UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 18 May 2022 (Kerala…)
18 May 2022
18/05/2022 CSE Interview
Name- Will disclose if and when I figure in the holy pdf.
Date and session of interview- 18.05.2022, Afternoon
Board- Smita Nagraj
Optional- Anthropology
College- ek IIT
Profession (if any)- Railway Service
Hobbies- Playing Chess and Reading.
Home state - Bihar
Only 3 + 1 panel.
Chairperson
1. You are working in Kolkata. There is lot of trade unionism there. Is it so? Have you felt so?
2. What should be the quality of the persons who should be appointed to deal with the unions ?
3. Should corrupt people be allowed ?
4. Will you allow people who are coming half an hour late and leaving two hours early ?
5. Will you allow those who violate the law ?
6. Industrial development in Kerala and WB has reduced. Do you think trade unionism is the reason?
7. Industrial codes have been enacted. What kind of industrial policy should be there? Hire and fire and give too much power to industrialists?
M 1
1. You have played football. Why is football less popular in Britain as compared to other nations in Europe? In other places it is very popular but it is not as much in Britain.
2. Do you know about NEC? North East Council ?
3. What is its role?
4. Has it performed ?
5. Reforms to improve it.
6. Look East and Act East policy. What are these ?
7. When and why was the word secular introduced in the Preamble to the Constitution?
8. Riots have happened after the introduction of the word secular also. So, why was the word introduced in particular by the 42nd Amendment act?
9. One last question. What is the basic structure of the constitution?
M 2
1. What is the role of a loco pilot in Railways?
2. I will give you a case. Suppose a train accident occurs and 7 people are killed. Signal has been breached. A committee is formed and the committee puts the whole burden on the loco pilot. He is removed from service. He goes to the court and the action is quashed. He returns to his job and no one is punished. People have died. What would you have done differently? Many cross questions on this.
3. Do you watch movies? When was the last time you watched a movie? What is its name?
4. Have you seen runway 32/34 or 36 or a name like that? This movie has a similar story.
5. There are a lot of court cases in Indian Railways. You may say that since it is the largest employer, there are so many court cases. That is true. Indian Railways is one of the largest employers. Do you know which is the largest employer in India?
6. Ok, not the Army, let us talk about the civil side. From the civillian side which is the largest employer? The dept of posts has large manpower.
So, why are there so many court cases in Railways? Is it that Railway employees are peculiar or there are issues with the grievance redressal machinery or some things else ?
M 3
1. You play chess and watch chess videos. Name two Indian chess players.
2. How do you become a Grandmaster ?
3. How did you work during the covid lockdown ?
4. Did you use e-office ?
5. How do you access e-office from home ? So, was VPN used to establish a secure connection ?
6. Do u know about UMID ?
7. Has it been completed by your Railway ? For both serving and retired employees ?
8. What are you doing for retired employees' registration ?
9. Do you know about HMIS (hospital) in Railways ? What is your zone's position ?
10. Large number of people from Bihar have migrated to Assam and other N-E states for work. Your optional is Anthropology. Is it a recent or an old phenomenon ?
11. A political strategist from Bihar is in news these days. Do you know him ?
12. Large number of people had migrated from big cities to villages during covid lockdown. What steps were taken by govt for those people ?
13. Do u know the name of the portal for registration of unorganised workers ?
14. what is e-shram ?
Chairperson - Thank you.
Your experience in interview- It was slightly stressful with substantial cross questioning.
Utility of mocks (if any)- I appeared in two mocks - NextIAS and KSG. Both told me to speak a bit louder. I followed this advice.
One question from NextIAS mock was repeated in the interview.
KSG mock had very difficult questions many of whose answers I didn't have and feedback had a lot of advice. I didn't follow any apart from the one related to speaking loudly.
Name – Anwar Farrukhabadi
Date and session of interview- 18 May, Evening (2nd to go).
Board- Sathiyavathy Ma’am
State- Uttar Pradesh
Optional- Sociology
College- B. Com (Hansraj College), MA Sociology (JNU)
Hobbies- Watching Lawn Tennis, Mentoring
Chairperson –
• Read aloud most of the DAF.
• Then said “Define hobby”. What is hobby for you.
• Do you watch female lawn tennis matches? Do you know the controversy related to “Naomi Osaka”? Why was she banned from a famous tournament? Should a sportsperson be compelled to attend pre and post-match conference?
• Tell me chronologically all important lawn tennis tournaments. Differentiate between the courts of all grand slam tournament.
M1
• Why inflation is such an important parameter for judging Indian economy? How to control inflation?
• Issues of tribal people? Why are our tribal laws ineffective? How to make them effective?
• Sociologically differentiate between the tribes of central India and North-East India.
• What do you think, caste will ever fade away from Indian society? What’s your stand?
M2 (lady member)
• You did graduation in Commerce and Accountancy. But, you chose sociology as optional. Is it out of interest or was it a well thought of decision taking CSE exam into mind?
• What are the differences in the accounting of private enterprises and government? Should government have accrual basis of accounting? What problems government will face when they move to accrual basis? How to overcome them?
• Why joint families are breaking in Indian society?....one or two counter question
M3
• Exact same question was asked by him that previous panel member had already asked. Nevertheless, he framed the question in short sentence, “Why sociology and not commerce”?
• Should student union be there? What are the merits of a SU? Can you name a minister in current cabinet who was active in student politics? (Here he wanted to hear the name of honorable finance minister from JNU Nirmala Sitaraman that I told him after he gave a hint).
• Why conviction rate in Prevention of atrocities act so low? How to improve that?
• Name few Important Indian sociologists. Don’t you think Dipankar Gupta is more of an economist than a sociologist?
M4
• Who is known as “Father of Modern Sociology”?
• Apart from the thinkers mentioned in your syllabus, have you read any other study of a sociologist. What was the study of A.M. Shah and what was his proposition.
• Why rupee depreciating? How is this going to affect our economy? Is there any merit in depreciation of currency? So, that means currency should depreciate. I said No, he asked why so? Current account deficit, forex reserves, essential import items. Name few export products from India that have high export value.
(Forgot few questions)
THANK YOU.
Your experience in interview – Overall cordial board. Most of the questions were opinion based. Whenever I was not able to give appropriate answer. They guided me toward the answer, which they were expecting, from me. Only thing that I did not like was that mam did not allow us to remove mask (I was wearing specs).
Utility of mocks (if any) - Gave 7 mocks. Some of the questions were repeated in the actual interview. Mocks guided me in the selection and choice of appropriate words. Helped in sitting etiquettes and mannerism. Developed confidence to face the panel.
Recommended – Vajirao and Reddy, KSG, Chahal Academy, IAS hub
Date and session of interview- 19-05-2022 Forenoon (1st to go)
Board- Ms. M. Sathiyavathy
Education- B. Sc. (H) Mathematics
College- SSC (DU)
Optional- Mathematics
Profession (if any) - None
Hobbies; ECA- Watching Films; Participated in a project to teach underprivileged children
Your experience in interview- Cordial board, engaging conversation, mostly opinion based questions, 50% questions from DAF
Utility of mocks (if any)- Building confidence, improving articulation, learning etiquettes to talk to senior board members
Chairperson (lady):
1. You are only 22, what is your inspiration to join Civil services
2. Bureaucracy no longer commands that respect among common people. Do you agree? Is there lesser respect compared to the earlier times, in relative terms?
3. What is Vedic Maths? Can it be used to teach Math to children? Can it be used as the primary method of math teaching despite its inaccuracies at times?
3. What got you interested in Maths?
4. How will you make other students interested in Maths, who usually shy away from it?
M1 (gentleman):
1. Importance of Panchayati Raj institutions in governance
2. Why do they not enjoy adequate powers? Is it a breach of the Constitution? Are political executive and bureaucracy responsible for the lesser devolution of powers?
3. Do you know a developed country without a local government system?
4. MP has a lot of forest area. What's the role of biodiversity amid climate change?
5. Which communities help preserve it? Can we learn from them?
M2 (lady):
1. Since you've taught underprivileged children, tell me why educational schemes for such children by the government don't yield desired results? What are the deficiencies?
2. Is foundational literacy and numeracy lacking in children?
3. These days a lot of NGOs and other organisations impart education to children and the education system has become fragmented. How do you see the future? What role can technology play in it?
4. Would you say that online education has also spurred online gaming habits?
5. Should online gaming be regulated? Is any regulation being contemplated for online gaming, gambling, casinos etc? (That day's newspaper had an article on this)
M3 (gentleman):
1. What is INSPIRE Scholarship? (DAF)
2. What is KVPY? (NOT in DAF)
3. What are GoI's schemes for boosting Science and technology?
4. What has been their performance? Do they need any changes/improvements?
5. Despite rising patents, it's a fact that commercialisation of technology is slow. Enumerate what steps need to be taken?
M4 (gentleman):
1. Name the very famous personality born in Khandwa (Kishore Kumar). Name his brothers.
2. What's your favourite branch in Mathematics? Why?
3. Do you think people around us take decisions based on logic?
4. Is logical decision making the right thing to do?
5. Give me a theorem from that branch and explain it to me
6. One only does a lot of theorems in this branch. What is its utility?
7. How will you apply the knowledge of this branch in administration?
8. There's a movement going on in the US, having global implications. Do you know which one? (Could only think of Black Lives Matter as such a movement, but he wanted one subsequent to that. But then asked about BLM only)
9. Is any such discrimination rooted in Indian society also (not necessarily racial discrimination)
10. Reservations have been provided for decades. Is it good/yielding desired results? What should be done?
Chairperson:
Thank you (and nodded as a permission to leave)
[Can't recall a few questions here and there, mostly follow-ups on the above]
THANKS A LOT TO KAPTAAN JACK SPARROW AND HIS OTHER FRIENDS WHO COORDINATE TO HELP UPSC ASPIRANT COMMUNITY. THANK YOU SO MUCH.