UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 18 May 2022
18 May 2022
Name - Heisenberg
Date and session of interview- 18/05/2022 ; Forenoon
Board- Smita Nagraj Ma'am
Optional- Electrical Engineering
College- IIT Delhi
Profession (if any)- NA
Hobbies- Home Workouts, Football, Tennis, Self-Growth (Only the first one was touched)
Your experience in interview - Cordial board, but the expressions of the members were hard to decipher.
Utility of mocks (if any) - Certain mannerisms and the habit of structuring your answers became inbuilt; A few questions were repeated from the mocks.
NOTE : The conversation was not as fluent as it seems in this transcript. This is just a recollection of events in a grammatically coherent way.
Chairwoman :
1. What are you doing presently?
2. Where are you based since 2019 (graduation year)?
3. You have certain origins in Uttarakhand as well. We are hearing constantly about the infrastructural expansion in the state around Badrinath and Kedarnath. What is your opinion, should we stop it?
4. Just give me a yes or no. If a project is proven by a report that it is harmful, should it be scrapped?
5. (The Nagraj Bouncer)What would be the logistical concerns if we reduce the number of people that are allowed to visit these ecologically fragile zones?
6. That is not logistics. Let me clue you in. If less people are allowed in these areas, what would we do about the rest of the people who have been stopped from reaching there?
7. What is the one major issue, according to you, that Uttar Pradesh is facing? How will you fill this lacuna?
M1 :
1. So were you born in Uttarakhand? (No, Lucknow)
2. And then you moved to IIT Delhi for your graduation in EE. You have a good GPA. Can you tell me what do you notice when you see that air conditioner?
3. Is it a good rating or bad?
4. Okay. Are you aware of the inverter technology being used in ACs? (I answered in the negative)
5. What is an inverter technology in EE? Where is it used?
6. Yes, so what is its utility in air conditioners?
7. What is your opinion about Electric Vehicles? Are they going to benefit India ecologically if we are still using power generated via thermal power plants in the charging infrastructure?
8. Is it proven that BEVs have higher efficiency?
9. Will it be economically viable for India to go for BEVs?
M2 :
1. You have put Home Workouts as your hobby. What are the things that a person should be aware of while working out?
2. What are two major issues in the power sector according to you?
3. No but that is only a short-term issue. (coal shortage)
4. How are you going to resolve these issues?
5. What are the major issues being faced by State Electric Boards?
6. What are SERCs? What is their function?
M3 : (Was harder to decipher than Batman or Bane! With his mask on.)
1. Taking cue from the previous discussion, let's move from Electric Vehicles to Electric Locomotives. What is the present status of electrification?
2. Are you sure that the year is 2030? (Answered that I am not certain)
3. What is the commitment made by railways under the Panchamrita for 2030?
4. In an electric locomotive, how are the different utility equipments (fans, AC, lights) in coaches powered? Is there a specific instrument used for it? (Answered that I did not know the specifics)
5. What are the advantages of electric locomotives over diesel-oil locomotives?
6. Any more? Advantage with regards to speed of the locomotive? (Answered yes, but I do not have the facts to support it at this point)
M4 :
1. We are seeing 49 degrees in Delhi, floods in Assam and heavy rainfall in Kerala. What are these extreme events collectively called?
2. Define Climate Change.
3. What is the difference between Climate Change and Global Warming?
What is the reason for Global Warming?
4. There is perennial debate about environment protection and development. What should we choose, according to you?
5. In that case, if there is a negative EIA report for a project, what would you do? In the end it is just a report, will you scrap the project?