthy people not file any return. How they can be brought to tax?

2. IS department Doing anything in this regard? What is your proposal if I make you the Chief Commissioner of Income Tax?

3. How many govt servants pay income tax. Can you tell me numbers?

4. I have visited your hometown almost 30 years back. How has it changed since then (asked about some particular flyover etc)?

5. What are changes seen in your district because of Aspirational Distt program?

6. Have you read todays newspaper. Which headlines touched you the most?

7. Is China’s reaction on recent quad meeting over hyped and too offensive?

Member 3-

1. Your name is quite unique. Pls tell me its meaning.

2. Why you took philosophy as an optional despite being a B.Tech graduate?

3. It seems decision was strategic then. Who is your favorite philosopher.

4. By any chance, do you know about Yoga Vasishta (Followed from Shankar’s Advaita in previous response)?

5. One must have some philosophy in life. What’s your philosophy of life?

6. Tell me some particular examples how reading philosophy has shaped you and impacted you while discharging your duty as a Bureaucrat?

7. Today when science has made such a tremendous progress and almost answered all human queries. Why do you think that such subject like philosophy and other social sciences even needed?

8. Which is your favorite newspaper? Have you read anything about Supreme court recently? What is this NJAC. Why struck down? What is collegium system?

9. Why SC is so peculiar about its independence from executive?

10. What is motto of G20? How India is living up to the spirit of that motto of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam?

11. Tell me something about your photography. What you like to photograph? What’s your recent work?

Member 4

1. I was listening your answers to questions of other members. You told that Faceless assessment scheme is successful? What’s your basis of such claim?

2. What about individual taxpayers. Does your department think only about big corporate houses?

3. Why your department sends wrong notices to wrong people? What’s your view on such wrong notices and mental harassment to taxpayers?

4.

In one of your answers, you mentioned that China defied ICJ ruling in South China sea against Phillipines? Are your sure it was ICJ? (I apologized and said I stand corrected as it was Tribunal of UNCLOS)

5. Ok. Let us suppose all countries like China start defying UN decisions, ICJ rulings etc. Then what’s the solution and what’s the utility of such international bodies?

6. Suppose you make something novel in the field in which you have engineering degree. How will you market it?

7. What is IPR. Enlist the names of all its types. (Followed from previous response)