UPSC interview, Lt Gen Raj Shukla board, 7 Mar 2023
7 Mar 2023
Name : psm0506
Date : 07/03/2023
Forenoon Session, Second Last to go
Board : Lt. Gen. Shukla Sir
Medium of Interview: English
College : B. Tech, IIT Delhi (2020)
Optional : Physics
Native : Katihar, Bihar
Attempts: 2nd, 1st mains and interview
Work Experience :
Research Internship in University of Sydney, Australia
Research Internship in University of Groningen, Netherlands
Selected for a weeklong conference in Harvard University, Boston, USA
Hobbies : Exploring new cities and cuisines, dancing in contemporary style, following cricket statistics
Achievements : 1st Prize in Inter-College Thematic Dance Competition at Rendezvous, IIT Delhi, 3rd Prize at Mood Indigo, IIT Bombay
Other Activities : NSS Member in College, Played Cricket at University Level
Chirperson:
1. Any work experience? No. Internships only.
2. Have you heard “ When it was the time to strike, it bend down? It was in the context of emergency. Ans: Sorry sir, I am not able to relate.
3. Have you heard “Speak Truth to power”? He gave a context of Russian generals giving Putin advice that the war would be over in 72 hours but the war is still waging. How can we imbibe this in our framework? Ans : Agreed to it. Gave reference to vip culture, following ideals of law and constitution, reforms in executive and legislature.
4. Aginpath Scheme : Salient features, Pros, Cons, why opposition, what’s there for rest 75%. I said entrepreneurship with Seva nidhi, retirement at 25 : Young age to pursue higher education. Then he asked about the reservations given in govt job and hence the pension would shift to other departments. I gave reference to NPS. He cited opinion on OPS in several states. I told them its not fiscally viable. Discussion about changing warfare and the need for people.
5. Are you in support of farm laws? Largely yes. Even experts are of the same opinion. Did we fail to convey properly about the benefits of the farm laws and agnipath? No for agnipath, but apprehension were there mainly for job security. However in case of farm laws, it was not conveyed properly, bills not referred to parliamentary committee and in the rajya sabha it was passed amidst the din. Large stakeholder consultation was missing while led to protests.
M1(Lady):
1. You are from Bihar. Tell me major rivers of Bihar.
2. Namani gange. Not aware of the specifics, but aimed at cleaning Ganga river. Why we need to clean : BOD, industrial and donestic waste etc hampering biodiversity and human life. Can we clean it. Gave examples of Rhine and Thames (Once biologically dead). Time and resources needed.
3. SDG related to women.
4. Tomorrow is a special day. Women’s day. Reasons for celebration. How to ensure gender equality.
5. You are from IIT Delhi. Such a prestigious institute. If we are to make new institutions like that, what do we need to do? Innovative teaching, focus on research, foreign faculty and students, gender inclusive infrastructure,etc
6. Your hobby is exploring new cities and cuisines. What was the last city you visited? Tell me differences between New York and Delhi.
M2 :
1. Tell me something about Katihar.
2. You talked about floods. What is the district administration doing to curb floods? I told them focus has been more on adaptation and not mitigation, which needs to be focussed upon majorly.
3. Performance of centrally sponsored schemes in Katihar. Told them about Pm poshan and PM JAY and said sorry I need to read more on that.
4. Which newspaper do you read? Indian Express. Favourite column. I told them C rajamohan’s. He asked me about the page. I told them editorial page. He told me that even he reads IE and his favourite page is explained. I told him yes sir that is also very informative. Why editorial page? Gives different perspectives of an issue which helps us build out opinions better.
5. What was there in yesterday editorial? Your favourite. I told them on CEC and ECs appointment methodology. Do you support that. I said that I am largely in favour.
He tried to ask more on this but the chairperson asked him to stop (Climax abhi baaki hai)
M3:
1. Why Civil Services
2. Difference between FR and DPSP
3. How to develop scientific temper in the society using Physics. Told them to encourage it, make learning more interesting, more competitions on physics, encouraging non physics people to study about it, etc.
4. What is Chatgpt? Good or bad. Told both pros and cons.
5. Children and technology. Told him to minimise usage restricted to learning. Focus more on sports, training, and other physical activities, etc.
M4: (Grilling pro max)
1. What is basic structure? Components. Separation of powers?
2. NJAC and why was it struck down.
3. Go back to M2. 😈 You just supported SC decision,which is against SOP. Yes sir it is against SOP. But the parliament has not followed the constitutional mandate of making a law for appointments. I feel that ECI has been following the mandate of free and fair elections. But justice should be seen to be done also. As the ruling party has a stake in electoral process as well.
4. Need for CJI being in the panel. Agreed that he may or may not have been a part. And it is a temporary provision as the SC has directed the parliament to make a law for the same. And the CJI has no vested interest either ruling parties or opposition.
5. The parliament may come up with a law and remove the CJI, LoP and place executive members in the panel. What would the SC do then? I told that I don’t have the legal expertise but its possible that SC may strike it down.
6. Do you mean to say that we have been violating our basic structure in the past 70 odd years. I said that we have had fair electoral practices and this is to counter possible misuse. I told them sir this is a very hard question and I need to read more on this to have a better opinion.
Chairperson: Your interview is over.
Overall Assessment: 30-35 minutes long. Cordial board but dull faces of 3 persons. Ma’am was very cheerful.
Utility of Mocks : very close (90%) to Samkalp and Next IAS and to a large extent (60%) Unacademy and Shankar IAS.