Interviews

UPSC interview, R. N. Choubey board, 7 Mar 2023 (Sociology)

7 Mar 2023

Date: 07th March 2023

Forenoon session

Shri R. N. Choubey Board

First one to go.

Chairperson: You can take a seat and relax. We are just going to have a natural conversation. If you don’t know anything, don’t hesitate to let us know. We don’t expect you to know everything and that’s not even humanly possible. If you don’t have any covid related symptoms you can remove your mask.

-Tell us about your educational qualifications and work experience.

-Can you tell us about any major govt scheme or initiative in health sector?

-Who all are covered in the Ayushman Bharat scheme?

-This year’s budget allocation to the scheme.

-Suppose you are the health minister and madam finance minister call you before announcing the budget and asks you for the allocation under the scheme. What would you do?

-Give funds to the private hospitals to facilitate the healthcare under the Ayushman Bharat mission, or

-Allocate the funds to develop primary healthcare infrastructure.

-Talked about suboptimal allocation, where if you split up the resources none of the concerned sectors gain benefit. So you have to choose one to allocate.

-If you ask a common man on ground if he wants to go to the government primary health centre or a private hospital, what would he choose?

-Now if you still choose contrary to what the people want, how will you convince the PM then? We are a democracy after all and there are elections every 5 years.

- Why would the common man be convinced by your arguments. They will say that every govt gives us these big promises, yet nothing changes on ground. Just give us the Ayushman Bharat card and we will go to the private hospital. How will you tackle that?

-How to resolve this dilemma of long term public interest vs the instant political gratification?

Member 1:

-Collegium vs NJAC issue and which side are you on?

-Why was the judiciary against it?

-Do you think the current system is fair?

-What changes should be brought in the process of judicial appointments?

-There are a lot of talks about UCC. Do you think it should be implemented? (Which side are you on)

-Why even after so many years, there is no progress on it?

-Do you know of any state which has it in place?

Member 2:

-Stubble burning is such a big contributor in Delhi pollution. Stubble is also used as a fodder for animals. Then why this prevalence of stubble burning?

-What steps have been taken by the government to tackle this issue?

-Is GobarDhan scheme going to help in this?

-Is there some financial component involved in it for the farmers?

Member 3:

-I would like your comment on India’s foreign policy.

-We are close to Russia, we have good relations with Ukraine. They both are at war. What is our stand on it? Give me an assessment of that.

-Is Russia listening to us?

-Why are we hosting the G20 summit?

-What does India stand to gain out of it?

-Is it not pushing China and Pakistan even closer?

Member 4:

-Suppose you are posted in the social justice department and you have to formulate a policy on street children. What would be the aims and objectives of that policy?

-You have a particular amount of fund for this. What would you choose?

-Make infrastructure for government run shelter homes, or

-Give funds to NGOs to run shelter homes.

-Won’t NGOs perform well on such social initiatives?

-There are several services constituted by the government, one of which you yourself are a part of. The govt handles a huge amount of funds. There are some checks by CAG, ECI etc on that. However, don’t you think we should have a specialised service for accountability?

-All the members of these bodies ultimately look up to the govt for their future assignments. Would having an independent body help in such a situation?

-Which system of recruitment is better?

-The UPSC like independent body recommending the candidates, or

-The earlier discussed NJAC or collegium system one.

-What would you choose to be?

-The smartest person in the room, or

-The most hardworking one.

-Why? What are the reasons for that?

Chairperson: Your interview is over. We had a great time talking with you. Do you want to tell us something more? We give this opportunity to every candidate. So if you have anything you want to talk to us about other than what we have discussed, you can tell us.

Overall, the panel was very cordial and engaging. The interview felt as if it revolved around the theme of would you rather :P It was diametrically opposite to my last interview where the discussion revolved around my DAF mostly. This time nothing from DAF was asked.

Date of interview - 7th March

Board : Shukla sir

Optional: sociology

College : DU BTech Comp sc

Profession : IIS (OT)

Hobbies: Hindustani classical (vocal) , Best out of Waste Art

Chairman

1) what are you doing nowdays

2)where are you posted nowdays

3) what is strategic communication

4) do you believe in the idea of vishwaguru

5) what is information deception

6) is china hiding information , stealing tech for its growth..etc

Member 1

1) what do you do in best out of waste

2) can you give successful eg of Delhi's waste management policy

3) on one side you are Btech in CS learning C++ etc on other side you do shloka uccharan . How to reconcile the two

4) importance of proper uccharan

5) can you recite a shloka

6) can you tell me any 3 centrally sponsored schemes

7) are they only on papers or can we see them on ground

Member 2

1) difference and similarities between western music and hindustani classical music

2) why sociology as optional

3) positive and negative impacts of social media

4) how is social media helping in governance

5) what is Article 352

Member 3

1) what is basic structure ? Can it be amended? Why should it be amended

2) what is complete justice? Do HC have the powers under constitution to do complete justice ?

3) provisions under which judges can be impeached

Member 4

1) 3 eg social changes from diff diff social institutions

2) e waste. Issues , steps to be taken

3) 3 benefits you are geyting from Delhi's local bodies

4) water and electricity subsidy related ques

5) There is a special event that takes place on 8th march..what is that? suppose you are invited as guest speaker for one the events and you have to discuss about the status of women empowement in India in 2 lines. Is it happening or not? How will you do ? What will you say.

Chairman:

Your interview is over .All the best.

Could have missed few ques . All in all this was it . Board was cordial and questions were DAF based with few static ques from polity.

Mock interview experience : Chahal, vajirao and reddy , chanakya mandal were good

All the best guys. Stay calm and just be yourself because you are amazing 💫

Panel- Raj Shukla Sir

Date- 06.03.2023, forenoon session

Homestate- Delhi, (Law optional)

Chairman-

What is your ambition in joining civil services?

The collegium issue- whats the tussle between government and judiciary

Whats the issue between legislature and judiciary- Israel attempt to overrule judiciary

What is more important- justice or law?

Are the laws on ADR sufficient?

M1

Difference between lawyer and advocate

What is judicial review

Death penalty and its desirability ( DAF based)

Justice delayed is justice denied- Issue of pendency of cases

How is the press regulated today?

M2

What is jamna paar? Why is it called so? Is it right to call it that ( East Delhi district)

What are millets? International year of millets significance

What news article did you read today?

What is ADR? Is it successful? What is the law on ADR?

M3

What is the problem that arises due to increased education of women ( incomprehensible question)

What is the lacunae in law for working women?

How smart is your jamna paar?

A bureaucrat joined work within 10 days of her delivery- is it a wise choice?

M4

Why civil services if you could have done so well in your existing career?

Trace the history of ADR in India?

In the great indian epics where do you see ADR being used?

Difference between mediation and conciliation?

Overall experience- Average- all members had a neutral face, no attempt at encouragement/ motivation.

Utility of mocks- good practice but answering in the actual interview is a different experience due to the serious environment. (useful to seek clarification in questions)

Date and session of interview- 2nd March

Board- Smita Nagraj

Optional- pub ad

chairman:

what are you doing these days?

have you had fight with your friends in school, college? (i said i had fights with siblings)

how those fights are settled?

why can’t water sharing disputes be solved?

what are the states that are having dispute over land boundaries ? why there are land disputes and ways to settle?

like the elder one among siblings had to be accommodative, why larger states always have to be accommodative ?

should India be accommodative to pakistan as india is bigger state?

we are spending so much for security and armed forces in kashmir, do you think kashmir issue will be solved?

member 1:

why did you choose public administration for masters?

what did you learn from public administration about what a civil servant should be doing?

what is the smallest unit of administration? and different levels of administration?

how many gram panchayats, mandals and districts in India and andhra?

don’t you think any one of those three levels should be removed because of complexity and overlaps?

tell about unique system of village administration in andhra pradesh?

how village secretariat system different from other states? give example

how is village administration in Telangana ?

do you thing this model of secretariat system be implemented in all states?

member 2:

how do you ensure good service delivery to people?

what is e-governance? tell about good and bad examples of it?

what is frbm ? why do we need it? what is the target ? did we achieved it?

what is fiscal deficit?

what is loose monetary policy and contractionary monetary policy?

what is repo rate? what happens if we reduce?

what are the countries we are importing oil from?

How can we reduce these oil imports ?

member3:

what is the architecture style of Victoria memorial in Kolkata ?

multiple questions about the short film i made

tell about the process of filmmaking.

why are more workers and labourers working in Hyderabad are from coastal andhra?

don’t you think it is about attitude of people towards work , where Telangana people are more laid back unlike andhra?

member 4:

what is NSS? what works are done in it? what can a student learn from NSS? Did you make any significant changes to the villagers?

MGNREGA is a waste on expenditure of government ? isn’t it ?

any structures built in your village by MGNREGA?

problems in NREGA regarding attendance ? any problems regarding payments?

your interview is over, Thank you

SOMP STUDENT TRANSCRIPT

👇👇👇👇👇👇

Name: Incognito

Date: 27th Feb

Board: Choubey sir

Optional: Nothing asked

DAF: B. Tech Marine, UGC NET JRF

Time: ~25 mins

Chairperson:

Introduce yourself with educational qualifications & experience

What is the international law that governs the oceans?

Should we scrap Rajya Sabha and State Legislative Councils?...follow up Qs

Should we adopt Presidential democracy?...follow up Qs

M1 (Male):

What could have been the benefits of farm laws?

Contract farming?

Why were these laws opposed?

Did the farm laws need wider consultation?

Challenges due to urbanisation?

M2 (Male):

Difference b/w EEZ & continental shelf?

Extent on India's continental shelf?

Opinion on free electricity for farmers

Unable to recall other Qs

M3(Female):

What is the concept of smart cities?

What are the 4 pillars of smart cities?

Effective utilisation of ICT?

What are smart sensors?

How can chatbots be used to improve our infrastructure?

M4(Female):

What are the functions of UGC?

What research have you done?

Thoughts on recent decision to allow pursuing two degrees simultaneously

SWAYAM portal and some other portal

NIRF ranking

NAAC accreditation

How to reduce import dependence for edible oil & pulses?

Chairperson:

We have asked what we wanted to ask. Do you want us to ask on any topic or want to share anything?