Interviews

UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 14 May 2022

14 May 2022

PT date - 09/05

Board - Manoj Soni sir

Optional - PSIR

Background - Btech Electrical Engineering from DTU

Hobbies - Astronomy and Jogging

Chairman : You can remove your face mask for the confirmation of the identity. Asked to wear it again. You can remove the face shield if you like.

Q1 - what did you do at forumias ? Why did you leave it after a year ?

Q2 - You are an electrical engineer, what is the electrical demand of India ? What is the installed capacity ?

Q3 - what are the different sources of energy ? Asked about the way electricity get produced in a thermal power station ,then nuclear energy power generation ? Asked if I could explain about other sources as well ?

Asked where are you more comfortable - electrical, political science and International relations. I told PSIR since I had read that recently, while studied electrical engineering during my graduation.

Q4 - what is energy security and energy independence ? What is the difference between the two?

M1 -

Q1 - what is the meaning of PPP? Which Prime Minister of India gave the idea of PPP?

Q2 - how many States in India ? And Union Territories ? Confirmed the two union territories formed from the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir ? Difference between lieutenant governor and governor ?

Q3 - what do we understand by common wealth nations? What is commonwealth ?

M2 (lady member)

Q1 - you have an interest in Astronomy , do you think by sending missions to moon,Mars etc. ISRO is wasting resources of the country ?

Q2 - is privatisation in space sector going to be detrimental to national security ? What should be done to deal with them?

Q3 - what do you understand by the term 'water wars'? Is India facing them?

Q4 - what is water security ? Is India facing it ? What should India do?

Q5 - you mentioned about inter linking of rivers , aren't there ecological issues associated with them ? What to do?

M3 :

Q1 - you talked about India using Indus water as part of water war to pressurise Pakistan. How can we do that given that Indus is just one river? ( Talked about the entire river system) where will this much water be diverted to? ( Can be diverted to water deficit regions in the states like Punjab, Haryana, rajasthan, UP, etc.)

You are an engineer, tell me how can we actually divert this much water ?

Q2 - why is night sky black? What about the incoming starlight ?

Q3 - You talked about PPP in Namami Gange project, what will the revenue model for STPs built through PPP ?

M4 :

Q1 - why is India providing so many benefits to Nepal ? What are the reasons other than the geographical reasons which make Nepal important for India ?

China is making inroads in Nepal too like in other countries like Sri Lanka. How can we prevent that ?

Q2 - Has India achieved 100% rural electrification ? Are all the households covered? By when do you think we will be able to cover all the households?

Q3 - In the context of Ukraine - Russia war and emerging situation, what should India do going forward ?

Chairman signalled this to be the last question.

Chairman - thank you. All the best. (Thanked chairman sir and the lady member )

Chairman asked to take away the face shield since I had forgotten about it.

Overall experience - cordial but a bit serious. No overtly generous and friendly remarks or smiles from the members. Mostly they maintained a serious poker face demeanor. Only once a member remarked good on an answer. There were some follow up questions but no grilling.

I did get a little nervous during the beginning but could manage it better later.

Utility of mocks - help in practicing and developing on the spot thinking and communicating.