Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 21 May 2022

21 May 2022

Board - Smita Nagraj

Chairperson: 1. so what have u been doing since 2019?

2. You chose law to help you in civil services?

3. What other reasons for taking law as graduation?

4. Security issues in Punjab?

5. Is it as grave as 1980s?

6. Way out to use the energy of unemployed youth, how to make agri remunerative?

7. Should we move out of wheat rice cycle

8. Last question: why wheat export banned recently?

9. How price rise in world has affected it?

M1:

1. You know KPS Gill? Tell his contribution, good / bad?

2. Why killings/attack of police and persons in punjab even after 1990s, to till date?

3. Any Role of SFJ in election funding?-Chairperson interrupted and said no political questions here. Pls change the question.

4. Do u know about Assamese Sikhs? Also why were they in news.(he permitted me to talk about Shillong Sikhs)

5. As DGP of Punjab or as civil servant how to deal drugs and security issues along with making youth productive?

Member 3

1. Why is your district called so? What does it mean?(I told her entire history, she said i wanted to know just the meaning in urdu)- there was some hindi song starting with this name, she was about to recall it; chairperson interrupted to ask next question.

2. Muslim population in your district?

3. When was your city made district, not originally,right?

4. What about Malerkotla? Muslim population?

5. How far is your district from border?

6. Is border fenced?

7. U wrote about criminal justice system, tell me what was the synopsis of ur paper?

8. Have you heard of latest judgement of 2 judges with different views?

9. Which section of IPC, which exception and what reasons were given?

M3-

1. Lets talk about international Law, what it is?

2. But don’t u think it doesn’t exist? It just depends upon treaty parties.

3. How international Law is applicable to countries which donot sign treaties?

4. Lets talk about about PMLA, tell what it is about?

5. Any specific term used for PMLA, do u know?

6. U said law will help you in services, how?

7. What is cooperative federalism, do u see it in India?

M4

1. Why caste system came into Sikhism, which was religion based on equality?

2. caste system in other religion? I started talking about hinduism, he said not that, tell me about Christians?

3. What is remedy for dispute bw govt and private party in case of contracts?

4. Tell me about other clauses in agreement, i told about arbitration, he asked about related act?which year law?

5. Has Arbitration and conciliation act 1996 ever been amended?

6. Which courts take appeal against Arbitration?

7. Tell me about Data protection law?

M2 interrupted while M4 was asking 1,2 questions. Chairperson asked her to ask after m4 finishes; so M4 asked me closing questions and not the chairperson.

M2-which state has highest population of SC? I told percentage wise.

She said why Punjab, when sikhism is against caste sytem; basically she repeated m4’s question.

Chairperson smiled and said thank you. I didn’t get up, was smiling looking into her eyes. She said your interview is over, i smiled again and said thank you.

I Walked out of room thinking number of things in my mind.