Interviews

UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 11 May 2022 (Kerala)

11 May 2022

Date: 11-05-2022

Board: Manoj Soni

Optional: PSIR

IRAS (2019 Batch)

Home state: Kerala

Hobbies: Writing poetry and short fiction, reading fiction in magical realism, watching cricket.

Disclaimer: please don't consider the text to be verbatim.

3rd to go in the forenoon session.

I went in. Chairman asked me to please take my seat after I had completed wishing the board. Chairman reads out my name and asks if he is pronouncing it right. I say yes. He also confirms my first name. I was then asked to take off my face mask and shield for verification. He compares my face with the photograph that I had provided and brought up some difference with regard to a scar/mole on the right side of my face which seemed prominent in the photo but absent on my face. A minute or two went by trying to find this scar until the chairman, lady member on the panel and I came to a conclusion that it might have been a temporary bruise or something.

I was told that the face mask was compulsory but the face shield was optional. Hence I attended the interview without my face shield.

Chairman:

- So we have a poet among our midst.

(I reply 'an amateur poet sir')

- A poet is a poet nonetheless. Do you have to have a specific reason that triggers you to write? How does it work?

- So you are in service already. IRAS. I see that you were alloted the service after the 2019 exam but joined quite late.

(I explain about being on Extraordinary Leave for a year and then joining training in January 2022)

- So what all parts of your training have you completed?

- Would you consider yourself as a person with a lot of inner strength, strong values? Are you a person who holds on your opinions no matter what?

- What if your superior gives you a task where you have to do something that is totally against your value system? What if you have a good understanding about this topic and feel that what the superior is saying is not the way to do things?

- What if it was a scenario where you have to draft a cabinet note?

- What if it was completely against your values and conscience? Will you do the job or recuse yourself?

(During the course of answering one of the previous qns I mentioned about putting down my advice in writing in the file)

- So you are in Hyderabad now as part of your training. Have you visited some of the famous places there? Like Hussain Sagar, Golconda Fort, Char Minar?

(I respond saying that of the places mentioned I've been only to the Char Minar upto now and that I've passed by the Hussain Sagar while going in the bus to the Char Minar)

- But you've been in Hyderabad for so long, since January and you haven't visited the other places?

(I mention that during the initial 3.5 months of my training I was at Vadodara and that I've been in Hyderabad only for the past 1.5 months. Chairman says ok.)

Member 1 (Lady Member):

- You are from the state of kerala. What is your opinion about the Sabarimala verdict? State authorities faced many difficulties in implementing the judgement.

- You said about reforms. Do you think that is a word that is getting misused today?

- Do you think we should have privatisation of the railways? What areas can be privatised? What are your thoughts on that?

- During the past few years what are some of the major contributions made by the railways?

Member 2:

- In the railways we are now going to implement a merger of services. What are your thoughts on this?

- But then now there is not going to be recruitment of engineers. Can you become an S&T engineer? Then what will be the future?

- If you were dealing with the IRMS file would you put down your advice in writing against such a merger of services?

- Should we look at the issue of ticket fares in railways and shouldn't there be some kind of an increase? What should be done here?

- What is magical realism?